Cover Page
Islam's Response to Contemporary Issues, Part 38
O ye who believe! be steadfast in the cause of Allah, bearing witness in equity; and let not a people’s enmity incite you to act otherwise than with justice. Be always just, that is nearer to righteousness. And fear Allah. Surely, Allah is aware of what you do.17
I cannot claim to have read everything about all major religions of the world but neither am I entirely ignorant of their teachings. During my studies, however, I have failed to find a similar injunction as the verse under discussion in their scriptures. Even the mention of international relations is rare. If a similar teaching is also found in another religion, === PDF-Seite 268 === 246 islam’s response to contemporary issues
then let me assure you that Islam is in full agreement with that teaching for therein lies the key to world peace. The world at large is worried today at the future prospects of world peace. The momentous and epoch-making changes in the socialist world and the improving relationship of the superpowers offer a glimmer of hope. The world is in an exultant mood. The general consensus of opinion amongst leading politicians seems to be extremely optimistic, even euphoric, at the likely outcome of the momentous revolutionary changes we are witnessing today. The West, in particular, seems to be over confident and jubilant. It is becoming increasingly difficult for the Americans to suppress their jubilation at what they consider to be a grand slam victory over the communist hemisphere, a victory viewed by some as good over evil and of right over wrong. It will be out of place to analyse in detail the current geo-political situation and its outcome. Perhaps I will be able to devote a few hours to this subject at the UK Ahmadiyya Muslim Community’s Annual Conference at the end of July this year (1990).
The Role of the United Nations Organisation Of the many debates raging around the future prospects of world peace as a result of the recent events, one in particular needs special mention. It relates to the role that the United Nations Organisation is going to play in being able to secure and maintain (i.e. make and keep) world peace far more effectively than ever before. With the cold war between the two super-giants coming to an end, it is said that there is a fair chance of closing the gap between their === PDF-Seite 269 === Political Peace 247
hitherto divergent outlooks: less veto in the Security Council’s sessions, it seems, and more united decisions on how global problems should be resolved. This may present a completely new look to the Security Council of the future. The only snag so far is the danger of China playing the odd-man out, but in view of China’s immensely complicated economic and political problems; it should not be impossible to convince China of the advantages of agreement. Whether this dream comes true or not is beside the point. Given that the Security Council as well as the United Nations emerged as the most powerful political instrument to influence the events of the globe and coerce smaller nations to submit to the supreme will of the nations of the world, such a scenario was inconceivable prior to the tumbling of the Berlin Wall. But the question remains, nay, it looms larger on the political horizon than ever before, whether or not the United Nations in its new role of combined judicial and executive powers of such enormous proportion, will be actually able to achieve global peace? I beg to be excused if I may sound over-pessimistic, but my answer to this question is a very apologetic, ‘No’. The issue of war and peace in the world does not only hang by the thread of superpower relationships. It is a deep and complex question with its roots embedded in the political philosophies and moral attitudes of the nations of the world. Moreover, economic disparity and the widening gap between the haves and have-nots of the world are bound to play an important role in the future events of the world. Some effects have already been discussed in the previous section of this address. Unless the principle of absolute justice in the economic relationship between countries is === PDF-Seite 270 === 248 islam’s response to contemporary issues
accepted and strictly adhered to and unfair market practices which exploit the resources of the poor are removed by and for all members of the United Nations, no peace can ever be guaranteed or even visualised for the nations of the world. As long as the relationship of the United Nations Organisation with its individual member states is not more clearly defined than at present, the prospects of world peace will remain bleak. There is a need to devise some measure to prevent governments from being cruel to their own subjects. Some instrument has to be made available to the United Nations to justly fight injustice wherever it prevails. Till then, one cannot dream of peace for the world. How far the United Nations can interfere with the so-called internal affairs of a country is a very sensitive question and yet vital to the attainment of world peace. But if, in the final analysis, the policy of the United Nations is not governed by the principle of absolute justice, and different standards are applied to individual nations, then providing greater leverage to the United Nations Organisations to interfere in the internal affairs of a state may create more problems than it can resolve. Therefore, this issue requires a thorough, cool and detached study. What has happened so far is simply that the Soviet Union and Eastern bloc countries have been compelled to confess the failure of scientific socialist philosophies in improving the quality of life in the Soviet Union and her neighbouring East European countries. This has created great confusion. The fog is yet to clear before we can see the shape of things to be. Will it be a total defeat for scientific socialism followed by a mad rush back to capitalism in its entirety or will there be new experimentation with mixed economies? Will there be a complete breakdown of strict === PDF-Seite 271 === Political Peace 249
