Grim Impertinences Against the Holy Prophet Muhammad(sa)

The Magnificent Services of The Just Imam, The Promised Messiah

Both Shia and Sunni scholars have made many other ridiculous statements. Scholars from both sides have used horrendous words, which reflects their ignorance. One prominent Deobandi scholar, discussing the Holy Prophet sa, states: Being superior to the Angel of Death does not prove at all that his (the Holy Prophet sa) knowledge regard- ing these matters is even equal to the Angel of Death, being greater is yet another thing. (al-Barahinul- Qati‘ah, w ritten by Khalil Ahmad [president Madrasah Deobandiyyah Saharan Pur], p. 56, Darul- Isha‘at, Urdu Bazar, M.A. Jinnah Road, Karachi, First Edition, March 1987)

In other words, Deobandis and Barelwis have been debating between each other about the level of the knowledge of the Holy Prophet sa. It is a pity that people who are themselves ignorant are issuing edicts regarding

[ 47 ]

khutba16.book Page 48 Friday, August 10, 2012 12:40 PM

Magnificent Services of the Just Imam, the Promised Messiahas, to Reform the Mutual Controversies and Distorted Beliefs of the Muslims

the knowledge of the Holy Prophet Muhammadsa. Both parties make rude remarks about the Holy Prophet sa. It is mind-boggling to see the nature of their discussions. They have argued whether or not the Holy Prophet sa is omnipresent. One group claims that if one does not believe in the omnipresence of the Holy Prophet sa, he is out of the pale of Islam! The other group raises the question that if he is omnipresent, is he watching over them while they have intimate relations with their wives? The first group confirms his presence but affirms that he keeps his eyes down due to modesty. They have created a ridiculous perception of the status of the Holy Prophet sa. They have twisted the concept of God and tarnished the pure and elite status of the Holy Prophet sa. They have not left any aspect of the sublime character of the Holy Prophet sa unsullied. They present such a twisted teaching of Islam to the world that any person in his right mind would never find any common sense in it. Yet, they reject the Reformer appointed by God. They do not relent for a moment from employing abusive language against the one who has been called ‘the Arbiter’ and ‘the Just.’ Another shameful and ignorant example of the comparison made by the Deobandis is, and I quote: It is a matter for deep deliberation that to argue—on the basis of knowledge granted to Satan and the Angel of Death—that the Holy Prophetsa had knowl- edge encompassing the whole world, amounts to

[ 48 ]

khutba16.book Page 49 Friday, August 10, 2012 12:40 PM

A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam

apostasy and has no element of faith, as it is done only on the basis of conjecture and lacks any firm authority. (al-Barahinul-Qati‘ah, written by Khalil Ahmad, [president Madrasah Deobandiyyah Saharan Pur], p. 55, Darul-Isha‘at, Urdu Bazar, M.A. Jinnah Road, Karachi, First Edition, March 1987)

The text is very complicated and may not be fully understood by many. To summarize, the impertinent writer is discussing whether the knowledge of the accursed Satan is greater than that of the Holy Prophetsa. If one has even an iota of love and respect for someone, he never compares that beloved one with a shameful example. These people do not feel ashamed in comparing the knowledge of the Holy Prophet sa with Satan. I am outraged! How dare they compare the Holy Prophet’s sa knowledge with that of Satan. One group is proudly and enthusiastically declaring that the knowledge of the Holy Prophet sa was greater than Satan’s, while the opposing group is retorting back that the knowledge of the Holy Prophet sa was (God forbid) less than Satan’s. This is how they express their love and affection and this is their concept about the Holy Prophet sa. They do not have control over their uncouth tongue. Ashraf ‘Ali Thanwi writes: If the Holy Prophet’s sa revered personage had the knowledge of the unseen and it is with Divine decree, then the question is whether this knowledge of the

[ 49 ]

10 of 10 left today