6 March 1908
Malfuzat – Volume X
(Before Asr Prayer)
Maulawi Muhammad Husain of Batala
Maulawi Muhammad Husain had requested the Promised Messiah, peace be upon him, in writing through one or more letters and verbally also, to act as the arbitrator in some dispute. And at the same time he had also threatened that if he would not agree to be the arbitrator in that matter, he would name him as a witness in the matter in court and, thus, he would have to appear in the court.
The Promised Messiah (as) said:
It is baffling that on the one hand he considers me to be a kafir [disbeliever] and dajjal [deceiver], faithless, and an apostate; and then, he has not just kept this limited to himself alone, but rather he has tried his utmost to enlist all the big maulawis of nearly the whole of India in his fatwa; yet, on the other hand, he wishes me to act as the arbitrator in a matter pertaining to the Shariah! If he considers me to be out of the circle of Islam, then what do I have to do with a matter pertaining to the Shariah and what would be the value of my verdict? Tell him that first he needs to settle the issue of my Islam or apostasy, then he can make me an arbitrator also.
This man has perpetrated everything that has been possible for him and has been within his power to even have me hanged, and has left no stone unturned in these efforts of his. However, it was the grace of Allah the Exalted and His special favour that He honoured me in every conflict and humiliated my enemies and those who sought my humiliation.
Look, how he incited the Aryas at the time of the murder of Lekh Ram! Even my house was searched. Then, he exerted efforts in the case of murder against me by becoming a witness in support of a Christian. He has not left any stone unturned to malign me before the government. He called me a traitor and openly questioned why the government does not arrest such a traitor. He has tried his utmost to create misgivings about me among the masses. He has told people not to say salam [Muslim greeting of peace] to me; not to shake hands with me. He has told them that it is justified to plunder our properties, to kill us, and to snatch our women. Thus, in view of such great favours that he has done to us, what is this communication and correspondence!
It seems that he has a personal and selfish purpose in this matter for which he is applying this pressure. If he had any share of good fortune, he would have pondered over how I have been bestowed great increase by God Almighty and what types of beneficence Allah the Exalted has caused to descend upon me, and in comparison, what has happened to him since the day he took up the task of opposing me and making all his back-breaking efforts to annihilate me. Just this one thing would have sufficed to guide a fortunate and good-natured person.
Then, he has written in his letter that a son would be born in his home. By writing this sentence, his purpose is to nitpick, and his objective is to, God forbid, belittle the prophecies and the matters related to prophethood. So in response to this, he should be told that he should study my book, Haqiqatul- Wahi [The Philosophy of Divine Revelation]. I have written about these matters in great detail in that book. He does not know that dreams can often be experienced even by low-life, carrion-consuming individuals, and do come true in many cases. So what is there to boast about in this that a son would be born to him?
Some Hindus come to me and relate their dreams and also tell me that their dreams have proven true. By this they only want to raise the objection that what distinction is there about Islam regarding this. I can provide such examples where even some sinners, transgressors, criminals, idolators, thieves, adulterers, and robbers saw dreams, and some of them came true. So what is special about Maulawi Muhammad Husain in this regard?
Sharampat is an Arya from here. He had told me that he was going to have a son [born to him] on the basis of his dream and the son was indeed born. Then at another time he said that Babu Allah Ditta would be transferred and this dream of his was also fulfilled. He cites Babu Allah Ditta as its witness of this also. So, are we to conclude from these things that Sharampat or other such people should, God forbid, be accepted by us as Prophets?
The truth of the matter is actually that Allah has bestowed these faculties upon people from all echelons of society to hold human beings accountable and so that a witness is provided from within one’s self to help him accept [the truth of ] prophethood. There are no prerequisites for true dreams. Allah the Exalted has, rather, endowed the constitution of man with the ability to see dreams lest he deny prophethood.
Allah the Exalted has not set any prerequisite for man to experience true dreams. This faculty has been given to every human being irrespective of him being a Muslim or a non-Muslim, virtuous or evil. Do you not see that the two men who were in prison with the Prophet Joseph (as)—both saw dreams and both were true as well? The Pharaoh, who was the king at that time, also saw a dream which came true. So did Joseph (as) pay homage to them and accept them as Prophets? Or tell me—have you also held them in any esteem? One of them proved the truth of his dream by getting executed, while the other gained proximity to the king. At least he should have been held in esteem.
If one could become a Prophet by one or two such true dreams and he acquires the glory of a Prophet, then tell me all the people you will come to believe in as your Imam? God forbid! This is an affront to the glory of prophethood and results in derision of the Prophets.