Foreword

Khilafat-e-Rashidah, Part 33

It should be remembered that his crookedness means open infidelity, mentioned in Ahadith. What Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) told them was: “As long as I practice Islam, it is obligatory upon you to obey me, and if I abandon Islam and commit open infidelity, then it is obligatory upon you to check me”.

Otherwise it did not condone criticism of his daily routine following whatever corresponded to their will.

If anybody asks whether Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) could commit open infidelity, the answer would begin by questioning whether Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) could be crooked that the Muslims would feel the need to set him right. Such a condition could only be created when the Companions (ra) proved from the Holy Qur’an and Ahadith that he had gone against the word of the Holy Qur’an and Ahadith. Was it possible for Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) to take a step against the Holy Qur’an and Ahadith? And for the Muslims to feel the need to set him right by force? Such type of crookedness and open infidelity was not possible for him. But to make it clear he stated that the eternal truth is the greatest of all things. It did not mean (God forbid) that he could commit the open infidelity. But it was his contention that being in the position of Khalifah, it was his job to spread the teachings of his Prophet (sa) and obedience in the real sense. Therefore, he pointed out to them that the eternal truth is above everything, and they should never leave the real teaching even if he himself spoke against it.

Now I will tell you that such types of proverbial sayings are present in the Holy Qur’an. Hadrat Shuaib (as) said:

“And it behoves us not to return thereto except

that Allah, our Lord should so will.”

When the infidels asked Hadrat Shuaib (as) to join them, he said that it was totally impossible to join their religion except that his God should so will. Now can anybody say that it was possible to make Hadrat Shuaib (as) an infidel? Surely it was not possible for him to be an infidel, because he was a Prophet of Allah, the Almighty. The purpose was to demonstrate the position and greatness of Allah, the Almighty. It was impossible for him to be an infidel. There is no greatness of his self, but this position he had achieved was only by the help of Allah, the Almighty. This virtue vanishes if He is not there.

Similarly Allah, the Almighty made the Holy Prophet (sa) speak such words. The Holy Qur’an reveals:

“O Muhammad (sa), tell the people that if there

had been a son of God, you would have been

the first of the worshipers.”

The verse does not mean that there is a possibility of a son being born to Allah, the Almighty. It only means that there is surely no son to God. If there had been, then a person like the Holy Prophet (sa), the most obedient, would have been the first to worship him.

In short, it was totally impossible for Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) to commit open infidelity. But just to impress upon the minds of the people the importance of the eternal truth, he said, “If I also go against it, then do not care of me.”

Similar is an event of the Promised Messiah (as). There was a person named Miyań Nizam Din in his age. When the Promised Messiah (as) claimed that ‘Isa (as) (Jesus Christ) had died, it created uproar in the whole of India. In those days Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) was in Lahore taking leave for few days from Jammu. Maulawi Muhammad Husain Batalwi also reached there and gave a challenge of debate to him on this issue in the light of Ahadith. Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) made it clear that Ahadith is not dominant over the Holy Qur’an, so they should decide the matter in the light of the verses of the Holy Qur’an. The controversy continued for many days, and posters were also published by each side. Miyań Nizam Din was the friend of Maulawi Muhammad Husain, and was also close to the Promised Messiah (as). He decided to resolve this issue. He thought that Mirza Sahib, a pious man, could not say anything contrary to the Holy Qur’an. He must have told something to Maulawi Muhammad Husain which he could not comprehend, and so Maulawi Muhammad Husain had gotten ready to oppose it with passion; otherwise how could he possibly deny the physical life of ‘Isa (as) (Jesus Christ) which is evident from the Holy Qur’an? A pious and righteous person like Mirza Sahib could not claim the death of ‘Isa (as) (Jesus Christ) contrary to the Holy Qur’an. He came to Qadian with great fervour and asked the Promised Messiah (as) that he had heard his claim about the death of ‘Isa (as) (Jesus Christ). He affirmed his claim. He said that if it was proved from the Holy Qur’an that ‘Isa (as) (Jesus Christ) was alive physically then he would abandon his belief. The Promised Messiah (as) replied, “If the physical life of ‘Isa (as) (Jesus Christ) should be proved from the Holy Qur’an, then I will certainly believe him to be alive.” On hearing it he became very pleased and said that he already had in mind that as Mirza Sahib was very pious man, he could not say deliberately anything contrary to the Holy Qur’an. He must have misunderstood something, and if it is removed then it would not be difficult to get him to believe in the physical life of ‘Isa (as) (Jesus Christ). Thus he asked, “If I bring out hundred verses from the Holy Qur’an to prove the physical life of ‘Isa (as) (Jesus Christ), then will you believe it?” The Promised Messiah (as) said,

