Part II—Arguments
Invitation to Ahmadiyyat, Part 43
This was strange because in the New Testament the disciples are said to have made all kinds of oaths. In Christian nations, nobody is appointed to high office without taking an oath. Even the King has to take an oath. Judges, MPs, high civil and military officers, all have to take oaths. Witnesses in court have to take an oath. In fact, Christian courts restrict oath-taking to Christian witnesses while non-Christian witnesses only say, ‘I declare before the ever-present and ever-seeing God,’ etc. Hence, this excuse on the part of Atham was ridiculous and was only meant to avoid taking the oath, for he had already witnessed fearful sights that had convinced him that if he took the oath he would be destroyed. That Atham refused to take the oath using lame excuses becomes clearer from the fact that, among Christians, no important religious office is given to anybody unless he takes the oath of loyalty. Protestant Christians (Atham was a Protestant) have to take two oaths, one of loyalty to the Church and another of loyalty to the State. All this was put before Atham but he offered no reply. The cash reward offered to Atham was raised from Rs. 1,000 to Rs. 4,000, and even the condition of a year of waiting was dropped and Atham could claim the cash reward as soon as he took the oath, but he could not do it when he knew in his heart that for fifteen months he had been concealing the true state of his mind out of fear of his fellow Christians. He did not take the oath and spent the rest of his days in silence. He gave up speaking or writing against Islam and stopped preaching Christianity. In this manner, the truth of the Promised Messiah’s (as) prophecy became clearer than ever.
Atham recanted his belief in the godhood of Jesus and his views about the truth of Islam were made abundantly clear by his refusal to take the oath. (This was despite the fact that during the debate in which the prophecy had been made, Atham had tried to prove that Jesus was God and possessed all the Divine attributes in his person.)
The grandeur of this prophecy boosts the faith of every honest person. In it, one can see the working of the Hand of God. Atham was a sworn enemy of Islam, a leader of an important community and its advocate in controversy with another, and he had spent all his life preaching and propagating his religion and disparaging the other. For such a person to start to entertain thoughts against his own religion, to have extraordinary hallucinations appear to him, and for him to be safe from death for fifteen months in consideration of his repentant demeanour, all this is beyond the power of man to bring about.
This prophecy relates to the downfall of Dowie, an American impostor. It constitutes a sign for Christians in general and the people of America in particular.
Alexander Dowie was a well-known name in America. He was Australian by birth and had later moved to America. In 1892 he started giving religious lectures and soon claimed that he had the power of healing, which brought him a lot of popularity. In 1901 he claimed that he was like Elijah and a forerunner for the Second Coming of Christ. Since the signs of the Second Coming of the Messiah had already been fulfilled, religious people were already waiting for his return. Hence, this claim by Dowie found a lot of followers. He then bought some land and founded a town called
Zion and declared that Christ would descend in that town. Many wealthy people, eager to have the first glimpse of Christ on his Second Coming, paid large sums to buy land and build houses in Zion where Dowie lived like a king. Soon his followers exceeded 100,000 and missionaries were appointed in all Christian countries. Dowie was a staunch enemy of Islam and always had something nasty to say about it. In 1902 he published a prophecy saying that unless all Muslims accepted Christianity, they would meet with death and destruction. When the Promised Messiah (as) learnt of this, he at once responded by publishing an announcement in which, after enumerating the beauties of Islam, he said that it was quite unnecessary to destroy millions of people just to prove the truth of Christianity. Instead, he, as the Promised Messiah (as), was willing to enter into a prayer-duel with Dowie, which would easily distinguish between the true religion and the false one and help people to determine the truth. This announcement was published in September 1902 and was publicised so widely that newspapers in Europe and America kept writing about it from December 1902 to the end of 1903. About forty of them sent their copies to Qadian. Such wide publication meant that the news of prayer-duel reached about two-and-a-half million people.
Dowie, instead of responding to the challenge, started cursing and attacking Islam even more vehemently. On February 14, 1903, he wrote in his paper, ‘I pray to God that Islam will soon disappear from the world. O God, accept this prayer of mine. O God, destroy Islam.’ On August 5, 1903, he wrote in his paper: ‘The black spot on the mantle of man [Islam] will meet its end at the hands of Zion.’
Seeing that Dowie was in no mood to give up his hostility, the
Promised Messiah (as) published another announcement in 1903, entitled ‘Prophecies about Dowie and Piggott’. In this announcement, he wrote that God had sent him in this age to re-establish belief in the Oneness of God and to put an end to idolatry. He said that he had been given a specific sign for America, and it was that if Dowie entered into a prayer-duel with him or, directly or indirectly, confronted him, then ‘before my very eyes, he will leave this world in pain and anguish’. The Promised Messiah (as) went on to say that he had previously invited Dowie to a prayer-duel but he had given no reply. Dowie was now being allowed another seven months. He then wrote, ‘Be sure, calamity is due to befall Dowie’s Zion.’ In the end, without waiting anymore for Dowie’s reply, he prayed, ‘God, ordain that the falsehood of Piggott and Dowie may soon become apparent to all people.’ This announcement, too, was published widely in Western countries and was commented on in several newspapers, such as The Glasgow Herald in Britain and New York Commercial Advertiser in America. Thus, millions became aware of its contents.
When this announcement was published, Dowie’s star was at its zenith and the number of his followers was on the rise. They were so rich that they gave Dowie presents worth hundreds of thousands of dollars every New Year. Dowie also owned several industrial establishments and his bank balance amounted to about 20 million dollars. His retinue of servants was larger than that of the richest in the land. He was in excellent health and attributed this to his own miraculous healing powers through which he claimed to be able to heal anyone. In short, he had an abundance of money, health, followers and power.
Upon the publication of the second pamphlet by the Promised
Messiah (as), Dowie was asked why he did not respond to it, to which he replied:
There is a Muhammadan Messiah in India who has
repeatedly written to me that Jesus Christ lies buried in
Kashmir, and people ask me why I do not answer him. Do
you imagine that I shall reply to such gnats and flies? If I
were to put down my foot on them I would crush out their
lives. I give them a chance to fly away and live.
Thus, despite refusing to take up the challenge, Dowie unwittingly accepted it. He forgot that the Promised Messiah (as) had written that if he, directly or indirectly, confronted him, he would leave the world in great pain and anguish. Having described the Promised Messiah (as) as a worm and saying that he could trample him under his foot, Dowie came into direct confrontation with the Promised Messiah (as) and invited God’s punishment.
Dowie’s vanity and egotism did not stop here. A few days later he described the Promised Messiah (as) as ‘foolish Muhammadan Messiah’. He also wrote, ‘If I am not a messenger of God on this earth, then no one is.’ In December 1903, he openly confronted the Promised Messiah (as) and said that an angel had told him that he would be victorious over his enemies. This was practically a counter-prophecy of the death of the Promised Messiah (as). The contest was slowly becoming clear. After this last attack by Dowie, the Promised Messiah (as) stopped writing about him and waited for God’s decision in keeping with the injunction in the Holy Qur’an, ‘So turn away from them, and wait. They are also waiting.’ God, who is slow in punishment but very firm when He comes to it, caused