Cover Page
Islam's Response to Contemporary Issues, Part 4
These Messengers have We exalted, some of them above others; among them there are those to whom Allah spoke frequently; and some of them He exalted by degrees of rank.6
Having accepted this proposition, one may wonder as to who should be considered as the highest in rank among the Prophets. This is a sensitive issue; yet one cannot close one’s eyes to the importance of this question. Adherents of almost all religions claim that the Founder of their religion stands supreme and no one else can be a match to him in excellence, dignity, piety, honour and in short all the qualities that go into the making of a Prophet. Then, does Islam also claim that Muhammad, the Holy Prophetsa of Islam, is the most exalted of all Prophets? Yes, Islam does make an unambiguous claim about the par excellence and supremacy of the qualities of the Holy Prophetsa over all the rest of the Prophetsas of the world. Yet, there is a very clear difference between Islam and other religions in their attitude to this claim. First of all, it should be kept in mind that no religion other than Islam recognises the universality of prophethood. When the Jews claim, if they do, that Mosesas was the greatest Prophet, they are not === PDF-Seite 36 === 14 islam’s response to contemporary issues
comparing Mosesas with Buddhaas, Krishnaas, Jesusas, or Muhammadsa, because they deny the claims of all other great Founders of the religions mentioned above to be genuine and worthy of acceptance. So, in the Jewish list of Prophets, no Prophets are included other than those specifically mentioned in the Old Testament; even the possibility of there being Prophets elsewhere is ruled out. In the light of this attitude, their claim regarding the supremacy of any Judaic Prophet does not belong to the same category as that of Islam, as according to Judaism, Prophets outside the Holy Bible simply do not exist. Exactly the same is the nature of similar claims of Buddhism, Zoroastrianism, Hinduism, etc. There is yet another difference to be kept in mind. When we talk of their Prophets, we are aware that they do not always refer to their holy religious figures as Prophet. The concept of Prophets and Messengers as understood in Judaism, Christianity and Islam is not exactly shared by most other religions. Instead, they treat the Founders of their religion and holy men as holy personages, or reincarnations of God, or God Himself, or, something approaching that. Perhaps in this respect, Jesus Christas also should be understood as an exception from the vantage point of Christianity. But according to Islam, all these so-called gods or reincarnations of God, or the so-called sons or children of God are merely Prophets and Messengers who were deified by their followers at a much later point. In fact, to be more specific, according to Islam, the deification of holy personages in various religions is a very gradual process and not that of the generation contemporary to the Prophetas. But of that, we shall speak later. When Islam, however, claims that its Holy Founder is supreme amongst the Prophets, it takes into account the holy personages of all === PDF-Seite 37 === Inter-Religious Peace 15
the religions of the world in the sense understood by the Judeo-Islamic concept of Prophets. It may bear repeating that Islam considers the Founders of all revealed religions to be merely human beings who were raised by God to the status of prophethood. There is no exception in this universal phenomenon. For instance, the Holy Qur’an declares:
How will it fare with them when We shall bring a witness from every people, and shall bring thee as a witness against these.7
Having made this essential clarification, we now proceed to study the status of the Holy Prophetsa of Islam, according to the Holy Qur’an. The most conspicuous and incontrovertible claim regarding the Holy Prophetsa of Islam is made in the widely known and extensively discussed verse of the Holy Qur’an:
Muhammadsa is not the father of any of your men, but he is the Messenger of Allah and (Khataman Nabiyyin) the Seal of the Prophets and Allah has full knowledge of all things.8
The Arabic word Khatam in this verse has many connotations but the essence of the title Khataman Nabiyyin is, without a shadow of doubt, to be the very best; the supreme; the last word; the final authority; the one who encompasses all and testifies to the truth of others.9 Another verse which speaks of the excellence of the Holy Foundersa of Islam declares that the teachings of the Holy Prophetsa are perfect and final. The verse runs as follows: === PDF-Seite 38 === 16 islam’s response to contemporary issues
This day have I perfected your religion for you and completed My favour upon you and have chosen for you Islam as religion.10
The obvious inference from this claim would be that of all law bringing Prophets of the world and in giving the world the most perfect teaching, he occupies the highest station amongst the Prophets. Developing the theme further the Holy Foundersa is assured in no uncertain terms that the Book being revealed to him will be guarded and protected from interpolations. As such, not only is the teaching claimed to be perfect, but also, it is declared to be everlasting—to be kept pure and unadulterated in the very words in which they were revealed to the Holy Foundersa of Islam. The history of the last fourteen centuries has borne ample witness to the truth of this claim. The following are some relevant verses:
Surely, We Ourself have sent down this Exhortation and We will, most surely, be its Guardian.11
Surely, this is a glorious Qur’an in a well-guarded tablet.12
In view of the above, the Holy Foundersa of Islam is clearly not only declared to be supreme but also the last and final law-bearing Prophetsa whose authority would continue to remain good till the end of time. === PDF-Seite 39 === Inter-Religious Peace 17
