11 November 1907
Malfuzat – Volume X, Part 3
Look, this Divine series [of revelations] had only just begun in Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya when the testimony of God also materialized into existence. All Prophets and holy men are in agreement that it is insanity to make a claim without evidence.
Saeen [Alam Din] said: ‘I do believe you to be the Messiah and Mahdi, and I don’t even perform my obligatory Prayers behind other [non-Ahmadi] people. These Ahmadi people do not perform their obligatory Prayers behind me. What is your verdict about this?’
The Promised Messiah replied:
If you repent and keep silence and do not say anything contravening the Word of God and the word of the Prophet, then they can offer their Prayer [behind you]. To make a claim without strong arguments and decisive proofs is like putting oneself into fire. To say that I am such and such Prophet or that I am superior to such and such Prophet are heretical statements. No one has jurisdiction over the heart. It is the tongue that makes one an apostate. All activity in the world operates on the basis of what is said.
Look, when a nikah [Islamic marriage] takes place between a man and a woman, only verbal consent is obtained and similarly just by saying, ‘I divorce you’, their entire relationship is severed. To make such claims, therefore, is repudiating 124,000 Prophets. One would not do this if he had the fear of God. It is better if you hold your tongue. Otherwise, beware—it will not bode well for you.
What a wise person can do, an ignorant one can do too,
But after suffering a lot of disgrace.
Saeen [Alam Din] said: ‘Then, do I say all these things falsely?’ The Promised Messiah said: ‘I cannot say anything about it. God knows if you are telling the truth or lying.’
Saeen [Alam Din] said: ‘You are the Messiah, King of people. Okay, pray for me.’
The Promised Messiah said: ‘Yes, I will pray.’