Deplorable Consequences of Perverted Logic
Majestic Writings of the Promised Messiah
If what you [the government of Pakistan] say is wisdom and what we say is folly, then by God we prefer our folly to your wisdom, since it is our ‘folly’ that glorifies Islam and its Founder—not your ‘wisdom’. You have started ascribing your ignorance to the Holy Prophetsa and the darkness of your soul to the Holy Qur’an. The one who descended on the minaret of light, offered you the light and strived to light the dark recesses of your soul—from him you turned away, closed all the windows of your mind, and refused to be enlightened. In the darkness of your soul, you scoff at the news that the sun has risen. What can we say except:
It seems that your hearts have been firmly bolted.
Meaningless Objections about the Command of Language
Another accusation against the Promised Messiahas is his diction. It is said that: ‘He was not capable of writing good Urdu; and since Mirza Sahib did not know how to write eloquently, he has put the religion of Islam in great jeop- ardy.’ The original accusation is worded as follows:
[ 24 ]
khutba13.book Page 25 Monday, April 27, 2009 7:43 PM
A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam
The writings of Mirza Sahib are dry and uninterest- ing, because his writings are without any intellectual content or literary merit; his handling of the issues is ineffectual and his compositions resemble third rate medieval expressions. He would severely berate his adversaries, and occasionally even use abusive lan- guage. Many of his writings are full of so-called prophecies, which are usually about the impending death of his opponents. (Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam, p. 13)
The sum total of the threat hovering over the Islamic world is that he (Mirza Sahib) was incapable of writing good Urdu, his style is without flair, and his writings lack humour and pun. Hence the man poses a grave threat to Islam! This accusation is completely false. The fact is that every word of the Promised Messiahas makes us ecstatic, inspires our souls, and kindles new life in us. If we pay tribute to his writings, then others may not accept it. Therefore, we ask the clerics of the past, who subscribed to a certain standard of piety; we research their prominent scholars, and their experts in Urdu literature, whose literary works were widely enjoyed by the Indian readership, for their objective appraisal of the Promised Messiah’sas writings. Maulana Abul Kalam Azad 9 , editor of the Urdu newspaper, Vakil of Amritsar, was an exceptional scholar and an eminent writer, whose diction and eloquence are
[ 25 ]
khutba13.book Page 26 Monday, April 27, 2009 7:43 PM
Majestic Writings of the Promised Messiahas in View of Some Renowned Muslim Scholars
self-evident from his literary works. The way he viewed the writings of Promised Messiah as is worthy of special attention. At the demise of the Promised Messiah as , respected Maulana Azad wrote: This man—the very pre-eminent personality— whose pen was a marvel and voice a magic. He was a monument of great intellectual wonders; his insight was revolutionary and his voice was charged with call of Judgement. His fingers moved the strings of refor- mation, and his two fists generated the thunderous lightning. The man who served as the epicentre of religious shock waves for thirty years, and awakened the sleeping souls of the world with his thunderous calls.
But could not awaken these unfortunate people! The quo- tation of Maulana Azad continues: This devastating death, this cup of poison death, which has laid the deceased in the belly of the earth, will always be lamented by millions. The strike of Divine decree has blatantly put an end to the hope
9. Some people have mistakenly attributed this writing to Maul- ana ‘Abdullah al-‘Imadi which is not correct. The magnificent style of writing clearly indicates that it is written by Maulana Abul Kalam Azad. This is also confirmed by his autobiogra- phy (Azad ki Kahani, Azad ki Zubani) which states on pages 309–310 that Maulana Azad himself used to write everything from lead articles to minor accounts. Maulana ‘Abdullah al- ‘Imadi was the editor of al-Bayan (Lucknow).
[ 26 ]
khutba13.book Page 27 Monday, April 27, 2009 7:43 PM
A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam
and aspirations of many, but their woeful cries will keep his memories alive for a long time.
Maulana Azad continues: Men who revolutionized the spiritual or intellectual world appear very seldom. But when such prides of the children of history do appear, they bring about a revolution in this world. The demise of Mirza Sahib, in spite of extreme differences over some of his claims and views, has made educated and enlightened Muslims realize that they have lost one of their pre- eminent personalities.
Now remember their remarks that the writings of the Promised Messiahas is without flair, and his writings lack humour and reasoning. The Maulana further writes: His distinction of serving as an ever victorious gen- eral against the opponents of Islam...
Our adversaries say that Mirza Sahib’s writings lack sub- stance and, besides prophesizing the deaths of his antago- nists, contributed nothing, but Maulana Abul Kalam Azad writes about the Promised Messiahas: His distinction of serving as an ever victorious gen- eral against the opponents of Islam compels us to openly and sincerely wish that the majestic move- ment which dwarfed and destroyed our enemies for a long time may continue in the future.
[ 27 ]
khutba13.book Page 28 Monday, April 27, 2009 7:43 PM
Majestic Writings of the Promised Messiahas in View of Some Renowned Muslim Scholars
O writer, may God bless your noble wish! This Movement still continues and will continue in the future. The Maulana further writes: The literature that Mirza Sahib produced against the Christians and Aryas has been acclaimed widely and as such does not need any introduction. Even today, now that it has fulfilled its purpose, we have to sin- cerely acknowledge its influence and magnificence. Our hearts can never forget the time when Islam was totally encircled by hostile attacks and Muslims, who were entrusted by the Real Protector [God Almighty] with the duty to defend Islam in the visible and per- ceptible worlds, were leading a miserable life as a penalty for their own vices. They did nothing for the defense of Islam, nor were they capable of it.