10 March 1908

Malfuzat – Volume X, Part 2

However, this person rather humbly requested him to make a stop and that all the companions of the Promised Messiah (as) should accept the treat of sugar canes. He held on to the Promised Messiah (as) and took him by his hand to his field. The Promised Messiah (as) smiled and walked around in his field for a few minutes. In the meantime he brought a pile of sugar canes. The companions of the Promised Messiah (as) all took the sugar canes.

Before leaving, the Promised Messiah (as) called him up with much kindness and inquired about his name etc. He then departed with a smile on his face due to this display of sincerity and love of the man. The kindness and graciousness of the Promised Messiah (as) had a special impact on his companions. This was but one example of his great morals.

The Oneness of God and

Idol Worship in the Vedas

The Promised Messiah (as) said:

Even after the passage of thousands of years, some influence or expression of the original teachings of a religion does survive among its followers by way of a seed. Were there any aspect of monotheistic teaching in the Vedas, its impact would have been evident in its followers at least to some extent. We see tens of millions of forms of idolatry being practiced among them. There are hundreds of thousands of temples that house all kinds of idols. In fact, most of them have vulgar and naked figures providing the world a glimpse into the true nature of their culture and of the Vedic teachings. From the intellectual point of view, the true nature of their teachings is exposed in the books that were written by them in disputation with Islam before the time of Dayanand.

Thus, those people would constantly present their arguments in favour of idolatry against the Muslim Unitarians from the holy books of theirs; i.e., the Vedas. All their striving served to vindicate the worship of different idols. Except for the few men produced by Dayanand, all their earlier great scholars and learned people believed in the worship of idols. Now, how can we consider these many hundreds of thousands of pundits and earlier elders of the Hindu faith to be wrong as opposed to these few followers of the Dayanand thinking?

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

[Ancestors have preference.]

There can only be two possible explanations. Either this precept of Tauhid [the Oneness of God] is an innovation of Pundit Dayanand conceived by him after observing the current thinking and enlightenment of this age, but has no basis in the Vedas which propound the old and fundamental doctrine of idol worship that has been established by the millions upon millions of rishis [sages] and pundits of the Hindus with their practical example over an enormous span of time. Or, if we accept Pundit Dayanand to be true in his claim and we concede that all the predecessors who were the original inheritors and devotees of those scriptures were wrong, then we would have to believe that the Vedas are mute and totally incapable of enunciating their purport.

There is a world of difference between Tauhid and idol worship and yet both these concepts are alleged to have originated from the same holy scriptures; i.e., the Vedas. On the one hand, earlier Hindus prove idol worship on the basis of the same Vedas and debate with the believers in the Oneness of God, while on the other hand, people of the current generation who subscribe to Dayanand’s thinking—who are the generation far behind the former, both in terms of time and [knowledge of its] language—cull Tauhid from the very same books and are averse to idol worship. Regardless, one has to admit that either the esteemed leaders of the past were right or the Vedas are mute, and are incapable and incompetent in articulating their intent.

Has anyone ever seen or heard of a Muslim subscribing to the worship of idols and praying to statues? The Holy Qur’an has expounded the doctrine of Tauhid in such a lucid manner with clear and convincing arguments that the notion or prospect of idol worship has never crossed the mind of any Muslim.

The Promised Messiah (as) said:

I have settled all the objections of these people in a comprehensive manner once and for all in my book, Chashma-e-Ma‘rifat. I am confident that if any seeker after truth, setting aside prejudice and obstinacy, reads this book of mine from beginning to end for the purpose of finding the truth, would—at the very least—never speak or write against Islam. The prerequisite is that one should read it with full attention from end to end with a fair mind.

10 of 10 left today