Offences Against the Holy Prophet Muhammad(sa) by the So-Called Upholders of the Unity of God

The Magnificent Services of The Just Imam, The Promised Messiah

khutba16.book Page 50 Friday, August 10, 2012 12:40 PM

Magnificent Services of the Just Imam, the Promised Messiahas, to Reform the Mutual Controversies and Distorted Beliefs of the Muslims

unseen was partial or complete. If it is meant to be the knowledge about only some matters, then this quality is not unique for Hudur sa [The Holy Prophet Muhammadsa], as partial knowledge of the unseen has been given even to non-prophets... (Hifzul-Iman ‘Aniz-Zaighi wat-Tughyan, written by Ashraf ‘Ali Thanwi, p. 92, published by Anjuman Irshadul- Muslimin, Lahore, Pakistan, Shawwal, 1400 Hijra, September 1980)

It is good to provide reasoning against a false concept but one ought not to be rude. It is unbearable for us to see such rudeness of comparing the Holy Prophet sa to non- prophets.

Offences Against the Holy Prophet Mu h a m m a d sa by the So- Called Upholders of the Unity of God

There are other outspoken self-righteous people, who brand the Barelwis as pagans because they exaggerate the status of the Holy Prophet sa and thereby associate partners with God. They allege that the Barelwis hold two pagan beliefs: association of partners in Prophethood and part- ners with God. They proclaim that the Barelwis associate partners in the oneness of God and join other saints in the holiness of the Holy Prophet sa . These accusers make tall claims of upholding the Unity of God. They seem to forget that they themselves have committed serious transgressions against the Holy Prophet sa. An example of an insult to the

[ 50 ]

khutba16.book Page 51 Friday, August 10, 2012 12:40 PM

A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam

Holy Prophet sa and the exaltation to their own scholars is found in the elegy by Maulavi Mahmud Hasan in the memory of Maulvai Rashid Ahmad Gangohi:

In this couplet he declares Maulavi Rashid Ahmad to be a duplicate of the Holy Prophet sa (God forbid) and says that because of him the opponents are raising the slogans for their idols. Then he says:

God was his teacher and he was the teacher of mankind My lord, my guide was certainly a scholar divine People—who still maintain zest for knowledge and wisdom in their bosoms— will wander in Ka‘bah, asking for the way to Gangoh

Such is their wisdom. He is claiming that Maulavi Rashid Ahmad of Gangoh is an equal to the Holy Prophet sa and Gangoh is not just the equal of the Ka‘bah but a place to which the Ka‘bah directs the people. He further mentions that he would not be spiritually content in the Ka‘bah,

[ 51 ]

khutba16.book Page 52 Friday, August 10, 2012 12:40 PM

Magnificent Services of the Just Imam, the Promised Messiahas, to Reform the Mutual Controversies and Distorted Beliefs of the Muslims

rather he would be asking the way to Gangoh [India]. Then Maulavi Mahmud Hasan says that:

By comparing your enlightened tomb to Mount Sinai, I keep pleading again and again ‘show me your face.’ See how simple I am!

It could be simple-mindedness, of course, that by comparing his grave with Mount Sinai, he disrespected Mount Sinai. In that sense the couplet would not be open to criticism. But there is another sense in which such expressions are used. Ghalib has a similar couplet:

I called him Yusufas [Joseph] and he did not reprimand me—that is well and good; But if he had reprimanded me, that would have been fully justified!

Even if we assume that he meant the expression in the first sense, a mistake once or twice might be forgivable, but he says that he is repeating it continuously:

(See Mersiyah, by Mahmud Hasan, President Deoband, p. 6–17, Published by Mat’ba‘ Bilali, Sadhora, Ambala Distt.)

[ 52 ]

khutba16.book Page 53 Friday, August 10, 2012 12:40 PM

A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam

This is not simple-mindedness. This is an offence—an offence so major that he is comparing the tomb of a maulavi with Mount Sinai. He is addressing that tomb with using words with which Musaas addressed God Almighty. And still they claim to be the upholders of Unity! Let me give you an example of how they exalt their maulavis and muftis: Today at Jumu‘ah prayer our hearts were distressed with the announcement that Rahmatul-lil-‘Alamin24 (Mufti Muhammad Hasan Deobandi of Lahore) passed away from this world. (Tadhkirah Hasan, quoted from Monthly Tajalli-e-Deoband and Monthly Nuri Kiran, Breili, February 1963, quoted from Deobandi Madh-hab, p. 126–127, written by Ghulam Mehr ‘Ali Golarhvi, Kutub Khanah, Mehriyah Man- zil, Mandi Chishtiyan Sharif, Bahawalnagar Prov- ince)

They declare Deobandi Mufti Sahib as Rahmatul-lil- ‘Alamin—the title given to the Holy Prophet sa in the Holy Qur’an! Another scholar, Maulavi Ashraf ‘Ali Thanwi, has been mentioned in the following words: The Holy Prophet’ssa blessed complexion, features and body were just like those of Hadrat Maulana Ashraf ‘Ali. (Asdaqur Ro’ya’, part 2, p. 3, published in Dhul-Hijjah 1354 H. (also quoted in Deobandi

10 of 10 left today