17 May 1908
Malfuzat – Volume X, Part 13
I am also charged with having laid claim to prophethood and that I have made a new religion or that I am contemplating some different qiblah. It is said that I have instituted a new Salat or that I have made a new quran, having abrogated the Holy Qur’an. So what can I say in response to these allegations except
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[‘The curse of Allah be upon those who lie’]?
My claim is only that God has sent me due to the evils of the present day. And I cannot conceal the fact that I have been conferred the honour of communion and converse, and God converses with me and does so abundantly. This is indeed what is called ‘prophethood’ but not actual prophethood.
نَبَأ is an Arabic word meaning news. Now, anyone who reveals to people the news received from God, would be called a
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[Prophet] in Arabic. I do not separate myself from the Holy Prophet s (as) and make any claim. This is merely a dispute in semantics. Plentiful communion and conversation [with God] is alternatively called prophethood.
Look, the quote from Hazrat Aishah, may Allah be pleased with her, provides clarity on this issue:
[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]
[‘Say, he (the Holy Prophet) is Khatamun-Nabiyyin—the Seal of the Prophets—but do not say that there is no Prophet after him’]. If prophethood has been discontinued in Islam, then rest assured that Islam, too, has died and there is no distinctive Sign in it either. If a garden is abandoned and forgotten by its caretaker and gardener, and he remains unconcerned about watering it, then the result is obvious: it would dry up and become fruitless in a few years, and ultimately its wood would be used for fire.
In reality, the dispute between them and us is about terminology. They, too, acknowledge communion and converse [with God]. Mujaddid Sahib also acknowledges this. He writes that those holy men who have communication and converse with God in abundance are called Muhaddath and Prophets. In any case, I ask if one receives news from God and conveys it to the world, what do you propose to call him in the Arabic language other than a Prophet?
It is strange that if the purport of this word is explained in Urdu or Punjabi, they accept it, but if the same is presented in the Arabic language, they hate and reject it. Is this anything but prejudice?
There is one last thing and I deem it necessary to explain. These people might have deceived even the educated and civilized people in this matter, and might have tried to alienate them against me. Therefore, I consider it advisable to make it clear to you that God has sent me for the renewal of the Faith with His support and help by giving me fresh Signs. You should know for sure that if God had not sent me, this religion would also have become caged within ancient stories and anecdotes like other religions. One who comes from God is not allowed to perish. Ultimately, God makes his success manifest to the world.
These people have made use of lies, fabrications, false accusations, and many other machinations to slander me. They have tried very hard to make people entertain doubts about me and to halt my progress. Nonetheless, with the power of Allah I continued to make progress despite all this, and this is continuing so much so that there are now more than 400,000 members of my Jama’at present in different countries. The fact is that, when sensible people understand that this is the only way to prevail against the enemy, they firmly embrace it with a sincere heart.
Now, those who believe that Jesus (as) did not die and is alive, while the Holy Prophet s (as) is dead and buried in Madinah—have they not mounted a grievous attack on the honour of the Holy Prophet s (as)?
And then they say that the same Israelite Prophet would come back to the world and reform the ummah of Muhammad s (as) and revive the Faith. Now, tell me how the Holy Prophet s (as) would continue to be Khatamun-Nabiyyin [the Seal of the Prophets] after an Israelite Prophet comes after the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him? By virtue of this doctrine, Jesus (as) would be Khatamun-Nabiyyin and not the Holy Prophet s (as). Most certainly not!
Jesus (as) was himself a Prophet of God in his own right. Would his earlier shariah and prophethood become abrogated?
When we have received the promise in clear words in Surah an-Nur that the one to come would only come from within you—there is now no room for anyone to come from the outside. Sahih al-Bukhari, which is the most authentic book after the Book of Allah, also says
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[‘Your Imam from among you’]. And when his death [that of Jesus] is clearly proven from the Holy Qur’an and the Hadith, then why is such a doctrine maintained that is a belief that is totally against the Holy Qur’an and the Holy Prophet s (as)? The Holy Prophet s (as) himself saw him [ Jesus] among the Prophets who are deceased on the night of Mi’raj [Spiritual Ascension]. If he was alive, there should have been some other place designated for him rather than being with the deceased. The living and the dead have nothing in common.
In short, God through His Word and the Holy Prophet s (as) through his action have proven that he [ Jesus] has already died.
Now, being Muslims, if they do not accept the Holy Qur’an and the word of the Messenger s (as), it is a choice that they make. They do not reject me but they reject the One from whom I have been sent and the one to whom I am enslaved. Set me and my rejection aside—they dare to reject the Holy Prophet s (as)! This is one and same thing—the Holy Qur’an has set forth the promise of the coming of a Khalifah [Successor], and in the Hadith, the Khalifah to come in the Latter Days has been named Messiah. Where is there conflict in this?
Allegations other than these are also likewise baseless and born out of obstinacy and prejudice. I have refuted them all in detail within my books. Some of their beliefs are such that they cause the heart of a true Muslim to tremble.