A General Allegation with a New Slant

Majestic Writings of the Promised Messiah

There is an allegation of a general nature. It is said that: The Promised Messiahas issued a fatwa [edict] against jihad and praised the British; thus it is established that he and the Ahmadiyyah Community has been ‘planted’ by the British.

This allegation is now being made with a different slant. It is alleged that during the Sikh rule, Mirza Ghulam Murtada, the father of the Promised Messiahas, promoted the British cause by providing fifty horses and fifty trained fighters at his own expense during the mutiny of 1857, and so during this jihad he had sided with the British against the Muslims. Since during the time of the Promised Messiahas, the Muslims did not engage in any battle against the British in India which the critics could cite as an example to assert

[2]

khutba13.book Page 3 Monday, April 27, 2009 7:43 PM

A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam

that Mirza Sahib issued a fatwa against jihad, or even that he stopped the Muslims or placed obstacles in their path from engaging in jihad [against the British]. Therefore, they have come up with a far-fetched story and have cited the ancestors of the Promised Messiahas as having done so. The fact of the matter is that the basic assertion on which their argument is based on is totally false. The contemporary historians of Pakistan portray the events of the mutiny as though it was a Muslim jihad against the British and all the Muslims were united in fight- ing this jihad. This is absolutely false. Nothing of the sort ever happened. What history demonstrates is that during the last days of Bahadur Shah Zafar’s rule, some conspira- tors, spearheaded by the Hindus and the Buddhists of the time, not only surrounded the King but also forced some Muslim clerics into issuing a fatwa that declared the mutiny to be a jihad. So far as the Muslim populace is con- cerned, a large majority did not take part in it. Rather, Muslim scholars who were cognizant of Islamic doctrines and possessed insight and piety, openly declared it a rebel- lion and wrote that calling it jihad was totally unjustified. In fact, they used very harsh words about those who took part in the mutiny. Had this insurgency been successful, it would not have resulted in an Islamic government in India. Anyone with a modicum of historical knowledge will understand that the outcome of this mutiny would have been the replacement of the English government with a

[3]

khutba13.book Page 4 Monday, April 27, 2009 7:43 PM

Majestic Writings of the Promised Messiahas in View of Some Renowned Muslim Scholars

Hindu government, with the Hindus further undermining the lives of the Muslims. This was the writing on the wall. When the mutiny appeared imminent to many perceptive scholars, they not only refused to call it jihad but also issued explicit edicts against it.

10 of 10 left today