Part I— Preliminaries – With the grace and mercy of God
Invitation to Ahmadiyyat, Part 6
It is quite true that we regard the Founder of the Ahmadiyya Community, Hadrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian, Gurdaspur, Punjab, India, as the Promised Messiah and Mahdi (as); however, when it has been established on the basis of the Holy
Qur’an and Hadith and logic that the Messiah has passed away, how can this belief be contrary to the Holy Qur’an and Hadith? When the death of the Messiah is established by the Holy Qur’an and there is even a Hadith in which the Holy Prophets (as) gives tiding of the coming of someone called Ibn Maryam, this clearly shows that the one whose advent has been promised will be an individual from within this ummah, and not the self-same Jesus of Nazareth who passed away.
They also argue that even if the death of the Messiah is established in the light of the Holy Qur’an and Hadith, we should still believe in his second coming because some Traditions give the tiding of the return of Ibn Maryam. Is God not powerful enough, they ask, to resurrect the Messiah and send him back for the reformation of the world? They thereby imply that we are denying God’s Omnipotence. The truth is quite to the contrary. It is not because we deny God’s Omnipotence but because we affirm God’s Omnipotence that we believe that God will not resurrect the Messiah of Nazareth and send him back to the world, and that He has instead sent an individual from this very ummah as the Promised Messiah (as). We do not believe that anyone who carefully ponders over this matter will accept that resurrecting the Messiah and sending him back to the world is a sign of God’s Omnipotence. Even in this world, we see that an affluent person does not have an old garment turned for new use. It is the poor and needy who have their old garments turned and altered to be used again and again. Since when has God become so constrained that, when His servants require direction and guidance, He has to resurrect and bring back a dead Prophet from the past? The fact is that, in order to reform a people, He chooses someone from among themselves to bring about their reformation. There is not a single instance, from the time of Adam down to the Holy Prophets (as), whereby God resurrected and returned an old Prophet for the guidance of mankind. This could only happen if it were accepted that God no longer has the power to cleanse and purify the people of this age, which is impossible. It is equally impossible that a dead Prophet should be taken out of Paradise and brought back for the reformation of the world. God is All-Powerful. If, after the Messiah, He could create a man like the Holy Prophets (as), it is surely not beyond his capacity to create someone like the Messiah or even better than him in this age.
We, therefore, reject the concept of the Messiah’s return to the world, not because we think that God does not have the power to bring this about but because we believe God has the power to choose and ordain any of His servants to bring lost souls back to the right path. Those who think that He cannot do this and has no choice but to bring back a past Prophet at a time of need are mistaken.
The concept of the second coming of the old Messiah does not only put a question mark on God’s omnipotence, but it also casts doubt on the spiritual power of the Holy Prophets (as). To say that the Messiah will return to the world for a second time means that God would be constrained to bring back an old Prophet because there would be no one among the followers of the Holy Prophets (as) with the capacity to bring about a transformation. This would be in contrast to past Prophets for whose followers God sent Reformers from among themselves. If we were to accept this notion, we would be no less of an enemy to the Holy Prophets (as) than are the Christians and Jews who question his spiritual status. When a candle is lit, it can light other candles; it is only a dead candle that cannot light another. Therefore, if there comes a time when the ummah of the Holy Prophets (as) has gone so far astray that no one from within it can stand up for its reformation, it would mean that the Holy Prophet’s spiritual influence has come to an end—God forbid! Every Muslim knows that, for as long as God wished the Mosaic dispensation to continue, there appeared within it people who followed in the footsteps of Moses and undertook the task of reformation. However, as soon as He desired to bring that dispensation to an end, He ceased sending Prophets from among the followers of Moses and instead sent a Prophet from among the progeny of Ishmael. Thus, if there were to appear an Israelite Prophet after the Holy Prophets (as), it would mean that God wants to put an end to the dispensation of the Holy Prophets (as) and start a new one—God forbid! It would also mean that the Holy Prophet’s spiritual power has become so weak that it can no longer inspire even a single one of his followers to receive spiritual light from him and bring guidance to his people.
It is a pity that while people express such indignation when their own honour is at stake and do not tolerate any defect being attributed to their own selves, they so daringly attribute every kind of flaw to the Holy Prophets (as). What is the use of love that is limited to verbal professions and finds no echo in the heart? Of what avail is the passion that fails in the demonstration? If they really loved the Holy Prophets (as), they wouldn’t for a moment tolerate the idea that an ancient Israelite Prophet will come to reform his ummah. Does any self-respecting person beg from another while he himself has adequate provisions, or call another for help while he is himself able and strong? The same mullahs who teach that the Messiah of Nazareth will come to save the Holy Prophet’s ummah from its tribulations are so conscious of their own honour and self-esteem that even when they are losing in a debate they consider it derogatory to admit defeat by asking help from another. In fact, if someone volunteers to help them out, instead of being grateful to him, they feel hurt and say, ‘Am I ignorant that you are putting words in my mouth!’ But when it comes to the Holy Prophets (as), they so easily say that a Prophet from another dispensation will be called to help him and that his own spiritual power cannot accomplish what is required. Alas! Are their hearts dead or have they lost all their senses? Do they reserve all honour for themselves and leave nothing for God and His Prophet? Is all their fury spent on their own enemies and none is left for those who attack God and His Prophet?
