Foreword
Life of Muhammad, Part 22
Christians have often cited this teaching of Jesus (as) and argued that Jesus (as) preached against war. But in the New Testament, we have passages which purport to teach quite the opposite. One passage, for instance, says:
Think not that I am come to send peace on earth: I came
not to send peace, but a sword (Matthew 10: 34).
And another passage says:
Then said he unto them. But now, he that hath a purse, let
him take it, and likewise his scrip: and he that hath no
sword, let him sell his garment, and buy one (Luke 22: 36).
Of the three verses the last two contradict the first. If Jesus (as) came for war, why did he teach about turning the other cheek? It seems we have either to admit a contradiction in the New Testament, or we have to explain one of the contradictory teachings in a suitable manner. We are not concerned here with the question whether turning the other cheek can ever be practicable. We are concerned only to point out that, throughout their long history, no Christian people have ever hesitated to make war. When Christians first attained to power in Rome, they took part in wars both defensive and aggressive. They are dominant powers in the world today, and they continue to take part in wars both defensive and aggressive. Only now the side which wins is canonized by the rest of the Christian world. Their victory is said to be the victory of Christian civilization. Christian civilization has come to mean whatever tends to be dominant and successful. When two Christian powers go to war, each claims to be the protector of
Christian ideals. The power which wins is canonized as the true Christian power. It is true, however, that from the time of Jesus (as) to our time, Christendom has been involved—and indications are that it will continue to remain involved—in war. The practical verdict of the Christian peoples, therefore, is that war is the real teaching of the New Testament, and that turning the other cheek was either an opportunist teaching dictated by the helplessness of early Christians, or it is meant to apply only to individuals, not to States and peoples.
Secondly, even if we assume that Jesus (as) taught peace and not war, it does not follow that those who do not act upon this teaching are not holy and honoured. For Christendom has ever revered exponents of war such as Moses (as), Joshua (as) and David (as). Not only this, the Church itself has canonized national heroes who suffered in wars. They were made saints by the Popes.
The teaching of Islam is different from both these teachings. It strikes a mean between the two. Islam does not teach aggression as did Moses (as). Nor does it, like present-day (and presumably corrupt) Christianity, preach a contradiction. It does not ask us to turn the other cheek and at the same time to sell our clothes to buy a sword. The teaching of Islam fits into the natural instincts of man, and promotes peace in the only possible way.
Islam forbids aggression, but it urges us to fight if failure to fight jeopardizes peace and promotes war. If failure to fight means the extirpation of free belief and of the search of truth, it is our duty to fight. This is the teaching on which peace can ultimately be built, and this is the teaching on which the Prophet (sa) based his own policies and his practice. The Prophet (sa) suffered continuously and consistently at Mecca but did not fight the aggression of which he was an innocent victim.
When he escaped to Medina, the enemy was out to extirpate Islam; it was, therefore, necessary to fight the enemy in defence of truth and freedom of belief.
We quote below the passages in the Holy Qur’an which bear on the subject of war.
(1) In 22: 40–42 we have:
Permission to fight is given to those against whom war is
made, because they have been wronged—and Allah indeed
has power to help them—Those who have been driven out
from their homes unjustly only because they said, "Our
Lord is Allah"—And if Allah did not repel some men by
means of others, there would surely have been pulled down
cloisters and churches and synagogues and mosques,
wherein the name of Allah is oft commemorated. And
Allah will surely help one who helps Him. Allah is indeed
Powerful, Mighty.—Those who, if We establish them in the
earth, will observe Prayer and pay the Zakat and enjoin
good and forbid evil. And with Allah rests the final issue of
all affairs.
The verse purports to say that permission to fight is given to the victims of aggression. God is well able to help the victims—those who have been driven out of their homes because of their beliefs. The permission is wise because, if God were not to repel the cruel with the help of the righteous, there would be no freedom of faith and worship in the world. God must help those who help to establish freedom and worship. It follows that fighting is permitted when a people have suffered long from wanton aggression—when the aggressor has had no cause for aggression and he seeks to interfere with the religion of his victim. The duty of the victim, if and when he attains to power, is to establish religious freedom and to protect all religions and all religious places. His power is to be used not for his own glorification, but for the care of the poor, the progress of the country and the general promotion of peace. This teaching is as unexceptionable as it is clear and precise. It proclaims the fact that early Muslims took to war because they were constrained to do so. Aggressive wars were forbidden by Islam. Muslims are promised political power, but are warned that this power must be used not for self-aggrandizement, but for the amelioration of the poor and the promotion of peace and progress.
(2) In (2: 191–194) we have:
And fight in the cause of Allah against those who fight
against you, but do not transgress. Surely, Allah loves not
transgressors. And kill them wherever you meet them and
drive them out from where they have driven you out; for