Foreword

Khilafat-e-Rashidah, Part 6

Government has a specific jurisdiction. When we identify a government, it must have some necessary features. Some of them are:

(1) There must be a specified boundary of a

country’s government, i.e. whatever the

organization is, it must have a boundary and

jurisdiction from one place to another.

Boundaries are an important feature of

government.

(2) Government has the power to restrict the

financial, personal, and civic liberties of people.

For instance, government has the power to

imprison someone, to expel someone from the

country, or collect revenue by force. Similarly, it

can impose restrictions on personal liberty. For

instance, it can order the youth to join the army

or it can call volunteers at a time of need. (3) It has the power to levy and collect taxes. Similarly, it has the power to make treaties with sovereign countries, to make laws for immigrants and emigrants, and to regulate business and trade. It has the power of Qada. In short, all of these functions fall within the jurisdiction of government, and it has the power to deal with them in its own way. Particularly, the existence of boundaries is a necessary requisite for government, for boundaries enable it to delimit the geographical extent of the implementation of its laws. It is also essential for foreigners who come into those boundaries to obey the laws of the country. One who goes out of the boundaries also goes, to a certain extent, outside the reach of the laws of that government. Thus, government is obliged to issue orders in certain matters, to prohibit certain other matters, and to impose restrictions on financial, personal, and civic liberties at times of need. It has the power to collect taxes, recruit for the army, enter into treaties, and render justice. Now let us see whether the Prophet (sa) was given all of these powers or not.

First are the boundaries of a country. The empowerment of the Prophet (sa) in this regard is clear, since he declared that no one could live within a specific area except for Muslims. If someone else were to come, he would be expelled. Second, rules were enforced for those people living there. Similarly, Allah, the Almighty empowered him to conclude treaties with others, or to terminate them with certain conditions when he considered the need for it. He was given the power to collect taxes, and to restrict financial, personal, and civic liberties. Therefore, all powers of government were given to the Prophet (sa) by Allah. Government orders the legality of certain things and prohibits others; it checks the financial, personal, and civic liberties of people in certain circumstances. Allah, the Almighty empowered him to take their property, collect taxes, and demand their lives for war. He was empowered to expel unwanted people from his country. Justice is also an obligation of government. Government has the power to issue a decree, i.e. the final verdict, and Islam gives that authority to the Prophet (sa) and declares his decision to be final. The Prophet (sa) was not bound to comply with all of the wishes of the people, but they were obliged to submit totally, because compliance to their wishes in most matters could have dangerous consequences. Thus, it is proven from these verses that the Prophet’s (sa) management of the affairs of government was not an interim arrangement, but was a part of sharia. As the commands of Salat and Fasting etc. are a part of religion, so is the organization of the government of the Prophet (sa). It cannot, in any way, be called worldly or interim.

Were Commands Related to

Establishment of an Organization only for the Prophet (sa)?

The plea of those who deny the need for Khilafat, that “Islam does not present any definite organization”, is open to this critique, that by accepting the part of the Prophet’s (sa) work pertaining to the organization as having no religious sanction, it will also have to be accepted that his work was simply to meet provisional needs. Ali bin Abdur Razzaq has also realized this. As an intelligent person, he is apprehensive of opposition from people who may object that when the Holy Qur’an contains commands pertaining to government, how can he call the acts of the Prophet (sa) interim and claim that Islam does not present any specific organization. He has tried to find a way out by saying that the government of the Prophet (sa) was the government of Prophethood and love, and not a kingdom. He says that, though the Prophet (sa) gave many directives, they were all the commands of a Prophet, not that of the head of an institution. Since the commands were not of the head of an institution, they cannot be delegated to others. As all those commands were given in the capacity of a Prophet, they ceased to be operative upon his death. The powers which the Prophet (sa) exercised were specific to his Prophethood. People greatly loved him, and as a result, they obeyed his commands. This was the case at the time of the Prophet (sa). The Companions (ra) loved him intensely and were always ready to obey him, even at the cost of their lives. Thus, they obeyed all of his commands, for they loved him and he was their beloved, and lovers always obey their beloved. However, this does not mean that all those commands became obligatory for all time. They were only concerned with him, and when he died, the applicability of these commands ended.

The plea of Ali bin Abdur Razzaq is valid to the extent that the companions of a Prophet have an intense love for their Prophet. We are eyewitnesses of the fact that thousands of members of our community imitated the acts of the Promised Messiah (as). Once, someone raised the objection, in the presence of the Promised Messiah (as), that some members of his Community shaved their beard. The Promised Messiah (as) said: “Once they acquire perfect love, they will automatically start maintaining a beard because I have one; there would, then, be no need of any advice or directive”.

There is no doubt that the love between a Prophet and his followers is so intense that its like cannot be found in worldly relationships. In fact, sometime, in the intensity of love, man apparently ignores sensibility. It was the habit of Hadrat Abdullah bin Umar (ra) that whenever he went for Hajj, he used to sit at one place to pass water. Someone enquired of him why he did thus. He replied, “The fact is that the Prophet (sa) once sat here to pass water. Whenever I come here, it brings to my mind the act of the Prophet (sa) and I sit here for a short time without fail.”

In love, sometimes a person does such things in imitation as are apparently senseless. Thus, we accept that the Companions (ra) loved the Prophet (sa) and obeyed him completely. But here, the question is not whether they obeyed him due to their love for him or because they were under some pressure. The question is whether Islam gave the Prophet (sa) any power to rule a country and its people or not? Similarly, was he given power over those who disobeyed those commands? If the Holy Qur’an had mentioned only commands without prescribing punishments for those who did not comply, then it could be said that the Prophet (sa) issued commands and the Companions (ra) obeyed them due to their love for him. However, we see that this is not the case, because punishments are also prescribed. It is said, on committing such and such crime, one will receive this punishment, and for some other crime, one will receive that punishment. Since the Holy Qur’an has prescribed punishments, the rule of love is not correct in its entirety, for punishments are not prescribed when the compliance of commands is attached with love only.

Islam has not simply given some commands, but it has also detailed the organization of government. Where details are given, there it has kept the door of consensus open for people so that rational mental faculties may not go to waste. Therefore, in some matters, Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) applied his judgment and presented the real Islamic issue before people.

Similarly Hadrat Umar (ra), Hadrat Usman (ra), and Hadrat Ali (ra) guided people according to the prevailing circumstances. Indeed, there are some matters which are still under consideration.

For instance, when the Nikah (announcement of marriage) of a daughter is agreed by her father before the daughter’s age of puberty, does she have the right to nullify it upon attaining puberty or not? This is a question which continuously arises. It is mentioned in the old books of Fiqah (Islamic jurisprudence) that if a father makes the Nikah of his daughter, then she has no right to break it on attaining puberty, but I have concluded that a girl has that right, and if she does not like the match, she can refuse it. Similarly, there are so many issues of Fiqah which continuously arise, and a number of them will come up in the future.

We are not concerned with details of whether Islam gave a specific form of government to the Prophet (sa), because there are various forms of government. The form of the government of England is different from America, America’s from Russia, and Russia’s from Germany. However, due to these differences, we cannot say that one is a government and that the other is not. Government means that a specific organization should be chosen and established within national boundaries, and the reigns of the people should be entrusted in the hands of a person or a party. Thus, we have to look at whether Islam enjoins an organization or not, irrespective of how different it may be from others, and whether the Prophet (sa) implemented that organization or not.

·

10 of 10 left today