Fallacious Beliefs of Deobandis

The Magnificent Services of The Just Imam, The Promised Messiah

There seem to be two opposing concepts of God. Deobandis, another faction of ulema, have a different conception about God. Both Barelwis and Deobandis keep squabbling with each other over their conflicting views. The Barelwis contend that God’s status and power are shared not only with mortal humans, but also with the

7. …on any other that can neither profit thee nor harm thee… (Surah Yunus, 10:107)

[ 12 ]

khutba16.book Page 13 Friday, August 10, 2012 12:40 PM

A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam

dead. The Deobandis, on the other hand, include God among the sinful humans. They assert that God has the power to commit sin and, thus, this subject becomes the point of contention among them. A Deobandi book states the following: Hence, we do not accept that it is impossible for God to lie, because that would mean that the human powers are greater than those of God. (Yak-Rozi, written by Maulavi Muhammad Ismail, Matba Faruqi, p. 145, line 1, quoted in Deobandi Madh-hab, by Ghulam Mehr ‘Ali Golarhvi, p. 100, Kutub Khanah Mehriyyah Manzil, Mandi Chistiyian Sharif, District Bahawal Nagar, Pakistan)

The maulavis have lengthy debates on this topic. The issue is not merely the possibility of lying; they go much further in their contention: Now how can we keep illicit behaviour out of the reach of the everlasting powers of God the Almighty. The illicit actions are within the power of God the Almighty. The righteous people recognise illicit actions among the other possibilities under the power of the Most High. (al-Juhadul-Maqall, part 1, p. 41, quoted in Deobandi Madh-hab, by Ghulam Mehr ‘Ali Golar- hvi, p. 102, Kutub Khanah Mehriyyah Manzil, Mandi Chistiyian Sharif, District Bahawal Nagar, Pakistan)

[ 13 ]

khutba16.book Page 14 Friday, August 10, 2012 12:40 PM

Magnificent Services of the Just Imam, the Promised Messiahas, to Reform the Mutual Controversies and Distorted Beliefs of the Muslims

The so-called illicit behaviour that they associate with God the Almighty cannot be quoted. Even though the words have been uttered by others, I feel embarrassed in narrating them. They have gone to the point of saying that theft, drinking and injustice are all within the power of God and to deny this power amounts to ignorance. Their argument is that whatever is within the power of man is within the power of God. (For details see, Tadhkiratul-Khalil, written by Ashiq ‘Ali Mirathi, printed at Maktabah Qasimiyyah Rang Purah Road, Sialkot City, Pakistan, Rabi‘ul-Awwal 4, 1389, May 1969, Article by Mahmud Hasan, quoted in the newspaper Nizamul-Mulk, Aug. 25, 1889) Their argument is that whatever is within the power of man is within the power of God. Both of these viewpoints have played a disgraceful role in slanting the concept of Allah. One upgrades the rank of people to God and the other downgrades the rank of God to the level of people. The God they speak of is not the God Who revealed Himself to the Holy Prophet Muhammadsa. This is not the God Who is the God of the universe and Who is without any errors, Whose praise and glorification is sung day and night, even by things considered lifeless by us. How can one compare their theories with the beautiful concept of Allah! We only recognise the God of our master Hadrat Muhammadsa and declare with full force that if you [non- Ahmadis] believe in the God that you have mentioned in

[ 14 ]

khutba16.book Page 15 Friday, August 10, 2012 12:40 PM

A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam

your writings, then by God, our God is different from yours. It is shocking to see how many stories have been fabricated to belittle the Divinity of God in order to associate man with his Creator. In a fable relating the miracles of Hadrat Sayyed Abdul Qadir Jilanirta, there is a story of his recovering a boat full of people that had drowned in a river twelve years ago. A well known Barelwi book, Guldasta-e-Karamat, tells the story of an old woman who was traveling with her only son’s wedding procession. While crossing a river, their boat sank and she lost her son. The old woman kept returning to the river regularly, with the excuse of fetching water, to mourn the loss of her son for twelve years. One day, Hadrat Abdul Qadir Jilanirta saw her and enquired about her grief. The old woman told him about her loss and he replied, ‘No problem.’ Then he focused his attention to the river and retrieved the boat that had sunk twelve years ago. All the drowned people, including the bride and groom, disembarked the boat happily. (See Guldasta-e-Karamat, pp. 21–22, published in 1861 CE (1377 AH), written by Mufti Ghulam Sarwar.) This is their concept of God! They make human beings partners in the divinity by ascribing to them the power of bringing the dead—even those who died twelve years back—to life.

[ 15 ]

khutba16.book Page 16 Friday, August 10, 2012 12:40 PM

Magnificent Services of the Just Imam, the Promised Messiahas, to Reform the Mutual Controversies and Distorted Beliefs of the Muslims

10 of 10 left today