25 May 1908

Malfuzat – Volume X, Part 2

The Promised Messiah (as) asked Maulana Maulawi Sayyed Muhammad Ahsan about him and his manners, and inquired if he was not easily overcome by anger, or quick of temper or easily excitable. Some of the companions replied that he was not like that, and that he was mild-mannered. However, if he is accompanied by a crowd of people, it could be a concern.

As the Promised Messiah (as) was busy writing his book, Paighame-Sulh [A Message of Peace], and had no time to spare, the Promised Messiah (as) told Maulana Maulawi Sayyed Muhammad Ahsan to write the reply to his letter and said: ‘I will also write a reply to him. You may conduct a discussion with him about these issues with cordiality and gentleness. However, do make sure that he does not bring a big crowd with him except a few honourable and cordial people. You should also have a discussion with him in a private setting. There is no harm in it.’ In the meantime, someone mentioned that he [Maulawi Muhammad Ibrahim] does not even believe that Hazrat ‘Isa [ Jesus], peace be upon him, was hung upon the cross, and that he presents the following verse in favour of his claim:

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

.

At this the Promised Messiah (as) said:

To adopt a course that has no evidence for it at all, disregarding consistent, obvious, and palpable matters, is totally opposed to wisdom and the Faith. I do not present anything new, nor do I try to persuade people to accept something unsubstantiated, for which I do not have strong evidence and clear testimony in my hand. There are hundreds of thousands of people with me as my witness. Entire nations are presenting their consistent and unanimous testimony. If someone has any doubt and suspicion, he can ask the Jews and the Christians as to their belief in this matter. Both contending parties are present. Ask them if they agree with what you present. You see, to go against the nationally held view and disregard it, without any powerful evidence or brilliant argument, is a most egregious error.

It is mind-boggling! And how was it possible to seize some other person and hoist him upon the cross without any rhyme or reason, while he uttered not a single word in protest? Why wouldn’t he scream aloud: ‘I am one of you! Why are you putting me on the cross while I am innocent? The real culprit is getting away. I am your compatriot. This is my name and so and so are my parents, and so and so are my relatives, why are you putting me to death?’

It was a matter of life and death for him and of becoming the target of an accursed death. The actual culprit was getting away. An innocent person—one without any fault; someone with nothing to do with it—was being put on the cross and strangely, he does not even protest in the least! This mystery is beyond my comprehension.

Apart from this, God has bestowed upon me revelation and knowledge of the unseen purely out of His grace, and—through the issuance of the special favour of communion and converse—He has given me true knowledge in these matters. Besides, my conscience cannot accept it at all that such sustained concurrence and the unanimous testimony of tens of millions of people is totally wrong and what they all had understood was a conjecture and a misconception. Look, اہر

يپات ہن ابدش [‘Until there is somewhat of something there, people do not just make up things’].

I cannot fathom why God had to show such weakness? Was He incapable of saving the Messiah in front of all the witnesses that He had to resort to such injustice? Why did He put an innocent man to death without justification? To advance a view discordant with the Holy Qur’an and the Hadith, puts the burden of proof on the one who advances such a claim.

What I mean by this is that all these matters are such that they are easily refuted. Just consider the word ْ ِّیتَوَفِّْیتَوَف [tawaffi] in the Holy Qur’an and see if there is any place where it has been used in meanings other than death, or has it been used for ascension to Heaven with the physical body? This very same word, ِّْیتَوَفِّْیتَوَف [tawaffi], has been used by Allah the Exalted for the Holy Prophet s (as). Ponder over the verse and see:

Then this same word occurs with regard to Joseph (as). So I cannot understand why Jesus (as) is given this special treatment in contravention to the dictum in the Holy Qur’an and to all the other Prophets (as).

The same word, ْ ِّیتَوَفِّْیتَوَف [tawaffi] appears nearly 300 times in the books of Hadith and nowhere does it mean ascension to Heaven with the physical body. Wherever you look it has always been used to denote death.

In fact, I sense a stench from someone who is not a seeker after truth and makes such a request just to brag and show his superiority in some fashion. I do not wish to waste my time on such a person who does not thirst for the truth and whose anguish is not for God and God’s religion; rather, he is a slave of his ego, and he lives and dies for the honour and glory of his own self.

And I sense a fragrance emanating from the one who comes to me in search of the truth and with a thirst and sincere fervour to reach God. So for such a one I stretch out my arms and receive him with honour and consider it an honour for myself to serve him to the best of my ability. On the other hand, I smell a foul odour from the person with an impure heart who entertains mischief concealed within him, and who is a seeker of the world; not of truth. Then, I do not desire even to speak to him.

The doctrine that God has established me upon is that Allah the Exalted has clearly mentioned the death of Jesus, peace be upon him, in the His Glorious Word [the Holy Qur’an] not just at one place but at scores of places. And the Holy Prophet s (as) bore witness to this practically in that upon seeing him [ Jesus] among the dead, he did not describe any distinction between him and the others.

·

10 of 10 left today