We are asked why we deny the return of an old Israelite prophet. The fact is that we do not have a choice in this matter. We cannot change our hearts and wipe off all traces of our love for the Holy Prophets (as) whose honour is dearest to us. Not for a moment can we believe that the Holy Prophets (as) should be beholden to someone else. Nor for a minute can we bear to think that, on the Day of Resurrection, when all of mankind will be assembled in the presence of God and the deeds of each one will be read out, the Holy Prophets (as) would stand burdened by the debt he owed to the Israelite Messiah, and angels would relate how, when the Holy Prophet’s spiritual power started to wane, it was the Israelite Messiah who had done him a favour by coming out of Paradise and returning to the world to reform his people and saving them from annihilation. We cannot even contemplate such a thought. We would rather have our tongues torn out than attribute such a denigrating proposition to the Holy Prophets (as). We would rather lose our hands than write such words about hims (as). The Holy Prophets (as) is the beloved of God and his spiritual power can never wane. He is the Seal of the Prophets and his spiritual grace and munificence can never fail. He can never be indebted to anyone, while all other Prophets are indebted to him. There is not a Prophet who made deniers of the Holy Prophets (as) believe in him, but there are millions to whom the Holy Prophets (as) has testified regarding the truth of all the other Prophets. There are said to be about eighty million Muslims in India. Some came from other lands but the rest are all indigenous and were not even aware of the names of any Prophets. Then, after accepting the Holy Prophets (as), they came to believe in Abraham, Moses, Jesus, and many others prophets (peace be on them).
If they had not become Muslims, they would still be hostile to those Prophets and see them as impostors, just as their Hindu brothers do even to this day. The same is true of the people of Afghanistan, China and Iran, who never believed in Moses or Jesus and it was the Holy Prophets (as) who apprised them of the truth of these Prophets. The Holy Prophets (as) has thus done all those Prophets a favour by revealing their truth to mankind. He himself is indebted to no one, and may the day never dawn when his spiritual power declines and someone from another dispensation is required to reform his ummah. The fact is that whenever there is a need for the reformation of this ummah, God chooses people from among the followers of the Holy Prophet who, having received and learned everything from him, reform those who have been corrupted and bring back to the right path those who have gone astray. Their mission is the mission of the Holy Prophets (as), for the pupil cannot be separate from his teacher and the disciple cannot be distinct from his Prophet. They are indebted to his munificence and their hearts and minds are inebriated with the wine of his love. To say that an ancient Prophet will come after him would be an insult to the Holy Prophets (as) and contrary to the status which Allah has granted him, as He says:
Allah does not take away a blessing after having bestowed
it on a people unless some vice develops among them.
Now, by accepting this belief, one has to either accept that there has been some change in the status of the Holy Prophets (as) (God forbid), or that God has broken His promise. Both these notions are heretical, as one amounts to the denial of God and the other to the denial of the Holy Prophets (as). This is why we find these beliefs so unacceptable. We believe that the Messiah whose advent had been promised was to appear from within this ummah and that it is in God’s power to elect whomsoever He pleases for any status.
It is evident from the sayings of the Holy Prophets (as) that the Promised Messiah (as) would appear from within this ummah. The Holy Prophets (as) says: ْسٰیيعِ
Looking at these two Traditions together, it becomes perfectly clear that the Messiah himself would be the Mahdi, and that he would be the Imam of this ummah from within this ummah and not an outsider. It is incorrect to think that the Messiah and the
Mahdi are separate individuals because it contradicts the words, ‘There is no Mahdi except Isa.’ A believer ought to carefully look at the saying of his Master and remove any apparent discrepancies through deliberation. The Holy Prophets (as) says that the Mahdi would appear before the Messiah and then the Messiah would join the Mahdi and his followers in prayer. However, on the other hand, he also says that the Messiah himself will be the Mahdi. Are we now to reject these seemingly contradictory sayings or is it our duty to ponder them and see if there is a way to reconcile them? Even with the least bit of deliberation, one can realize that the only way to reconcile the two statements is to consider the words ‘There is no Mahdi except ‘Isa’ as clarification for the other statement which seems to indicate that the Messiah and Mahdi are two separate individuals. ‘There is no Mahdi except ‘Isa’ makes it clear that the aforementioned statement is metaphorical. It only means that an individual from the Holy Prophet’s ummah would be appointed for the reformation of the world but he would initially not be given the status of Prophet; later on, however, the prophecy about the advent of the Messiah would also be fulfilled in his person and he would claim to be ‘Isa. The Hadith, therefore, speaks of the manifestation of the two spiritual stations. He would initially come with the claim of general reformation and only later claim Messiah-hood. Such metaphors are common in prophecies, without them they can be impossible to understand.
If these Traditions are not interpreted in this way, then we are left with one of two alternatives, both being extremely perilous. The first is to say that the Hadith ‘There is no Mahdi except ‘Isa’ is not true. The second is to posit that the Hadith does not mean that the Messiah and the Mahdi are the same person, rather it only highlights the difference between the spiritual stations of the two, whereby ‘Īsā is the true Mahdi and Mahdi himself is nothing compared with him. This is just as one might say, ‘There is no scholar, except Tom,’ which does not mean that there are no other scholars, rather it means that Tom is far superior to others. Both these interpretations have dire implications. On the one hand, it is dangerous to declare a Hadith to be false without any reason, especially if the Hadith is accompanied by testimony. On the other hand, to say that the Mahdi will have no status as compared to the Messiah contradicts the Hadith wherein he has been called the Imam while the Messiah is described as his follower. The only acceptable interpretation, then, is that this Hadith gives the tiding of a single individual being raised from among the followers of the Holy Prophets (as) who would first claim to be a Reformer and then claim to be the Promised Messiah (as). These Traditions can have no other meaning.