Cover Page
Islam's Response to Contemporary Issues, Part 34
Political Peace
Political Peace Has to Be Carefully Examined at the National and International Level As far as national politics is concerned, the foremost issue is which political system is good or bad for man. Again, we need to discover whether it is the failure of political systems and their inherent defects which are responsible for the miseries and dissatisfaction of a people or is it something else. Is the system to be blamed or those who run it? Can immoral selfish, greedy, or corrupt political leadership which rises to power by democratic means be really good and beneficial for society as against benign dictatorship, for instance? In order to establish and guarantee international peace, Islam has a word of advice for the contemporary politicians. Islam lays extraordinary stress on introducing absolute morality to all spheres of human activity—politics being no exception. === PDF-Seite 242 === 220 islam’s response to contemporary issues
No Outright Condemnation of Any Political System We begin with the observation that no political system is mentioned in Islam as the only valid system against all others. There is no doubt the Holy Qur’an speaks of a democratic system where the rulers can be elected by the people, but it is not the only system recommended by Islam. Nor can it be the fundamental prerogative of a universal religion to choose a single system of government without due regard to the fact that it is not practically possible for a single system to be applicable to all regions and societies of the world. Democracy has not developed enough even in the most advanced nations of the world to reach the stage of polity which is the ultimate political vision of democracy. With the rise of capitalism and the building of extremely powerful machinery in capitalist countries, truly democratic elections cannot be held anywhere. Add to this the growing problem of corruption, and the coming into being of the Mafia and other pressure groups. One can safely conclude that democracy is not in safe hands even in the most democratic countries of the world. Then, how can it be suitable in the Third World? So, to say that Western democracy can prevail in African, Asian or South American countries or the so-called Islamic countries of the world would be tantamount to making a hollow and unrealistic claim. As far as I am concerned, Islamic teachings do not reject any political system of the world, but Islam leaves it to the choice of the people and historically established traditions prevailing in any country. What Islam emphasises is not the form of government but how the government should discharge itself. === PDF-Seite 243 === Political Peace 221
Provided a system of rule conforms to the Islamic ideal in the discharge of the trust owed to the subjects, different systems of government, such as feudal lordship, monarchy, democracy, etc., can be accommodated under Islam.
Monarchy Monarchy is mentioned repeatedly in the Holy Qur’an without being condemned as an institution. A Prophet of Israel reminds the Israelites of Talut:
Their Prophet said to them: Allah has appointed for you Talut as a king. They demurred, saying: How can he have sovereignty over us while we are better entitled to sovereignty than he, and he has not even been granted abundance of wealth? He answered; Surely Allah has granted him superiority over you and has given him a large portion of knowledge and strength. And Allah bestows sovereignty upon whom He pleases. Allah is Lord of vast bounty, All-Knowing.1
Monarchy is also mentioned in the broader sense of the people being the monarch themselves: === PDF-Seite 244 === 222 islam’s response to contemporary issues
Call to mind when Moses said to his people: O my people, recall the favour that Allah bestowed upon you when He appointed Prophets among you and made you kings, and gave you that which He had not given to any other of the peoples.2
Again, sovereignties created or expanded by conquest in general do not enjoy a good reputation as we find in the verse about the Queen of Sheba advising her counsel. The Queen of Sheba’s decision is set out as follows:
She said; Surely when mighty kings invade a country, they despoil it and humiliate its leading people. And that has been their way.3
Kings can be good or bad, of course, just as democratically elected prime ministers and presidents can also be good or bad. But the Holy Qur’an mentions a category of kings who were appointed by God. They are of the type, such as King Solomonas, who was not only a king as understood by the Jews and Christians, but also a Prophet of God according to the Holy Qur’an. This demonstrates that sometimes the offices of prophethood and sovereignty combine in one person and they are sovereigns directly commissioned by God. Another type of sovereignty through the authority of a Prophet is mentioned in the Holy Qur’an. The following verse illustrates this fact: === PDF-Seite 245 === Political Peace 223
O ye who believe, obey Allah and obey His Messenger and those who are in authority among you. Then if you differ in anything among yourselves, refer it to Allah and His Messenger if you are believers in Allah and His Messenger and the Last Day. That is the best and most commendable in the end.4
