17 May 1908
Malfuzat – Volume X, Part 6
I have observed that there are also many in this day and age who consider religion to be fanaticism and they do not hold any respect for it in their hearts. They claim that the dwellers of Arabia were savages and illiterate—that the Holy Qur’an was sent down at that time apropos for their needs. Now the world has advanced and this is the age of enlightenment. Now religion needs to be amended to suit the present times. But let it be known that religion is not some absurdity. Quite the contrary, real comfort of the world and salvation in the Hereafter are bound up with this religion alone.
Those unlettered people of Arabia who were the sincere servants of this religion—their being unlettered was itself a miracle in that these same unlettered people, after coming under the sway of teachings in the Holy Qur’an, worked such wonders that claimants of great scholarship were utterly unable to compete against them.
God knew full well what new fields of knowledge would emerge in this age, and people with what kinds of opinions would come into being among the Muslims. Allah the Exalted has already addressed all these issues in the Holy Qur’an and there is no new research or advance in knowledge that can outstrip the Holy Qur’an. And there is no new truth that has emerged now but is already present in the Holy Qur’an.
The course that the Holy Qur’an has presented is not found in the New Testament nor can it be discovered in the Torah. There is also no other book in the world that can lay claim to the same perfection and comprehensiveness that Allah the Exalted has, out of His perfect wisdom, endowed upon the Holy Qur’an. There is no comparison with the Holy Qur’an; they are not even worth mentioning. The New Testament transformed a frail and feeble man into God, but the true measure of his strength can simply be assessed in his confrontation with the Jews.
The second element and the source of pride was the moral teaching of the New Testament, but it is so absurd and deficient that no right-minded person can adhere to them. Even the conduct of Christian priests is totally opposed to this teaching. For instance, the New Testament teaches that if anyone slaps you once, you should turn to him the other cheek; and that if anyone asks for your shirt, you should hand over your cloak as well; and if anyone forces you to go one mile, go with him two miles.
Now, to begin with, I’d like to ask those very gentlemen—the Christian priests who support and laud the New Testament—to what extent they follow this teaching. What exemplary conduct of this teaching have they shown that they should invite others to it as well?
Moreover, it is written in this same New Testament that you should not resist evil. In short, the teaching of the New Testament is so wholly given to the extreme [of forbearance] that one cannot possibly act upon it save for some unusually extraordinary circumstances. On the other hand, if we look at the teachings of the Torah we see that they are tilted to the other extreme—that only one aspect is stressed: life for life, eye for eye, ear for ear, and tooth for tooth. There is absolutely no mention of forgiveness and pardon in it.
The fact of the matter is that these scriptures were actually particular to a specific time and a specific people. On the contrary, what a holy path the Holy Qur’an has told us about which is free from either extreme and is in perfect accord with human nature! For example, the Holy Qur’an says :
meaning that, recompense for an evil is permissible to the extent of the evil committed, but if one pardons, and reformation is the objective of the pardon and the forgiveness is not out of place or occasion, then there is reward for him who thus forgives, which he will receive from God.
Just look, what a pure and pristine teaching this is! There is no exaggeration and there is no deficiency. Retribution is permitted but it also holds out the enticement for forgiveness so long as the prerequisite of reformation is present. This is the third option presented to the world by the Holy Qur’an. Now, it behoves a fair-minded person to compare and contrast these teachings and decide for himself which teaching is in conformity with human nature and which one is repulsed by the righteous mind and conscience.
In Judaism, a father would charge his son or grandson to take his revenge. Thus, at times the son or the grandson would take the revenge for his father or grandfather. In short, the regulations of the Torah were extremely violent.
And as for the New Testament, those who boast about its moral teaching do not realize that, in the first place, that teaching is so defective and, because of it being specific to a time and a people, there exists no need for it today; nor does it deserve to be called a moral teaching in this day and age. And even if it is accepted as such, there is no one who can be seen practicing this teaching. Those who are enamoured by this teaching should at least present a practical example. In reality, as the expression goes, ‘We are dealing with elephant teeth here; one set for display and another to eat with.’ Divine philosophy is totally different from it. Man is like a tree with many branches.