7 April 1908

Malfuzat – Volume X

(10:30 am)

On 7 April 1908, an American couple, who said they were residents of (Chicago) USA and were travelling from country to country for the purpose of tourism, had come to India as well to learn about its indigenous political and religious environment. They arrived in Qadian from Lahore at about 10 o’clock, accompanied by a Scotsman. They were cordially received in the offices located under Mubarak Mosque and since they had requested a meeting with the Promised Messiah (as), he also came there. The conversation, conducted through the interpreter, proceeded as follows:

(Initially Deputy Ali Ahmad and later Mufti Muhammad Sadiq worked as interpreters.)

Question: We have heard that you had issued some challenge to Mr. Dowie. Is this correct?

Answer: Yes, it is correct. I did challenge Dowie.

Question: What was the basis for your challenge?

Answer: Dowie had claimed that he was a Messenger of God and God had informed him through revelation that Jesus was the Son of God and was, indeed, God himself; that Jesus himself had given him this revelation in his capacity as God; that Islam would (God forbid) perish; and that Muhammad s (as) was (God forbid) a false prophet.

God had informed me through His revelation that Jesus was neither God nor the Son of God, that he was only a pious man and a Messenger, and that Dowie is false in this claim of his being a Messenger; for, it is absolutely impossible that two Prophets exist at one and the same time sent by the very same One God, yet who are diametrically opposed to one another and are treading opposing paths. As this would have resulted in chaos in the world and the distinction between truth and falsehood would have been lost, I challenged him so as to settle the issue of who is truthful and who is the imposter.

Although there are many in this world who believe Jesus to be the Son of God and even the One God [Himself ], their condition is not so pitiable because those concepts and doctrines are based only upon longstanding erroneous and fabricated narratives and tales, and those people are following traditional accounts. In contrast, Dowie imputed a lie to God with this claim of his. He had, thus, attempted to mislead the masses through attributing a false claim to God. He actually used to say that God had personally informed him of it. He was misguiding people by proclaiming—in his capacity as a ‘prophet’ of God—that Jesus is the Son of God and God. This is indeed the reason why I gave him the challenge to resolve this.

Question: Dowie had made a false claim as he could not prove his truth. And it is written in the Bible that false prophets would appear in the Latter Days. This being the case, what is the proof of the truth of your claim?

Answer: The Promised Messiah (as) said: ‘Where it is written in the Bible that there would appear many false prophets, the coming of a true Prophet is not negated there. It is not written that the true Prophet would not come. On the contrary, appearance of false prophets itself implies that there would also be, among them, a true one.’

Question: Jesus raised the dead. Thus, it is proven that a person was raised. And the Bible was recorded in written form very soon after the death of Jesus. And the raising of the dead by anyone else is not proven. Therefore, this testimony is enough proof and evidence of his claim.

Answer: The Holy Qur’an also mentions the raising of the dead at the hands of the Holy Prophet s (as). But we believe that the raising of the dead by the Holy Prophet s (as) was in a spiritual sense and not in a physical sense. Similarly, we believe that the raising of the dead by Jesus (as) was also in a spiritual sense and not in a physical manner. Moreover, this phenomenon is not peculiar to Jesus (as) alone. It is written in the Bible that Prophet Elijah also raised some of the dead. In fact, he far excelled Jesus (as) in the matter. Even if we concede it as a remote possibility that the Bible refers to the raising of actually dead people, then we are forced to accept Prophet Elijah as a God too. So what distinction of Jesus is there in this? And how is it the differentiating feature? In fact, it is written about the Prophet Isaiah that the dead would come to life just by coming in contact with his body.

It is clearly evident from all these accounts that are recorded in the same Bible that raising the dead cannot be an argument for the Divinity of Jesus (as). But if it is accepted as proof, then why should others who surpassed Jesus in this work, not be accepted as Gods as well? Why should Divinity be restricted and reserved solely for the person of Jesus?

In fact, in my view, the miracle of Moses (as) in converting his staff into a snake, is far greater than raising the dead. The dead and the living have some similarity and likeness because it is the same person who was alive not long ago. One can argue that perhaps the dead person had some possibility of being revived. In contrast, a snake has no similarity or relationship with a staff. A staff is of the nature of a plant and a snake is a snake. Thus, for a staff to become a snake is a far more amazing phenomenon than bringing the dead back to life. Therefore, Moses (as) should be accepted as a greater God. The truth and reality is, however, that I do not subscribe to the notion that those who were really dead were brought back to life.

10 of 10 left today