We have chosen this verse not only to enumerate the categories of sovereignty but to emphasise that according to the Holy Qur’an, sometimes democratic choices are not necessarily always the right ones. It is quite likely that the overwhelming majority of people fail to recognise the essential qualities of great leadership in a person and protest against his election if he is imposed upon them. By all political criteria, his appointment would be decried as dictatorial. The choice may be against popular will but is certainly not against public interest. The inherent weakness in the democratic form of elections is that the masses make their choice on superficial impressions and latest assessment and are incapable of judging for themselves the sound qualities of leadership which are best suited for their ultimate benefit. It seems that in the history of God’s favoured people, there have been times when their political survival required Divine intervention. At such times, God takes the choice of a king, sovereign or leader into His own hands. It should not be inferred from this that all monarchs or leaders are divinely chosen by God or sanctified as such. This misconception which has been common in the medieval Christian system is not shared by the Holy Qur’an. For instance, King Richard laments: === PDF-Seite 246 === 224 islam’s response to contemporary issues
Not all the waters of rough rude seas can wash the balm of an anointed King.5
Defining Democracy The concept of democracy, despite its Greek origins, is based on Abraham Lincoln’s brief definition of government of the people, by the people, for the people. It is a very interesting cliché indeed but seldom applied in totality anywhere in the world. The third part of this definition for the people is very vague and rife with dangers. What can be declared to be for the people with full confidence? In a system of majority rule, it can very often happen that what is considered to be for the people is merely for the majority and not for the remaining minority. In a democratic system, it is also possible for vital decisions to be taken solely on the basis of absolute majority. Yet, when you further dissect and analyse the facts and figures, you discover that it was in reality a minority decision, democratically passed, and imposed on the majority. One of the numerous possibilities is that the ruling party is voted into power on a first past the post basis having obtained a minor majority in most constituencies. Again, if the turnout on polling day is rather low, it becomes dubious if the ruling party does in fact enjoy the support of the majority. Even if the party emerges with an overall majority of the electorate, many things may happen during the term of its tenure. Public opinion may change drastically so that the sitting government is no longer a true representative of the majority. After all, a gradual process of change of heart by the electorate manifests itself at each change of government. === PDF-Seite 247 === Political Peace 225
Even if the government remains popular with its voters, it is not unlikely that when certain key decisions are made, a considerable number of the ruling party’s members do not agree at heart with the majority but may have voted out of party loyalty. If the difference is in the strength of the ruling party over the opposition party or parties, then, more often than not, the so-called majority decision would in reality be a minority decision imposed on the people. It is also noteworthy that the concept of what is seen as good for the people changes from time to time. If decisions are not taken on absolute principles but what one considers to be good for the people, or at least what the party considers to be good, it may lead to a constant shift in policy from time to time. What appears good today may be bad tomorrow and good the day after. For the man in the street, this can be a tricky situation. The experimentation of communism on such a large scale for over half a century was after all based on the same slogan of for the people. Not all socialist states were dictatorial. It should also be noted that the line separating the socialist states from the democratic ones, as far as government by the people is concerned, is very thin and sometimes non-existent. How can one condemn all world governments elected in socialist countries as having been brought to power not by the people? Of course, in a totalitarian state, it is possible to dictate the choice of candidates to the electorate in such a manner as leaves them little room to elect any alternates. Yet similar and other high-handed tactics can also be employed, save for a few exceptions in the Western world, in countries with a democratic system of government. In fact, democracy in most parts of the world is not given a free hand and the elections are seldom by the people. With election-rigging, === PDF-Seite 248 === 226 islam’s response to contemporary issues
horse trading, rule of fear through police tactics and other similar corrupt measures, the spirit and substance of democracy in the world are attenuated with adulteration so that there is little of democracy left in the end.
Islamic Definition of Democracy According to the Holy Qur’an, people have a free choice to adopt any system of rule which suits them. Democracy, sovereignty, tribal or feudal systems are valid provided they are accepted by the people as the traditional heritage of their society. However, it seems that democracy is preferred and highly commended in the Holy Qur’an. The Muslims are advised to have a democratic system though not exactly on the pattern of Western style democracy. Islam does not present a hollow definition of democracy anywhere in the Holy Qur’an. It only deals with principles of vital significance and leaves the rest to the people. Follow and benefit, or stray and be destroyed.