Cover Page

Islam's Response to Contemporary Issues, Part 27

I have not created jinn and men but to worship Me.25

In examining each mode of seeking pleasure, one may not find much fault with any to justify their total ban. Particularly in the free societies of the world, it is very difficult for the people to understand why Islam is so puritan to the extent of dryness. Islam is not at all dry and boring; howsoever it may seem so from a distance. First of all, those who acquire a taste for goodness, also learn to draw sublime pleasure out of an act, which may seem rather drab to the outsider. Secondly, the more fortunate among those who experience the true love of God, transcend to a state of sublimity from where worldly pleasures appear too lowly, base, meaningless and transient. Thirdly, in its much broader application, a society not given to the pursuits of pleasure is not left empty-handed at the end of the day. In the final analysis, it turns not only to be an exchange of value—excitement, exhilaration, intense sensual experiences and explosive raptures are bartered for peace, tranquillity, equilibrium, growing sense of security, nobility and contentment, which as a reward per se is the noblest of all rewards. When the two social atmospheres and climates are compared as a whole, it is not difficult at all to understand that the tree of God’s love and devotion to Him can seldom take root in the materialistic climate of a fun-loving society. Of course, there are exceptions but exceptions do not make the rule. The two climates are very different. === PDF-Seite 184 === 162 islam’s response to contemporary issues

Endnotes

1. Various sources of Ahadith 2. Ch. 3: Al- ‘Imran: 135 3. Ch. 51: Al-Dhariyat: 20 4. Ch. 39: Al-Zumar: 8 5. Tirmidhi, Kitabul Birri Was Silati ‘An Rasulillahi, Babu Ma Ja’a Fishshukri Liman Ahsana Ilaika 6. Ch. 39: Al-Zumar: 8 7. Ch. 2: Al-Baqarah: 4 8. Ch. 76: Al-Dahr: 9–10 9. Ch. 74: Al-Muddaththir: 7 10. Ch. 2: Al-Baqarah: 262–265 11. Ch. 93: Al-Duha: 11 12. Bukhari, Kitabuz Zakat, Babun La Sadaqata illa ‘An Zahri Ghinan 13. Ch. 2: Al-Baqarah: 274 14. Ch. 59: Al-Hashr: 8 15. Bukhari, Kitabuz Zakat, Babun La Sadaqata illa ‘An Zahri Ghinan 16. Ch. 2: Al-Baqarah: 268 17. Ch. 22: Al-Hajj: 38 18. Ch. 2: Al-Baqarah: 271–272 19. Bukhari, Kitabun Nikah, Babun Al-Mar’atu Ra’iyatun fi Baiti Zaujiha 20. Ch. 2: Al-Baqarah: 4 21. Ch. 3: Al- ‘Imran: 111 22. Ch. 5: Al-Ma’idah: 91–92 === PDF-Seite 185 === Socio-economic Peace 163

23. Ch. 2: Al-Baqarah: 220 24. Ch. 3: Al- ‘Imran: 191–192 25. Ch. 51: Al-Dhariyat: 57 === PDF-Seite 186 === Allah will abolish interest and will cause charity to increase. And Allah loves not anyone who is a confirmed disbeliever and an arch-sinner. —The Holy Qur’an, 2:266

O

Nay, but you honour not the orphan, and you urge not one another to feed the poor, and you devour the heritage of the poor, and you love wealth with extreme love. —The Holy Qur’an, 89:18–21 === PDF-Seite 187 === Chapter Four

Economic Peace

Economic Philosophies of Capitalism, Communism and Islam The Islamic economic order neither belongs to capitalism nor to scientific socialism. The economic philosophy of Islam is scientific without being mechanical. It is disciplined without being over- restrictive. It allows private possession and private enterprise but does not promote greed and the amassing of wealth in a few hands whereby a large section of society turns into destitute, serfs and slaves to a cruel and relentless system of exploitation. There are three fundamental differences in the economic philosophies of capitalism, communism and Islam.

Capitalism In capitalism, capital is rewarded with interest. It is intrinsically accepted in principle that capital has a right to grow. Interest plays the === PDF-Seite 188 === 166 islam’s response to contemporary issues

central motive force for the amassing of capital, which is then channelled as energy to set and keep the assembly line of production in motion. In short, interest acts as an incentive for keeping capital in circulation.