central control by totalitarian governments or will the totalitarian control itself break down into pieces resulting in a near state of anarchy? Or, will there be a gradual transition into totalitarian state control to a new compromised system of give and take between the state and individual so that, with the passage of time, civil liberties are progressively introduced and fundamental human rights restored? It is important to wait for the outcome of a new struggle between Mr. Gorbachev’s ideas of perestroika and glasnost on the one hand and the attitude of the strict orthodox in the communist hierarchy. To the best of my knowledge, most of the benefits in the USSR’s classless society are mutually shared by the party hierarchy, civil service and the defence forces. The vital question is what role are they going to play at this critical nascent stage of the bloodless counter-revolution, which is now taking shape? This and similar questions have to be answered before one can reasonably visualise the impact of these changes on the prospects of world peace. Merely a détente between the two superpowers in itself does not bring any hope of peace. On the contrary it invokes many phantoms of lurking dangers for the Third World countries in particular. It was the mistrust prevailing between the two superpowers and their jealousies, which, in fact, provided a sort of canopy for weaker nations. Also, it was the ability of the weaker nations to change sides and allegiances from the West to East or vice versa which gave them a small measure of manoeuvrability and bargaining power. But this is no longer so. What hope can these weaker nations entertain now to survive respectably as independent nations in the future? The thought at this stage shifts to the UNO—a bastion of peace and the only torch of hope for the establishment of a new world order. === PDF-Seite 272 === 250 islam’s response to contemporary issues
At least, one wishes it was so. However, upon a closer critical examination, a completely bleak, oppressive and even threatening picture emerges. In the newly emerging balance of power, will not the United Nations be practically governed by only one superpower? This presents the smaller and weaker nations no chance to escape the inevitable fate of hunted animals. The present United Nations has proved again and again to be a powerful organisation working not for justice but for the political ends of whichever nation has the greatest lobbying power. The concept of right and wrong has never played a part in the decision- making process of the United Nations in our recent memory nor in the present set up can it play a meaningful role in the future. Politics and diplomacy are too deeply and inextricably rooted in the soil of modern politics to leave any room for absolute justice to take root and be given a fair chance of survival. It is a hard and bitter fact, which no man with respect for truth can deny, that this great and awesome institution has been reduced to an arena of intricate diplomatic activities, lobbying, secret paramours and power struggles, all carried out in the name of world peace. According to the Holy Qur’an, therefore, what the world needs is an institution, which sets itself the task of establishing justice. Without absolute justice, no peace is conceivable. One can wage wars in protestation in the name of peace, stifle conscience and still dissent for the purported aim of establishing peace, but all that one can achieve is death but not peace. Alas! Few among the great politicians of the world understand the difference between death and peace. === PDF-Seite 273 === Political Peace 251
Death is borne out of inequity, tyranny and persecution by the mighty. Peace is the child of justice. The Holy Qur’an often speaks of peace but always in relation to justice. Peace is oft-mentioned as conditional to the dispensation of justice. In a situation erupting into belligerence and active hostility between two Muslim individuals or nations, the Holy Qur’an has this to propose:
In case two parties among the believers, be they individuals or nations, fight each other, bring about reconciliation between them. If, however, one of them persists in belligerence and transgresses against the other, bring your collective might to bear upon the one that transgresses to force him until he agrees that his dispute be resolved in accordance with the word of Allah. Then if both parties having so submitted, effect reconciliation between them and make them resolve their dispute with equity and We advise that you must exercise absolute justice, act justly. Remember, Allah loves the just. All believers are brothers, so make peace between your brothers and be mindful of your duty to Allah that you may be shown mercy.18
In the above verse, non-Muslims are not mentioned for the obvious reason that they cannot be expected to submit to the teachings of the === PDF-Seite 274 === 252 islam’s response to contemporary issues
Qur’an. Yet, the verse serves as an excellent model for the whole world to follow. While the eyes of the world are turning to the United Nations and the Security Council in the hope that it will acquire a more active, wider and meaningful role in resolving international disputes and thus transforming the world into a more secure, safe and peaceful abode, there is very little in the past record of the performance of the United Nations to give credence to this wishful thinking. A world arena of lobbying, intrigue, intense diplomatic activity aimed at formation of pressure groups and attempts to gain an upper hand over one’s opponents by any means available, where scruples have no part to play and human conscience is barred entry, may of course be called a House of Nations even though in conflict and disarray. But it would be an irony to call such a house a House of United Nations. If that be the concept of unity, I for one would much rather risk survival in a community of Nations which are disunited but united in truth and justice. The will to muster power to crush adversaries and still the voice of dissent is a most vital question which every nation must address and resolve. One wonders with a deep sense of sorrow as to how long the member nations of this august House would continue to shut their eyes and refuse to open their minds to the dangers inherent in the style in which the affairs of nations are run. World peace hangs precariously on the string of a feeble hope that justice will prevail and justice will be done. === PDF-Seite 275 === Political Peace 253
Endnotes
1. Ch. 2: Al-Baqarah: 248 2. Ch. 5: Al-Ma’idah: 21 3. Ch. 27: Al-Naml: 35 4. Ch. 4: Al-Nisa’: 60 5. Shakespeare 6. Ch. 42: Al-Shura: 37–40 7. Ch. 4: Al-Nisa’: 59 8. Ch. 23: Al-Mu’minun: 117 9. Ch. 42: Al-Shura: 39 10. Ch. 3: Al-‘Imran: 160 11. Matthew 22: 21 12. Ch. 4: Al-Nisa’: 66 13. Ch. 4: Al-Nisa’: 136 14. Ch. 4: Al-Nisa’: 60 15. Ch. 8: Al-Anfal: 59 16. Ch. 27: Al-Naml: 63 17. Ch. 5: Al-Ma’idah: 9 18. Ch. 49: Al-Hujurat: 10–11 === PDF-Seite 276 === Those who believe and whose hearts find comfort in the remembrance of Allah. Aye! It is in the remembrance of Allah that hearts can find comfort. —The Holy Qur’an, 13:29 === PDF-Seite 277 === Chapter Six