“Leave the hundred, even one verse is sufficient for me.” He said, “If not one-hundred, I’ll surely bring fifty”. The Promised Messiah (as) said, “I have told you that for me only one verse is sufficient. There is no question of hundred or fifty.” He again asked, “If it is so, then I’ll surely bring ten such verses to prove the physical living of ‘Isa (as) (Jesus Christ).” He went straight to Lahore, and met Maulawi Muhammad Husain. In the meanwhile the debate of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) and Maulawi Muhammad Husain Batalwi became prolonged for a period. Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) admitted under pressure that supporting Ahadith from Bukhari could be presented along with the Holy Qur’an. Maulawi Muhammad Husain Batalwi was very pleased with this victory, and was boasting with great zeal that he had persuaded Nuruddin (ra) very much, and knocked him down in such a manner that he, at last, had to admit that Ahadith could be presented along with the Holy Qur’an. It was just by chance that Miyań Nizam Din encountered him when he was boasting. He asked him to leave the debate aside, and said that on his visit to Qadian he had got the consent of Mirza Sahib that if he brought out ten such verses to prove the physical living of ‘Isa (as) (Jesus Christ), he would abandon his belief, and he demanded to give him ten such verses hurriedly to resolve the dispute, so that he could get Mirza Sahib to believe in the physical life of ‘Isa (as) (Jesus Christ) in the sky.

When Maulawi Muhammad Husain Batalwi, who was proudly saying that he persuaded Nuruddin (ra) so much that he had to accept his defeat, heard the words of Miyań Nizam Din he flared up and said angrily, “Who was so foolish to ask you to go to Mirza Sahib. In two months I brought Nuruddin (ra) to Ahadith with great struggle, and again you have turned the direction of the debate towards the Holy Qur’an.” He [Miyań Nizam Din] was a noble man, and when he heard this, he remained quiet for some time wonderstruck. Then he addressed him, “O Maulawi Sahib, if there is no proof of the physical life of ‘Isa (as) (Jesus Christ), then where there is the Holy Qur’an, there am I.” Saying this he went to the Promised Messiah (as) and took his Bai‘at.

Now look how Allah, the Almighty clarified this fact to the Promised Messiah (as) that ‘Isa (as) (Jesus Christ) had died, and while proving this with reason from the Holy Qur’an and Ahadith, he said, “If you bring even one verse against it, I am ready to abandon my belief.” Can anybody say that it means the Promised Messiah (as) (God forbid) did not have absolute certainty about it, and that he had any thought of any verse against his own beliefs? If anybody presumes it, he will be a great fool, because when he asked to bring even a single verse to show the physical living of ‘Isa (as) (Jesus Christ) he would abandon his belief, it was said to keep in view the greatness and nobleness of the Holy Qur’an. It was his objective that he would abandon his belief if it were contrary to a single verse of the Holy Qur’an. It was not his objective to mention that he had a belief against the Holy Qur’an. Similarly the saying of Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) did not mean that he could commit an open infidelity. But it means that truth should always be obeyed, and for this there is no question of any specific individual. “If I also commit such thing then you can disobey me.” It did not mean that he could ever act against the command of God and His Messenger, nor did it mean so in the presence of the command, “Obey Allah, and obey His Messenger and those who are in authority among you,” in the verse of Succession.

Verse of Succession and the Second

·

10 of 10 left today