A Ridiculous Accusation Against Hadrat Dawud(as)
The Magnificent Services of The Just Imam, The Promised Messiah
Hadrat Dawudas is a noble and great Prophet of God. If you read the Zabur (Book of Psalms) you will notice that he is a Prophet who is very much in love with God and who always sings the praises of God’s Holiness. The Holy Qur’an has mentioned the Zabur with great love and respect. However, the commentaries Tafsir Jami‘ul-Bayan and
[ 34 ]
khutba16.book Page 35 Friday, August 10, 2012 12:40 PM
A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam
Tafsir al-Baghawi fi Hashiyati Tafsiril-Khazin give the following account regarding Hadrat Dawudas while commenting on the verse:18 ... Hadrat Dawudas was in the balcony reciting the Zabur, i.e., singing songs of God’s praise, when Satan in the guise of a little golden bird fell near him.
Now how could he let this golden bird escape? The account continues: So he rose to catch it. The bird flew to a parapet.
Thus, the Prophet set the Zabur aside and forgot about singing God’s praises, as he saw a piece of gold and ran after it (God forbid). This is about the Prophet who was given more gold and precious gems than any other Prophet, but according to the commentators, his greed was such that he ran to catch a golden bird while neglecting his worship. It continues: When he climbed to the parapet he saw a woman bathing in the garden beyond.
Now he forgot about the bird! The story continues: He fell in love with her at first sight and later conspired to send her husband to die on a war front, and then married her. Before this, Hadrat Dawudas
18. Surah Sad, 38:22–26
[ 35 ]
khutba16.book Page 36 Friday, August 10, 2012 12:40 PM
Magnificent Services of the Just Imam, the Promised Messiahas, to Reform the Mutual Controversies and Distorted Beliefs of the Muslims
had 99 wives. (For details see, (a) Tafsir Jami‘ul- Bayan, (b) Tafsir Al-Baghawi fi Hashiyati Tafsiril- Khazin, commentary of Surah Sad, 38:22–26 (c) Tafsir Jalalain ma‘ Kamalain, by Jalalud-Din Muhammad bin Ahmad al-Mahalli and Jalalud-Din Abdur-Rahman bin Abu Bakr as-Suyuti, under verse of Surah Sad, 38:22–26)
Such are their commentaries and such are their concepts of the Prophets of God. We seek Allah’s protection from this. These days, if anything of this kind is mentioned about even an ordinary ruler, he would defend himself forcefully and a great debate would ensure about such accusations. If such a thing were found to be true, there would be a revo- lution. If it were proven against any ruler that he unjustly caused the death of a general—just to marry his wife—it would be considered a great crime. This would be a great crime even for an ordinary atheist. However, these com- mentators maintain that a Prophet of God who holds a high stature amongst Prophets and whom the Holy Qur’an men- tions with great love and respect, fell madly in love with another person’s wife. As a matter of fact, they have tried to undermine the gift that God had given Hadrat Dawudas and in doing so, they have not been mindful of God. It is possible that they did so in ignorance, but their ignorance seems to be limitless. Wherever Allah shows that His Prophets were pure and innocent, these commentators try to prove otherwise. All the verses that the commentators
[ 36 ]
khutba16.book Page 37 Friday, August 10, 2012 12:40 PM
A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam
have tried to use as accusations of crime against the Prophets, were in fact revealed by Allah to defend Prophets from exactly these kinds of accusations. Wherever Allah cites the princely example of the good character traits of his Prophets, these commentators try to negate it. Instead of appreciating the Prophets, they come up with an evil and undesirable connotation.