Part II—Arguments

Invitation to Ahmadiyyat, Part 33

There were scores of others who offered similar mubahalah prayers against the Promised Messiah (as) and were soon seized by God. One of these was Maulawi Ghulam Dastgir of Kasur, a renowned and influential scholar belonging to the Hanafi school of thought. He also prayed against the Promised Messiah (as) and invoked Divine punishment upon whoever was the liar. Within a few months, this Maulawi died of the plague and became a warning for others.

Another example is that of Faqir Mirza of Dulmial. He started saying that God had told him that Mirza Sahib (as) would be dead by 27th of Ramadan, 1321 a.h. He put this into writing and handed copies of it to members of the local Community. The note said that if Mirza Sahib (as) did not die by the date specified, or if his Movement did not come to an end, then he would be willing to suffer any punishment. He also had many people sign this statement as witnesses. This claim was made on the 7th of Ramadan. The 27th of Ramadan came and went but nothing happened, and no wonder, for the words of liars cannot affect the truthful. When Ramadan came the following year, the plague visited Dulmial and the first life it claimed was that of Faqir Mriza’s wife. Then he himself contracted the disease and died in great agony on 7th of Ramadan, 1322 A.H., exactly a year to the day he had made his announcement. A few days later his daughter also died.

Examples of this kind, if they were to be compiled, would run into thousands. There were indeed thousands of men who, having been defeated in argument, became adamant and started praying for the destruction of the Promised Messiah (as), and they were all held accountable by God. The strange thing is that these signs of disgrace and ignominy were manifested in many different ways. For example, those who prayed that the liar may die in the lifetime of the truthful one died during the life of the Promised Messiah (as). Others, who said that a longer life was no proof of truth and cited the example of Musaylimah al-Kadhdhāb who lived long after the Holy Prophet s (as), such people were granted respite and ended up like Musaylimah, the pretender.

An example of this was Maulawi Thanaullah of Amritsar, editor of the weekly Ahle-Hadith and a recognized leader of the

Ahle-Hadith sect, who exceeded all bounds in his opposition to the Promised Messiah (as). The Promised Messiah (as), therefore, challenged him to a mubahalah (prayer duel) in keeping with the verse in the Holy Qur’an:

Now whoso disputes with you concerning him, after what

has come to you of knowledge, say to him, ‘Come, let us

call our sons and your sons, and our women and your

women, and our people and your people; then let us pray

fervently and invoke the curse of Allah on those who lie.’

Maulawi Thanaullah saw that this mubahalah did to augur well for him and so he declined to accept it despite repeated invitations. The Promised Messiah (as) then wrote out a prayer and proposed that the Maulawi Thanaullah should publish it in his Ahle-Hadith publication. In this prayer, the Promised Messiah (as) invoked Almighty God to decide between him and the Maulawi in such a way that the liar should die in the lifetime of the truthful one. Even this was refused by Maulawi Thanaullah. Instead, he started writing in his publication that this was no criterion for judging the truth of anyone. He said that even the Holy Qur’an says that the liar is given a longer respite and that Divine law also testified to this because Musaylimah lived on after the Holy Prophet s (as). The result of this announcement was that God held the Maulawi culpable by his own criterion. God gave him a long life so that he outlived the Promised Messiah (as). Thus, in keeping with his own writing, every day that he lived was a testimony that he was akin to Musaylimah.

God destroyed or debased the enemies of the Promised Messiah (as) according to the criterion they had accepted. Those who accepted the criterion that the liar dies in the lifetime of the truthful one were killed during the Promised Messiah’s lifetime, while those who insisted that a liar can outlive the truthful one were given that respite. The fact that among the enemies of the Promised Messiah (as) we find the likes of both Abu Jahl and Musaylimah shows the degree to which the Promised Messiah (as) reflected the image of the Holy Prophet s (as). It also serves as proof that what befell the enemies of the Promised Messiah (as) was a deliberate act of God and not mere chance or accident. Had all this been mere coincidence, how did everyone meet his end according to the criterion of his own choosing?

Aside from those who died as a result of mubahalah or praying against the Promised Messiah (as), so many other afflictions befell those who opposed him that they have no parallel in history. This does not require much elaboration because every country and every nation has witnessed plagues, earthquakes, influenza outbreaks, famines, or wars, that have destroyed whole towns and regions.

Some of the calamities that befell individual opponents were of the kind whereby they fell victim to the same misfortune that they had wished on the Promised Messiah (as). For instance, those who claimed that the Promised Messiah (as) suffered from leprosy, themselves fell victim to leprosy. Those who claimed that he had died or would die of the plague, succumbed to the plague. Dr Abdul Hakim Khan of Patiala predicted that the Promised

Messiah (as) would die of lung disease; it so happened that he himself died of tuberculosis. There are indeed hundreds of such examples. Anyone who honestly ponders over these signs of Divine wrath that were shown in favour of the Promised Messiah (as) will come to have complete faith in God as being ‘Severe in punishment’. He will also have no choice but to believe that the Promised Messiah (as) was a true servant of God, which is why God demonstrated His concern for his honour and continues to do so to this day.

dering, Haqiqatul-Wahi, London, 2018, pp. 476–479

We know from the Holy Qur’an that God created Adam and commanded the angels to prostrate before him. Prostration (sajdah) is a form of worship and it is not permissible to offer it to anyone or anything other than God, neither to Prophets nor even to Muhammad, the Chief of the Prophets (sa). Not only is it not permissible, it is a mortal sin and anyone guilty of it is deprived of God’s grace. Therefore, the word sajdah in this verse cannot mean ‘to worship’. It is also wrong to say that this was permissible in earlier times and forbidden afterwards, because Shirk is not the kind of sin that can be allowed at one time and disallowed at another. Tauhid is the most fundamental of principles and it can never be altered. If we were to assume that it was allowed at that time and forbidden later, then Satan would be entitled to claim that God ultimately had to accept what he had been saying all along, which was that it is not permissible to prostrate to anyone other than God.

·

10 of 10 left today