11 April 1908
Malfuzat – Volume X
(During a walk)
Some critic had sent a letter to Hazrat Maulana Maulawi Sayyed Muhammad Ahsan in which he had criticized the prophecy concerning Mirza Ahmad Baig. Maulawi Sahib mentioned it at the time of the walk.
The Promised Messiah (as) said:
One should first ask such a person whether he even subscribes to the Kalimah [Islamic creed] or not, and whether he even
hidden, semi-apostate. After witnessing thousands of lustrous Signs, he still sees only darkness. It is the fault of his eyes. He may soon lose faith even in the Holy Prophet s (as), if he starts to have such doubts’ (Badr, vol. 7, no. 16, p. 4, dated 23 April 1908).
believes in the Holy Prophet s (as) and the Prophets before him or not?
I am baffled at the condition and mindset of such people that they witness thousands of Signs. They neither care for them nor benefit from them, yet they are eager to raise an objection when they fail to comprehend out of their weak understanding and wisdom, the true import of a matter that is susceptible to interpretation. If they are asked what use they have made of thousands of clear Signs that are on record, they have no answer. The issue they criticize due to their lack of knowledge is in conformity with the practice of God, and no Prophet has been dealt with differently [by this practice of God].
What peril his faith is in who denies this practice of God! He does not just criticize my prophecy, he falsifies even the Holy Prophet s (as). In fact, this necessarily implies rejection of all Prophets.
Consider the incident of the Treaty of Hudaibiyyah of the Holy Prophet s (as) in which many of the senior Companions (ra) faltered. However, God saved them by lending them a helping hand. Even Hazrat Umar, may Allah be pleased with him, was involved in it. Another incident was when the Holy Prophet s (as) said that Abu Jahl would accept Islam. Besides these, there is the matter of twelve thrones for the twelve disciples of Jesus (as); the matter of the tribe of Prophet Jonah (as). A similar incident is also found in the life of Moses (as). I wonder what other things such a person would dispute even though he is called a Muslim.
It is absurd to reject something simply because you fail to comprehend it.
One leg of this prophecy of mine was broken in accordance with the prophecy, right away. This caused fear to descend upon them. They repented by giving alms and charity, by showing their submission and humility in so many other ways, and by shedding tears and crying. Thereupon, God Almighty also turned to them in accordance with His practice.
Look, there was no precondition in the promise of destruction that was given by Prophet Jonah to his people and the wording was clear and explicit that (after forty days), destruction would descend upon them. Thus, when the suspension of an unconditional and definitive prophecy with repentance, anguish, shedding of tears, and wailing is in conformity with the practice of God, then why is a conditional prophecy criticized? It had the following clear words:
[‘Repent, repent, for mischief is pursuing you!’]
Hazrat Sheikh Abdul Qadir Jilani, may Allah be pleased with him, writes in his book, Futuhul-Ghaib,
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
—meaning that there are some promises of God Almighty that are not fulfilled. The Holy Qur’an also mentions of mutashabihat [verses susceptible to differing interpretations]. Such mutashabihat help distinguish a believer from a disbeliever. They are an instrument to set apart the concealed apostates and hypocrites. The world would not have been the same if there were no mutashabihat. It is the way of a hypocrite that he fails to see the river flowing and fails to draw any benefit from it. Instead, he is drawn towards the dried sticks and straws, and [consequently] becomes an apostate.
They would have had an occasion to criticize if I had presented something outside the things common to previous Prophets, and had presented something new on my own accord. It is mentioned in the Holy Qur’an that:
How can he be guided who has never stayed in my company and heard my discourses, nor does he have the ability to evaluate them by comparing them with the standards of other Prophets?
In this era, God has amassed such a rich treasure of mighty Signs, and has furnished such means that even a 100,000 Prophets could prove their prophethood if they wished to do so. In earlier times, there were neither such pressing needs nor such means and resources. If powerful Signs and manifest miracles are shown right with the advent of a Prophet, faith would no longer remain faith—it would merely be an acknowledgement of a manifest reality. There would remain no basis for reward and higher ranks. If clear successes and victories are achieved right at the outset, the corrupt, the wicked, and the sinful would have been the first to join the Prophet s (as). There would remain no way to distinguish between the truthful and the imposter, or between the sincere and the hypocrite. In that case, there would be—God forbid—no assurance.
Look, Hazrat Abu Bakr, may Allah be pleased with him, recognised the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, due to his sound judgement and light of faith. Did he ask for a Sign? Of course not! He accepted the truth of the claim of the Holy Prophet s (as) with great conviction and steadfastness simply on the basis of the initial events of the life of the Holy Prophet s (as).
Sufis have written that, before all others, truth is instilled by God in the heart of the person who is to become the Khalifah [Successor] of a saintly person, a Messenger, or a Prophet of God. There is a quake that rattles the world at the death of a Messenger or spiritual leader, and that time is extremely perilous. And God effaces it through a Khalifah and the work is stabilized and realigned through that Khalifah.