Revolutionary Impact of the Effect of Eloquent Writings

Majestic Writings of the Promised Messiah

These are the impressions of pre-eminent Muslim scholars, who had the fear of God, loved honesty, had refined taste, and whose writings have set the standard of Urdu litera- ture. Mirza Hairat Dehalvi, editor of the paper Curzon Gazette wrote about the writings of the Promised Messiahas and their influence in the June 1, 1908 issue of his paper: The great services the deceased rendered to Islam against Aryas and Christians deserves high commen- dations. He transformed the style of scholarly debate and laid the foundation of modern literature in India. Not only as a Muslim but also as a research scholars, I admit that not even the most eminent of the leading Aryas or Christian ministers had the courage to con- front the deceased. He wrote such unequalled books refuting Arya and Christian doctrines, and gave such devastating rebuttal to the opponents of Islam, that even to this day we have not seen any rejoinder to them based on sound reasoning. (Curzon Gazette, June 1, 1908)

The government of Pakistan is disturbed that the Promised Messiahas has left behind writings that neither Aryas nor Christians have been able to rebut. Even his adversaries had to concede that he gave devastating arguments in defense of

[ 31 ]

khutba13.book Page 32 Monday, April 27, 2009 7:43 PM

Majestic Writings of the Promised Messiahas in View of Some Renowned Muslim Scholars

Islam. What a great threat to the world of Islam! The White Paper asserts that [God forbid] the Promised Messiahas did nothing, except insult his opponents, and that there is nothing else in his writings. This does not only show their ignorance but is blatant falsification. They deliberately slander the Promised Messiah as . Otherwise, one must conclude that the ones making allegations have not read any of his books and have written without any investigation. It is nothing but fabrica- tion and deception. Now let me tell you who used insulting language. (I will provide some examples later). Mirza Hairat Dehalvi has mentioned the manners in which these debates were con- ducted, what was being presented by the Promised Messiahas, and what the tactics of his opponents were. He writes: I have not seen their counter-rebuttal except that the Aryas would abuse him in an uncivilized manner or use extremely foul language against the leaders and principles of Islam. But there was so much force in his pen that today there is no one in the entire Punjab or in all of India, who could write with similar force.

They were hurling abuses, but this stout defender of Islam had no need to resort to abusing. Mirza Hairat Dehalvi continues:

[ 32 ]

khutba13.book Page 33 Monday, April 27, 2009 7:43 PM

A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam

His brain had a treasure-house of words full of elo- quence and energy. When he wished to write, such a stream of measured and precise words would flow that it was beyond description. Those who did not know the late Maulavi Nur-ud-Din—the first caliph—mistakenly think that Maulavi Nur-ud-Din might have helped him in his writing, but from my personal knowledge I can say that the late Hakim Nur-ud-Din, compared to Mirza, could not even write a few lines. Despite the fact that his literature occasionally had a flavour of Punjabi in it, yet it had a unique grandeur. It is a fact that one would get enraptured by reading some of his passages.

Sayyed Mumtaz ‘Ali writes in Tehdhib-e-Niswan (Lahore): The late Mirza Sahib was a holy and noble personage. The force of his righteousness could subjugate even a hard-hearted person. He was an extremely erudite scholar, a dauntless reformer, and the epitome of noble deeds. Although, in the religious sense, I do not accept him as the Promised Messiah, yet his teachings and guidance did indeed breath new messianic life into the dead souls. (Tehdhib-e-Niswan, printed in Lahore, quoted in, Tash-hidhul-Adhhan, vol. 3, copy 10, p. 383, 1908)

The paper Sadiqul-Akhbar, Rewarhi, Bahawalpur, writes: Mirza Sahib has silenced the opponents of Islam by giving a crushing rebuttal to their vulgar allegations with his powerful speeches and superb writings. He

[ 33 ]

khutba13.book Page 34 Monday, April 27, 2009 7:43 PM

Majestic Writings of the Promised Messiahas in View of Some Renowned Muslim Scholars

proved that truth does prevail. It is a fact that Mirza Sahib defended Islam as it should have been done and left no avenues unexplored in the service of the faith. Justice demands that the sudden and untimely death of such a great and resolute champion of Islam, erudite theologian, helper of Muslims, and irreplace- able scholar should be mourned. (Sadiqul-Akhbar, quoted in, Tash-hidhul-Adhhan, vol. 3, copy 8, p. 382, 1908)

Khwajah Hassan Nizami was a famous and well-known writer. He was from a family of Urdu scholars that is widely respected in India. He was not a supporter of Ahmadiyyat, in fact, he was an opponent. He writes: Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Sahib was a great scholar of his time… a study of his writings and words… is extremely beneficial. I cannot but concede his intel- lectual superiority and the excellence of his erudition. (Munadi newspaper, February 27, March 4, 1930)

Even an opponent like Maulana Zafar ‘Ali Khan had to accept that the writings of the Promised Messiahas had a unique force. He writes: Mirza Sahib responded to the onslaught of the Hindu and Christian religions with great competence. His books Surmah Chasham Arya and Chashma-e- Masihi, etc. are very good books against the Arya Samajists and Christians. (Zami n dar newspaper, September 12, 1923)

[ 34 ]

khutba13.book Page 35 Monday, April 27, 2009 7:43 PM

A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam

This statement lacks the flair, but his praise is justified.

10 of 10 left today