Part II—Arguments
Invitation to Ahmadiyyat, Part 27
That when He distributed good and evil among His creation,
To them alone did He grant truth; and falsehood to all others.
They say that among other nations,
There have only come hundreds of liars and pretenders.
If you call a brilliant ruby worthless,
The lustrous stone will not be any the less precious for it.
Reviling the virtuous affects them not in the least,
It only reveals your own wickedness.
The fifth pillar of faith in Islam is the belief in the Hereafter and in Heaven and Hell. The Muslims did their best to bring down this pillar as well. Their hearts were definitely in denial of life after death, why else would they have so blatantly turned their backs on the teachings of Islam? Even on the physical level, strange concepts were being entertained. The idea of Paradise held by a Muslim reflected the fact that the true meaning of Paradise had been forgotten. Paradise to them was no more than a place of fun and pleasure. In other words, they thought that the purpose of man’s existence was to go to a place where he would have plenty of food and drink and women and that if this was achieved then nothing more was wanted. However, Allah says in the Holy Qur’an that the purpose of man’s creation is to worship Him (51:57). In other words, man should try to acquire Divine attributes because the Arabic word al-‘ubudiyah also means to humble oneself and to accept the influence of another. It is, therefore, the height of naivety to think that man should only fulfil the purpose of his creation for fifty or sixty years and then spend an eternity eating and drinking and indulging his carnal desires. Similarly, Hell was thought of as a place where God would subject evil-doers to eternal damnation and, like a cruel tyrant, never forgive them.
The Promised Messiah (as) rejected these misconceptions and restored people’s faith in the Hereafter through arguments and miracles. He expounded upon the ephemeral nature of this world and the excellence of the Hereafter and inspired others with the eagerness to act accordingly. He also undid the absurd notions about Paradise. He said that Paradise was not a mere metaphor, nor was it a place of physical delights that was only more stable and on a larger scale than the physical delights of this world. He said that the delights of Paradise are very different from those of the material world. The physical delights of the Hereafter are like the joy one derives from worship and good works in this life. In other words, what we call the soul in this world becomes the body in the next; and the soul of the next world is a more developed and a more advanced form of existence than anything we know of in this world. This can be likened to the man who develops out of the sperm but has far greater powers than the sperm.
Similarly, the Promised Messiah (as) also proved that the punishment of Hell is not eternal and that it is bound to end sooner or later. It may last a long time but it is not forever, because Allah says:
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
‘My mercy encompasses all things.’ It is, therefore, contrary to His Majesty that He should subject someone to eternal damnation. Also, when the Holy Qur’an speaks of the bounties of paradise it describes them as
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
‘which shall not be cut off ’, and
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
‘rewards unending’. However, the punishment of Hell is not described in the same way. Why should the readers of the Holy Qur’an not observe and heed this difference? The Holy Prophets (as) himself said in explanation of the teachings of the Holy Qur’an about Heaven and Hell:
A time will come when no one will be left in Hell, and the
morning breeze will blow rattling its windows and doors.
In addition to the pillars of faith, there was also a lot of distortion in the practical aspects of Islam. Some had started stressing permissiveness and believed that so long as a person recited the Kalimah, ‘There is no god but Allah, and Muhammad is His Messenger’, he was free to do anything he liked. They said that if they did not sin, how then would the Holy Prophets (as) intercede on their behalf ? Others preached that the Shariah is not the objective, it is rather like a boat that leads to God, and that once a person has found God he had no further use for religious ordinances.
Others thought that religious duties had been ordained as external symbols of internal states. They claimed that the external aspects of the law were stressed in the time of the Holy Prophets (as) because people at the time were uncultured and primitive, but since mankind has now evolved into a state of knowledge and understanding, it is no longer necessary to stick to those external formalities. If a person observes cleanliness, remembers God in his heart, cares for the community, helps the poor, is moderate in eating and drinking, participates in patriotic activities, etc., he has no need to observe the five-daily prayers or fasting, or give Zakat, or perform the Hajj.
Others go to the other extreme and say that Muslims are obligated to follow the example of the Holy Prophets (as) down to the smallest details. If, for instance, the Holy Prophets (as) wore a certain type of dress or kept long hair, we should all do the same.
Some Muslims were of the view that the Holy Prophets (as) had no right to command us to do anything because he was just a man like us, and that the only teaching we need to follow is that of the Holy Qur’an.
Others were adamant that they would not accept anything that goes against the saying of certain holy men and that people are bound to follow them without question.
These were the generalities, but when we delve into the details we find even greater chaos. Some Muslims believed that the learning of other languages was sinful. Others had outlawed the acquiring of modern education. In contrast, there were those who allowed for the practice of usury even though the Holy Qur’an categorically forbids it and says:
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
That is to say, the taking of interest is like going to war against God.
There is so much contrast in the beliefs of different groups of Muslims regarding prayer, fasting, inheritance, etc., that the truth has become wholly obscured. They hold on to some trivial point and declare it to be the pivot of Islam and quarrel with those who disagree. People who call themselves Muslim are known to have broken the fingers of fellow Muslims because they raised their index finger for tashahhud, or put filth in their mouth for having said amin aloud during congregational prayers. Thus, the practical aspect of Islam has suffered as much distortion and disfigurement as the doctrinal aspect.
The Promised Messiah (as) also corrected these misconceptions. He disproved the notion of permissiveness and said that intercession is for those who do their best to avoid sin but still have some shortcomings. It is not for those who deliberately continue to sin in the hope of attaining intercession. The purpose of intercession was to eradicate sin, not to promote it.
He also clarified that even though the Shariah is not the objective in itself, total obedience to God is the objective and, therefore, we must follow His laws and commandments. Finding God is not a finite objective that can be attained, after which one no longer needs to worship. The Holy Prophet s (as), to his dying day, was commanded to pray:
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
‘Only You do we worship’ and
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
‘Guide us on the right path’. How can anyone else claim that he does not need to pray anymore? Those who think in this way consider God to be a finite goal, like the bank of a river, and try to hide their impiety under such false beliefs.