1 May 1908
Malfuzat – Volume X, Part 4
If my opponents do not forsake righteousness and piety, and abandon prejudice and obstinacy, then they know, and our elders and saints who have preceded us have written that
[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]
Throughout the world there exist not hundreds but indeed thousands and hundreds of thousands who experience true dreams. In fact, sometimes true dreams are experienced without distinction between the righteous and the sinful, by disbelievers and Muslims. Sometimes adulterers and adulteresses, the unclean and the foul also experience true dreams. Then why would one not accept that a believer—who, due to his flawless faith, is more deserving than they—can experience a true dream or visions or revelations? In fact, a believer can experience all these phenomena a great deal more.
Do not think that this takes away from the lustre of the visions and revelations of the righteous and those ordained by God, the Prophets and the Messengers, or that it detracts from their majesty or that it decreases their esteem. Not at all. The fact is that these matters affirm the revelation of prophethood and the discourses and converse of God that are bestowed upon His Prophets and Messengers by Him, and they are a strong argument for their reality.
If the seed of this phenomenon was not found in the people, these sinners, transgressors, and faithless people, would have denied the very existence of wahi [revelation] and ilham [inspiration] and their objection would have been strong. It is for this very reason, therefore, that Allah the Exalted, in His perfect wisdom, has Himself planted the seeds of this phenomenon in people of every category to serve as a witness for the discourses, converse, and prophetic revelation of the Prophets and saints so that man would have no way to escape and would be held guilty before his own conscience.
and Converse [of God] is the Soul of Islam
As a rule, man starts to entertain doubts about something if he is not provided a sample of it. This is something that is found exclusively in Islam and it is a great proof of the truth of a religion which is not found in any other religion.
Islam alone is the chosen, favoured, and accepted religion of God. For this reason, out of His sheer mercy, He bestowed upon Islam the perfect blessing of [His] eternally continuing discourse and converse in order to safeguard Muslims from stumbling and entertaining doubts. It is common for people to question in their minds that I too am a human being, and this claimant to Divine revelation is also, ultimately, a human being like me, so what is the reason that I do not experience revelation and converse with God while this person does? It is for this reason that, to eliminate such doubts, Allah the Exalted has placed a glimpse of this blessing in every person by way of a sample.
Look, just as a single penny can be an argument in favour of the possible existence of one to two hundred thousand pennies, and just as one rupee can be an argument in favour of the existence of a treasure of ten or twenty million rupees; similarly, a true dream can serve as an argument in favour of revelation. True dreams have been bestowed upon human nature as an illustration so that one may believe, from this rudimentary experience, that the most sublime form of this bounty does exist. If an ordinary person or even an ignoble person can have a dream, then why is it not possible for a perfect, pure, and pious person of the highest calibre to experience the most refined form of dream which is referred to as revelation, for a true dream is just a minute fraction of the most wonderful excellences?
Remember this well, that the continuation of discourse and converse [with God] is the soul of Islam. If Islam did not have this honour, then—like other religions—it, too, would have been a dead religion. Understand this point very well that if Islam had also been devoid of this blessing and grace of Allah, then certainly there would have been no reason for its eminence. This is the special grace of God that He has continued to send such living examples in Islam at the head of every century, and has, thereby, continued to prove to the world that Islam is a living religion.
There was a time when Islam was such a religion that its renunciation by a single person caused people to imagine that the world had come to an end, but now, it is that same Islam, yet hundreds of thousands have renounced it and became faithless. A concerted effort was made to annihilate Islam through internal and external assaults. Islam was defamed; it was trampled and crushed underfoot. Being ignorant of the essence of the Faith, those claiming to be Muslim are themselves proving to be the enemy of the Faith.
Now, tell me what other misguidance and deviation remains that is now being awaited? Just read the books of Reverend Pfander from among the Christians and see for yourself. He writes that there is not a single prophecy in the religion of Islam that was made nor is there any that was fulfilled. He declares that the prophecy of:
was guesswork and deception, and alleges that the Holy Prophet s (as) had—God forbid—framed this estimation from current events and thereby conceived the prediction. Besides this, there are hundreds of other books and periodicals that have been written against Islam. No Muslim can stand before a Christian and no one can give a crushing reply to the enemies of Islam. If Islam and the life of Islam have come to rest solely upon the tales and fables from the past, then know that Islam has no chance, neither today nor tomorrow.
Know it well that God Almighty can still manifest ever fresh Signs to help Islam just as He helped Islam in the beginning and continued to do so ever since. He can create a furqan [what sets truth apart from falsehood] for every believer provided he is a believer.
But alas! Such are the so-called scholars and supporters of this serene, solid religion, who are themselves announcing that there is no one in Islam who can produce a Sign or a miracle. For instance, Maulawi Muhammad Husain himself admitted in the Conference of Religions, where the followers of all religions were gathered, that it was a pity that Islam did not have people who could show Signs in the present times. In other words, he himself admitted that even his religion was dead like other religions and no longer enjoys the Signs that are the hallmarks of life.