Having said that, one begins to wonder if, in the eyes of some, this claim about the supremacy of the Holy Foundersa of Islam would be tantamount to creating ill-will or misunderstanding amongst the followers of other religions. So how can one reconcile this claim with the theme of this address, namely that Islam guarantees peace in all spheres of human interest, religion being not the least important among them? It was with this question in mind that I had to elaborate this claim at some length. This question can be answered to the satisfaction of an unprejudiced and enquiring mind in more than one way. As has already been mentioned before, similar claims are also made by followers of many other religions. It is only prudent for one to investigate the relative merits of the claim without being unduly excited about it. By itself such a claim should not offend the sensibilities of the followers of other religions who make similar counter-claims. But Islam goes one step further by teaching humility and decency to its followers so that their belief in the supremacy of the Holy Foundersa of Islam is not expressed incautiously, thereby giving offence to others. The following two Traditions of the Holy Foundersa of Islam stand aloft as beacons to illuminate the case in point. 1) One of the Companions of the Holy Foundersa of Islam became involved in a rather heated discussion with a staunch follower of the Prophet Jonahas of the Fish (or Whale). Both parties in the debate claimed their respective Prophet to be head and shoulders above the other in excellence. It appears that the Muslim contender might have rubbed in the claim in a manner so as to hurt the sensibility of the follower of Jonahas who approached Prophet Muhammadsa, and === PDF-Seite 40 === 18 islam’s response to contemporary issues
lodged a complaint against the Muslim involved in this debate. Addressing the community in general, the Prophetsa issued the following words of instruction:
Do not declare me to be superior over Jonah (Yunus), son of Mattah.13
Some Muslim commentators of Traditions are perplexed by this Tradition as it seemingly stands counter to the claim in the Holy Qur’an that Muhammadsa is superior not only to Jonahas but all Prophetsas. But they seem to miss the point that what he said was not that he was inferior to Jonahas, (nor superior to Jonahas), but simply that his followers should not declare him to be superior in a manner liable to hurt the feelings of others. In the context of what had passed, the only inference one can draw is that the Prophetsa was teaching Muslims a lesson in decency. He was instructing them not to become involved in bragging. They should take care to avoid discussing his status in a manner that could cause offence. Such an attitude would indeed be detrimental to the cause of Islam because instead of winning hearts and minds to the Message of Islam, quite the opposite would be achieved. 2) This attitude of the Holy Prophetsa, is corroborated further by another Tradition in which a Muslim was involved in a similar argument with a Jew. Both claimed and counter-claimed the relative superiority of their spiritual leaders. Again, it was the non-Muslim contender who thought it fit to lodge a complaint against the behaviour of his Muslim adversary. The Holy Prophetsa, responded === PDF-Seite 41 === Inter-Religious Peace 19
with his habitual humility and prudence and taught the Muslim the same lesson in decency and courtesy by admonishing:
Do not declare my superiority over Mosesas.14
The long and short of this is that it is for God to decide and declare the comparative ranking of the various Prophetsas closeness to Him. It is quite likely that in a particular age, in the context of a particular religion, God may have expressed His pleasure with the Prophet of the time in such strong terms as to declare that he was the best. Superlatives can, after all, be also used in relative terms in the context of a limited application of time and space. This could easily have led the followers of that holy personage to believe that he was the best and holiest for all ages and for all times to come. To genuinely believe in this should not be considered an offence against others. A civilised attitude would require that such issues should not be abused to create friction amongst religions. That exactly is the true import of the admonition of the Holy Prophetsa, quoted above. If adherence to this principle of humility and decency is adopted by all religions, the world of religious controversy would be the better for it.
Salvation Cannot Be Monopolised by Any Single Religion The question of salvation, howsoever innocent it may appear, is potent in its danger to peace in the religious world. === PDF-Seite 42 === 20 islam’s response to contemporary issues
It is one thing for a religion to declare that those who seek to be redeemed from Satan and attain salvation should rush to the safe haven of that religion; it is there that they would find salvation and eternal liberation from sin. But it is quite another thing for the same religion to declare in the next breath that those who do not come hither to seek refuge will be damned eternally, one and all. Whatever they do to please God, however much they love their Creator and His creation, however much they lead a life of purity and piety, they would most certainly be condemned to an everlasting Fire. When such a rigid, narrow-minded and non-tolerant view is expressed in a provocative language as generally is by religious zealots, it is known to have produced violent riots. People come in all shapes and sizes. Some are educated, cultured and refined and so are their reactions to offences committed against them. Yet a large number of religiously-inclined people, be they educated or illiterate, are likely to react violently when their religious sensibilities are hurt. Unfortunately this seems to be the attitude of the clergy of almost all religions of the world against those who do not conform to their faith. Even Islam is presented by most medieval scholars as the only door to salvation, in the sense that ever since the advent of Islam, all the descendants of Adamas who have lived and died outside the pale of Islam are denied salvation. Christianity does not offer a different view, nor does any religion to my knowledge. But let me assure my audience that the attribution of this bigoted and narrow view to Islam has no justification. The Holy Qur’an has a completely different story to tell us in this regard. According to the Holy Qur’an, salvation cannot be monopolised by any single religion of the world. Even if new truths are revealed and === PDF-Seite 43 === Inter-Religious Peace 21
new eras of light have dawned, those who live a life of ignorance through no fault of their own and those who generally try to lead a life of truth even if they inherited false ideologies, will not be denied salvation by God. The following verses from the Holy Qur’an elaborate this point further: