19 March 1908

Malfuzat – Volume X

The Promised Messiah (as) said:

The Shias exaggerate without reason. In confrontations, the Kharijites are the ones who leave them confuted. The fact is that even if any dispute ever occurred among the Companions (ra), it should not be a cause for concern. Disputes and disagreements always occur where people have deep relationships and this is not anything unusual. Allah the Exalted has given His verdict in all such matters by saying:

Thus, to argue in those matters where God has delivered a verdict is not indicative of possessing faith. If the Shias raise objections against the Companions (ra), the Kharijites raise objections against Hazrat Ali (ra). Thus, it is reported that Hazrat Ali, may Allah be pleased with him, wanted to marry the daughter of Abu Jahl. However, when the Holy Prophet s (as) learned about this, he was very displeased and said it would never be possible for the daughter of the Messenger of God and the daughter of the Enemy of God to be united in one household, and if that is what he still wanted to do, then Fatimah (ra) should be divorced. The Kharijis, in fact, go to the extent of saying that Hazrat Ali (ra) himself—God forbid—deliberately killed Hazrat Fatimah (ra) by poisoning her in order to fulfil this wish of his, and did indeed fulfil this desire.

The wives of the Holy Prophet s (as) have been called the mothers of the believers in the Holy Qur’an. Thus, it is as if Hazrat Ali (ra) has kept arguing with his ‘mother’ [i.e., Hazrat Aishah] for a long time. Hazrat Hasan (ra) gave up his homeland due to the conflict with Hazrat Mu’awiyah, but Hazrat Ali (ra) did not give up quarrelling with his ‘mother’. Indeed, it is established that Hazrat Ali, may Allah honour and exalt him, had even deferred making the pledge of allegiance with Hazrat Abu Bakr (ra) in the very beginning. Then, after reaching his home, something that only God knows caused such a sudden change of heart that he immediately rushed back, wearing just his cap and not waiting even to put on his turban—which he had brought to him later on—to take the pledge of allegiance. It seems that it occurred to him that it was a grave sin and, for this reason, he showed so much haste that he could not wait even to put on his turban. The fact of the matter is that all these issues arise as a result of not pondering over the Holy Qur’an.

On the issue of the death of Jesus (as), the Promised Messiah (as) said:

The Holy Qur’an is the authority to judge the disputes between the Christians and the Jews. The real dispute was that based on what was written in the Torah, the one who is put on the cross is not raised spiritually and, thus, is not worthy that the robe of prophethood be conferred upon him by God. On the contrary, he is accursed and condemned. Crucifixion was the punishment of habitual criminals. Therefore, how can one be worthy of being raised spiritually if he died as a result of the punishment meant for habitual criminals?

In short, the Jews only contended that Jesus (as) was not raised spiritually. Even regarding Moses (as) they believed in his spiritual, and not physical, ascension. They were not even thinking about physical ascension. Thus, the truth of the matter is that Muslims and Jews have a common and firm belief that holy men are raised spiritually after their death and this, indeed, is the feature that is worthy of honour. They do not believe in physical ascension, nor do they assign any superiority to it. Thus, the Holy Qur’an also lays forth this very principle as follows:

مُّفَتَّحَةٗ لَّهُمُ ٱلۡأَبۡوَٰبُ meaning that God opens the heavenly doors of mercy for those who are righteous and honourable in His estimation and they are raised spiritually after their death.

In contrast to them, the heavenly doors are not opened for those who are evil-doers and distant from God and have not inculcated a relationship of sincerity and devotion with Him, as He says:

In other words, the objection of the Jews, in fact, was that since Jesus (as) was put on the cross, he is accursed and obviously an accursed person cannot be raised spiritually—we seek refuge with Allah [from such an accusation]. It was in response to this very point that the Holy Qur’an said

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

.

Besides, I may ask if the objection of the Jews was just that Jesus (as) was not raised physically, then what is the answer to this objection given by the Holy Qur’an, which came to be the judge between these two peoples? Why is it that the Holy Qur’an did not provide any answer to the real objection of the Jews while laying so much stress on the spiritual ascension [of Jesus]? It said,

[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]

[‘Allah exalted him to Himself ’]. Why did it not say,

[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]

[‘Allah exalted him to heaven’]? The Arsh [Throne of Allah] is a creation that is hidden beyond hidden, that is as far from the earth as it is from the heavens; indeed, it is just as far from whichever direction it is approached. It is not the case that Allah’s Throne is close to heaven and far from the earth—we seek refuge with Allah [from such a belief ]. One who maintains such a belief is accursed. The Arsh is a transcendent station and it is for this reason that God is Omnipresent and Omniscient, as He says:

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

and

Heaven until a camel goes through the eye of a needle (Surah al-A‘raf, 7:41). [Publisher]

In short, the real dispute was about his spiritual ascension and him being one granted nearness in the court of the Sovereign [God]. So, Allah the Exalted settled this issue by saying,

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

. Now, can someone explain how this proves his [physical] ascension to heaven? Is God present in heaven but not on the earth?

Allah the Exalted has settled the matter of Jesus (as) once and for all where the following dialogue is recorded [in the Holy Qur’an] that:

This verse proves two points. One is the death of Jesus (as) and the second, that of his not coming back to this world again because the above conversation will take place on the Day of Judgement. Allah will ask Jesus (as) whether he taught the Christians this idolatrous teaching. Jesus (as) would say, ‘O God! They went astray after my death. I have no knowledge as to what kind of beliefs they adopted after me. I had only taught them Tauhid, [the Oneness of God].’ It is very clear, explicit, and obvious from this question and answer, that Jesus (as) has died and he would not return to this world again. Otherwise, if he had come back to the world and corrected their foul teachings and idolatrous beliefs, broken the cross, and killed the swine—wouldn’t

Almighty Allah have chastised him for his blatant lie? Could he tell such a lie on the Day of Judgement in front of God with such audacity and boldness? Absolutely not! Therefore, the only factual and actual truth is that Jesus (as) has died and will not come back to this world again.

The aforementioned is the statement of Allah the Exalted. It was affirmed by the actions of the Holy Prophet s (as). On the night of the Mi’raj [Spiritual Ascension], he saw Jesus (as) sitting next to Yahya (as) [ John the Baptist]. It is worth reflecting over what a living person has to do with, or to be with, a dead person. Life and death are opposites. Just as light and darkness cannot come together in one place, in the same way the dead and the living do not have any connection so as to coexist in one place. On the contrary, a separate cabin was needed for Jesus (as).

10 of 10 left today