Part II—Arguments
Invitation to Ahmadiyyat, Part 24
Many have deemed the Holy Qur’an so insignificant as to render its verses subservient to the most inauthentic and dubious of Hadith. In the name of Sunnah (the practical example of the Holy Prophets (as)), they have placed the Word of God under the authority of self-seeking and immoral men. The Holy Qur’an may reject a thing vehemently, and yet if they find it to be permissible in a most unsupported Hadith, they will give priority to that Hadith. If the Holy Qur’an teaches something but they find it forbidden in a Hadith, they will put the Holy Qur’an aside and adopt the Hadith.
Some believe that the Holy Qur’an was narrated by the Holy Prophets (as) and not revealed by God. Although they describe the Holy Qur’an as the Word of God, they interpret this to mean that the words that came from the Holy Prophets (as) were supported by God and, therefore, should be called the Word of God, even though they were the words of the Holy Prophet s (as). They think that God cannot reveal in the form of words because words require lips and a tongue to be expressed.
Others think that the Holy Qur’an must not be translated. In this way, they have barred the only way of conveying its message to the masses and are responsible for the resultant spread of ignorance and godlessness among Muslims.
Some think that the Holy Qur’an is an abstract book that points out some essential teachings but nothing specific can be derived from it.
Some think that the Holy Qur’an is full of taqdim and ta‘khir, whereby the apparent order of words has to be changed in order to arrive at the true meaning.
Some have collected all kinds of fictitious tales that are unacceptable to common sense and abhorrent to human nature and ascribed them to the Holy Qur’an. Even if no such mention is made in the Holy Qur’an, or even when such tales are completely at odds with the Holy Qur’an, they still bring old Israelite stories into its commentaries. They do not even hesitate to attribute such stories to Prophets and sages of the past.
Another injustice they have done to the Word of God is that they deny that it has any rational order or sequence in its chapters or verses. In other words, just as a person utters meaningless words when he is not in his senses, so do they imagine that the Holy Qur’an has related random accounts without any regard for order or sequence.
Another wrongful belief almost all Muslims hold about Divine revelation is that, whereas God would reveal His word in earlier ages, He no longer does so. In other words, one of God’s attributes has been held in abeyance, and while He can see and hear, He can no longer speak.
God save us from all this!
In short, they have all tried their best to tear apart the Holy Qur’an and to conceal its beauty from the world, and they do all this in the name of ‘service to the Holy Qur’an’, but in so doing they have only managed to alienate people from the Holy Qur’an and made them indifferent to its guidance.
The Promised Messiah (as) removed all these misconceptions and proved with powerful arguments that the Holy Qur’an is God’s final guidance; that it is free from abrogation and every word of it is to be practised by Muslims; that no part of it contradicts another part; that any seeming discrepancy in its verses is due to ignorance and lack of understanding; that it has not been altered in the least; that every word we find in it today is exactly as it was revealed to the Holy Prophets (as); that not only has it not been altered, it is incapable of alteration, either through change or addition of subtraction; that God Himself has provided such means for its protection—both physical and spiritual—that it cannot be affected by human interpolation; and that it is, therefore, wrong to believe that some parts of it have been abrogated or changed even in the smallest degree. It is secure and shall forever remain secure.
To say that parts of it taken away from the world reflects badly upon God because it would mean that the perfect Book He sent for the guidance of humankind could not serve its purpose even for one day. To accept any sort of alteration in the Holy Qur’an would render it forever unreliable. If this had indeed been the case, it would necessitate the coming of a new Prophet and a new Shariah so that the world would not be left without Divine guidance.
The Promised Messiah (as) proved that the Holy Qur’an, and indeed all Divine revelation, is free from the influence of Satan. Satan can never interfere in the Word of God, neither by taking control of a Prophet’s tongue nor by mimicking the Prophet’s voice. Citing his own experience, the Promised Messiah (as) said that even though he was a mere servant of the Holy Prophet s (as), the Revelation he received was true beyond any doubt; how then could the Holy Qur’an, which was revealed to the Holy Prophets (as) and is the source of Divine guidance for all times to come, be susceptible to Satanic influence even for one small instant?
The Promised Messiah (as) told the Muslims that the Holy Qur’an was an authentic scripture and that God has promised to safeguard it in such a way that even its opponents are forced to admit that it has remained intact to this day. To try to counter it with Hadith amounts to denigrating and knowingly rejecting the Word of God. Any Hadith that contradicts the Holy Qur’an cannot be the saying of the Holy Prophets (as) because the Prophet of Allah cannot contradict the Word of Allah. Moreover, Hadith was not compiled in a safe and secure manner. It is, therefore, wrong to force Hadith on the Holy Qur’an; indeed, it is important to keep Hadith subordinate to the Holy Qur’an. If the two appear to be irreconcilable, then we should abandon the Hadith, which might have been distorted, intentionally or unintentionally, by some human being.
It is said in response to this that most of our knowledge of Islam comes from Hadith. However, the Promised Messiah (as) said that we have yet another source aside from the Holy Qur’an and Hadith, and it is the Sunnah—the actions of the Holy Prophet s (as), which his Companions learnt directly from him and performed them in the same way. For this, we do not need to rely on any verbal Hadith. Millions of Muslims saw millions of other Muslims perform certain acts in certain ways, and they, in turn, imparted them to the generations that followed them. The Sunnah never contradicts the Holy Qur’an, whereas the verbal Hadith has an element of doubt. Hence, if a Hadith is in keeping with the Holy