Foreword
Khilafat-e-Rashidah, Part 24
The second objection they have is that in this verse it is said:
“As He made Successors from among those
who were before them.”
The earlier nations were granted Khilafat by Prophethood or by kingship, so the comparison can be considered valid only up to this extent. The critics concede that there would be prophets and kings amongst Muslims, but they then say that the type of Khilafat in which we believe comes neither under Prophethood nor under a Muslim kingdom. So then what is the argument for its establishment?
The third objection is that even if we take the model of the Khilafat which came after the Holy Prophet (sa), it was accompanied with a government. Therefore, it would come under:
“and He made you kings.”
How does this then justify the Khilafat of Jama‘ate-Ahmadiyya, which is neither a Khilafat of Prophethood nor kingship?
The fourth objection that is contained in the promise in this verse, is taken to refer to a Jama‘at which means that some persons will be Prophets in this ummah and some will be the kings. However, the Khilafat of Prophethood was terminated by the Holy Prophet (sa) because it is a shared belief that the types of Prophets who came before, cannot come again. Moreover, it is a shared belief that the previous Khulafa’ were not considered as kings. As it is mentioned in the Ahadith:
“The Holy Prophet (sa) said, Prophethood will remain among you as long as God desires, then God will take back this blessing, and will bless you with Khilafat on the pattern of Prophethood, and it will remain among you as long as God desires, then God will take it back, and will establish kingdom as long as He desires.”
The critics conclude that the Holy Prophet (sa) did not consider the Khulafa’ to be kings as it is said that there will be Khilafat and then the kingdom. It shows that the people of Ummat-e-Muhammadiyyah can get neither Khilafat of Prophethood, nor of kingship. Therefore, there is no proof of any personal Khilafat in this verse, but only of a Khilafat of the community as a whole; and nobody can object to that.
Reply to the Question that the Promise is Made with the Muslim ummah, and not with Some Individuals
Now I will respond to the following questions. The first question is that the promise made in this verse is with the Muslim ummah, and not with only some individuals. My answer is:
No doubt, the promise is made with the nation but it does not mean that it is not to be fulfilled through some individuals. Some promises are made with a nation but they are fulfilled through certain persons, and it is said that the promise made with a nation is fulfilled. The incidents of it are available in every language, e.g. in our language it is said that English are the kings. Does it mean that every Englishman is a king? Every Englishman is neither a king nor can be a king. Even then it is said that the English are the kings. Similarly, it is said that a certain nation is the ruler, whereas the whole nation cannot possibly be the ruler, a few people are in charge of the government and the rest of them are their subordinates. Sometimes it is said that such a nation is very rich but it does not mean that every one person of that nation is rich. It is usually said that the British people are very rich but there are also very poor people amongst them. Our elder brother Mirza Sultan Ahmad (deceased) once told me that when he was in London, the house maid threw out the waste of the house. Suddenly an English boy rushed to it, picked up a piece of bread and ate it.
Similarly, I have seen women going out with pots on their heads to fetch water in Brindisi, and the pants of their children patched with different pieces of cloths. Even then it is said that the English are very rich.
Therefore, the promise made with a nation does not mean that it is not fulfilled through some individuals. Many promises are made with a nation but they are fulfilled through individuals. An incident of it is available in the Holy Qur’an. Allah, the Almighty says:
When Musa (Moses) reminded the people to call to their minds Allah’s favours upon them and the appointment of Prophets amongst them and also
[and He made you kings]. Can anybody prove that every person of Bani Isra’il were kings? Surely there were very poor people in Bani Isra’il, but Musa (Moses) said to them, that He made you all kings. The import is that when there are kings in any nation, the whole nation shares the favours and blessings of the kingdom. In other words, we can say that the nation has been granted the kingdom. So in the light of the verse [and He made you kings], it does not mean that every Jew became a king. Then how can we conclude from:
“Allah has promised to those among you who
believe and do good works that He will surely
make them Successors in the earth, as He made
Successors from among those who were before
them.”
That this promise should not be fulfilled through some individuals, but every member of ummah should get the blessings of Khilafat. Is it not strange that Allah, the Almighty says about Jews that He
[made you kings]? The commentators say without any hesitation that though few people became kings, as the standard of living of the common man was raised, it could be said that they were all granted the kingdom. But when Allah, the Almighty says: