18 May 1908

Malfuzat – Volume X

(After Zuhr Prayer in Lahore)

Professor [Clement Lindley] Wragge, whose meeting and question and answer session with the Promised Messiah (as) has been published previously, again met with the Promised Messiah (as) on 18 May 1908 on the motivation of and through the person of Hazrat Mufti Muhammad Sadiq. After exchanging some niceties, the following question and answer session took place.

Question: What is your belief about God? Is He finite or is He omnipresent, and does He have a physical persona and emotions?

Answer: I do not believe God to be finite, nor can God be finite. We know about God this much that just as He is in the heavens, so is He on the earth. There are two forms of relationships that He has. One is the general relationship that exists with all creation. The other is the special relationship which exists with special people who, after purifying their own selves, advance in their love for Him. He, then, becomes so near to them as if He speaks from within them. This is a wonderful thing about Him that despite being far, He is near, and in spite of being near, He is yet far. He is extremely close, but yet we cannot say that He is near as one body is near to another body.

He is above all, yet we cannot say that anything is underneath Him. He is more manifest than everything, and yet He is profoundly profound. The degree to which a person purifies himself is the very same degree to which he gains awareness of Him.

The Promised Messiah (as) continued:

By emotions, he probably means that why has God burdened man with the weight of the Shariah and why has He bound him down with the constraints of the lawful and the unlawful? So, it should be known that the fact is that God is Quddus [Holy] to the most perfect degree and, on account of His purity, He does not like impurity. And as He is Merciful and Beneficent, He does not desire man to embrace those paths that lead to his destruction. So, these are His emotions, if you will, on the basis of which the system of religion is established.

Question: Does God have any shape?

Answer: When He is not finite, how can He have a shape?

Question: While God is love, just, and fair, then why do we witness in the world that some things have been made by Him to serve as food for others? If love and justice, or equity and mercy, are His innate attributes, then why has He endowed some of His creation with the desire and the ability to devour others while they are both equally His creation?

Answer: When the word love is used for God, it would be a grave error to conceptualize it as human love. The word love as it is applied to human beings and its import as it is understood in the context of human relations, cannot be applied to God at all, nor is its meaning and purport truly befitting for God. Man has the attributes of love and anger, but the connotation that comes to our mind when using them in the human context cannot be applicable to God at all. This is a mistake. It has been ingrained in human nature that when he loves someone, he suffers grief by separation from that person. A mother loves her child and what a shock she receives and how much pain and grief she suffers if her child gets separated from her.

Similarly, when a person is angry with someone, he experiences its shock and impact initially within himself, as if he is punishing his own self at the same time as he punishes the other person. Anger is a suffering that has its impact first on the person himself. A kind of bitterness is created in the mind supplanting peace and tranquillity. However, God is immune from all this. Therefore, it can be clearly concluded from this that the way we use these words for man and the meaning it holds in human relations, cannot be used for God nor can they be true for Him. Therefore, I do not like these words.

This application has been created by those who perceive God to be like a human being. God is Holy. The bond with Him is ever on the increase when one acts in compliance with His will. The words of love and anger can be used for God but only in the metaphoric sense.

It should be understood that this world is an elaborate operation for the management of which God Almighty has appointed the current organizational structure out of His perfect wisdom, and it is operating under this system. However, such words are not truly applicable to this system. The word love has a connotation of suffering and tenderness. If it is assumed that God is love and He has the attribute of anger as well (with human experience as reference), we would have to assume at the same time that God, too, experiences some kind of distress, sorrow, and grief. However, such imperfections cannot be imputed to God.

Question: This, I have understood. But I wish to inquire as to why God has destined that the weak should be subservient to the mighty or become its food and remain subservient to it?

Answer: I have just explained that we cannot imagine God’s attributes of love, mercy, and wrath to be like the attributes as they exist in human beings. To conceptualize that God has experiences like that of a human being is a grave mistake. This is a vast system of God that He has created as it is. A human being cannot encroach this system beyond his own limits. It is not proper that man should find a way to question everything being intrusive about the very complex and intricate wisdom of God.

This world is a limited world. God has set up a vast realm to follow this one wherein He has desired and promised that true and everlasting prosperity will be awarded. Every suffering that exists in this world will be redressed and compensated in the other realm. Any shortcoming that is found in this world will be made whole in the next world.

10 of 10 left today