Scientific Socialism In scientific socialism, although there is no incentive of interest to cycle and recycle capital into a productive mechanism, the state monopolises capital. So, there is no need for motivation. In free private enterprise, whether one pays or does not have to pay interest, one’s sense of personal ownership is sufficient to create an urge that one’s capital should grow at the fastest possible rate. If one has to pay interest on borrowed money, the rate of interest acts as a benchmark. It works like a window through which one can monitor the comparative growth or diminution of capital. In the socialist economic system, however, there is neither this urge, because those who employ capital do not own it, nor is there any means of comparison whereby one can judge whether the rate of growth is economically sufficient or not. In socialist scientific order, the forcible possession of the entire state’s capital by the state itself renders the system of interest totally irrelevant and meaningless. The snag is that when you are not under any pressure to earn more than the interest you may have to pay, you lose all incentives and any sense of responsibility. If the entire capital in circulation in a communist state could, for instance, be valued from the point of view of how much interest it could earn had it been deposited in a bank, that would present us with === PDF-Seite 189 === Economic Peace 167

one side of the picture. The second side of the picture could be conceived by assessing the economy on a profit and loss basis. Of course, it would present many complications such as assessing wages etc. But if financial experts put their heads to it, such hurdles may be overcome. A comparison of these two would present very interesting possibilities. It is more than likely that the real culprits for the decline of standards of living could precisely be pinpointed in this way. Even without such a gigantic exercise, it is not difficult at all for one to determine the causes of such decline. I believe that because the state becomes the capitalist, it is deprived of a monitoring system to warn it of failures, wastage and blunders regarding the way it handles the state’s capital because it has no financial obligations to fulfil and can employ capital without accountability. Such a situation is rife with inherent dangers. Lack of personal interest and a warning system on the profit or loss arising from the employment of capital works havoc with the input-output ratio. The quantum of waste goes on increasing. Again, there is no check placed on the policy of channelling capital. For instance, there is no mirror for the socialist governments to judge the real rate of economic growth in comparison to the free market economies of the outside world. An added problem is that communist states require much larger expenditure on defence, surveillance and law-enforcing agencies within the country. Other things being equal, this requires a disproportionate level of expenditure on defence and the maintenance of law and order. These and other similar factors take a heavy toll on the economy. The ultimate collapse of the economy can be delayed, of course, but cannot be averted altogether. === PDF-Seite 190 === 168 islam’s response to contemporary issues

Islamic Concept While communism provides no incentive for direct dedicated involvement in the production of wealth, despite banishing interest, Islam provides the incentive. Islam does away with the system of usury and interest without sharing the specific problems of the communist world. In the absence of interest dragging capital along non- productive channels, Islam checks idle capital. This check is a form of ‘tax’ known as Zakat, which is levied not on income or profit but on the capital itself. The contrast is very clear. In capitalist societies, capital is amassed in the hands of a few out of greed to increase capital through the accumulation of interest and is recycled into the economy with the set task of yielding a profit greater than the prevailing rate of interest. Failing this, the economy is bound to go into recession. In Islam, out of fear that any idle capital would be gradually eroded away through the imposition of Zakat, anyone with surplus savings would have to employ it in earning profit to offset the effect of Zakat. According to Islam, the answer to the economic problems of the world lies neither in scientific socialism nor capitalism. It is impossible to elaborate on this subject here but we must have a topical view of the economic imbalance created by capitalism to draw some lessons for the future. === PDF-Seite 191 === Economic Peace 169

Four Characteristics of a Capitalist Society The signposts for determining that such an imbalance has arisen in a society are very clearly stated in the following verses of the Holy Qur’an:

Nay, but you honour not the orphan. And you urge not one another to feed the poor. And you devour the heritage of the other people wholly. And you love wealth with exceeding love.1

Briefly, these features are:

1. Dishonourable treatment of orphans. 2. Feeding of the poor is not promoted. 3. Usurpation of the heritage of others. 4. Endless amassing of wealth.

Capitalism Ultimately Leads to Destruction Without endorsing the philosophy of scientific socialism, Islam rejects some aspects of capitalism because:

Mutual rivalry in seeking worldly increase diverts you from God. Till you reach the graves. Nay! you will soon come to know the truth.2 === PDF-Seite 192 === 170 islam’s response to contemporary issues

The Changing Economic Order Exploitation of poorer citizens by interest-based capitalism, which gives birth to socialist rebellion, seems to be relegated to history. But a deeper study would reveal that it is only a change of guise. Already the world as a whole has been split into the haves and have-nots, thanks mainly to the exploitation by the advanced capitalist countries. Add to this situation the momentous return to capitalism by the repentant Eastern bloc. One shudders to visualise how much more blood would be sucked from the already enfeebled and anaemic nations of the Third World. But, it would seem that the vampires of capitalism must draw more blood. It is clear that the age of confrontation between the two major opposing economic philosophies of capitalism and scientific socialism is over. The economic systems based on Marxism-Leninism have bowed out of the stage of human affairs. On the other hand, the so- called ‘free’ economy of the West seems to be exultant over its apparent victory. Barring China, the Eastern bloc countries are still struggling to mitigate the miseries of the multitudes of have-nots in their respective countries in the wake of their newfound freedom. The economic gap between the East and West is not as big as that between the North and South. The First World countries of the North are divided on another plane from the Third World countries of Africa and South America. Though in terms of economic disparity, the gap between North and South America is certainly hurtful, it is nowhere near the gap between Europe and Africa. Africa, so close in proximity to Europe is, in terms of economic disparity, the farthest apart from Europe. === PDF-Seite 193 === Economic Peace 171

·

10 of 10 left today