1 August 1899

Malfuzat – Volume II

On 1 August 1899 after the Maghrib Prayer, a Hindu ascetic (sadhu), from a well-known class of people, came to visit His Holiness and had a discussion with the Promised Messiah (as). The following is a summary or abridgement penned in my own words according to memory. —Editor Al-Hakam

Promised Messiah (as): Is your practice of meditation according to the tenets of the Sanatan Dharam or the principles of the Arya Samaj?

Ascetic: According to the Sanatan Dharam.

Promised Messiah (as): The Arya Samaj are a sect with words but no action. Ascetic: Absolutely. These people do not believe in the need for a spiritual teacher (guru). In fact, they do not even believe in Dyanand to be a spiritual guide. They simply say that he has showed them a path and now everyone ought to follow that way.

Promised Messiah (as): Your meditation is full of very strenuous exercises. Ascetic: Yes, indeed.

Promised Messiah (as): After this exercise, do you develop some sort of strength or power, which causes one to perceive that love which the individual engaged in meditation, possesses for God? For love cannot be perceived or seen to exist until a perfect expression is made from both sides. On the one hand, man must be ready to bear all sorts of grief and pain in the fervour of love, while on the other hand, God (Parmeshwar) endows a lustre or light (parkash) to such a person, which distinguishes them from others in general. Ascetic: Yes, a person does manage to develop a certain degree of strength and power.

Promised Messiah (as): Please, do relate something in the context of this power and strength. Not something that you have heard of, but something that you have witnessed yourself, either in your guru or in his guru. You see, things that we have heard about do not possess the same effect, no matter how true they may be, and people consider them to be nothing more than tales and stories. For example, someone may say that there is a certain country where humans fly. Now there can be no doubt that we will be reluctant in believing this because we have neither seen humans flying, nor have we taken flight ourselves. Therefore, in order to increase the strength of our faith and certainty, matters of hearsay are of no benefit. On the contrary, new and fresh observations that we witness before our eyes, and even more so, things that we experience personally, do have an effect. So, the reason I ask this question is so that you will kindly tell me something of the nature that I just mentioned, which you have observed or heard personally from those who engage in this meditative exercise.

Ascetic: Our spiritual leader (guru) did possess certain qualities whereby he could discern the thoughts of others, and when he said something, it would occur. His guru also possessed many such qualities, but I have not seen him. But it is one and the same, because our guru’s teacher passed away some eighty years ago, and those who saw him are still alive.

Promised Messiah (as): Have you also performed meditative exercises? Ascetic: Yes, I have also undertaken such exercises.

Promised Messiah (as): What have you done exactly?

Ascetic: Initially, I would engage in retreats. A single retreat lasts for eight months.

Promised Messiah (as): What would you eat during that time?

Ascetic: In the beginning, I would have rice flour. Then, I began having nothing but porridge—I would boil barley in water and when the mixture would be reduced to half a vessel, I would then keep it aside. The next morning I would have about a litre of that porridge and urinate immediately thereafter. Then, I would eat nothing.

Promised Messiah (as): This did not contain iron etc., did it?

Ascetic: No.

Promised Messiah (as): During this period of spiritual exercise and meditation, did you witness any astonishing or remarkable sights or visions?

Ascetic: Yes, at times I would see a light that would enter my body. Then, I would also see people coming and going from afar.

After this, there were a few minutes of silence, which was finally broken by the following question posed by the Hindu ascetic. —Editor Al-Hakam

Ascetic: Do you believe Parmeshwar (God) to be aakar or nir-aakar?

At this point, Hazrat Maulvi Nur-ud-Din Sahib explained for the benefit of the audience that aakar means, ‘one that can be made into an idol’ and niraakar means, ‘a God who does not require a sculpted form.’

To this, the Promised Messiah (as) responded: “In order to worship the God that we believe in, we neither require such meditation and exercises, nor are we in need of any idol. In our religion, there is no need whatsoever to bear such difficulties in order to attain the nearness of God Almighty and witness the displays of His power. In fact, those who truly love God and are devoted to Him, can find Him in no time at all, in a very easy manner, and I have experienced this myself. If man moves a single step in God’s direction, He moves two steps; if man walks swiftly towards Him, God races towards man and fills his heart with light.

The Wisdom in God Remaining Hidden

In my opinion, those who make idols of God have not understood the wisdom and secret behind God Almighty keeping Himself in a state of apparent hiding. God Almighty being hidden is the very fact that opens the pathways for all of man’s quests, searches and investigations. All the knowledge and insight that has ever been revealed to man, though present all along, at some point in time, was hidden. It was the strength of man’s struggle and effort that showed its lustre and achieved the ultimate end.

10 of 10 left today