19 April 1901

Malfuzat – Volume III, Part 5

Yuz Asaf is the same man referred to as Christ. The word asaf means ‘gatherer of dispersed communities.’ Since it was the task of the Messiah, peace be upon him, to gather the lost sheep of the house of Israel, and researchers agree that the people of Kashmir are from the children of Israel, it was necessary for Jesus (as) to travel to this land. Further, the account of Yuz Asaf is well known in Europe. In fact, this is to such an extent that in Italy a church has been built in this name and a festival takes place there every year. Now, to spend such a vast sum of money to construct a house of worship, and then to arrange a festival there every year, is not something that should be viewed with a cursory glance. The people say that Yuz Asaf was a disciple of the Messiah (as). In my view, however, this is not true. The fact of the matter is that Yuz Asaf was the Messiah himself. If Yuz Asaf is the name of a disciple, then it falls upon the Christians to prove that the Messiah (as) had a disciple who was referred to as the Prophet Prince.

These are points which entirely unveil the details relating to the incident of the crucifixion. Of course, if the Christians rejected the matter altogether, that would have been the end of this debate. However, since they do accept that there was a man named Yuz Asaf who once existed; and when his teaching was the same as the Gospel; and when he, too, named his book ‘Gospel’ and when he was also referred to as the Prophet Prince, just as the Messiah (as) was referred to as the Prophet Prince; one is compelled to reflect that if this individual is not the Messiah (as), then who is he?

For the sake of God, reflect. An individual who does not attach their heart to the world and who loves the truth can have no issue whatsoever in accepting this. Now, if one accepts that Yuz Asaf was the name of an actual person who had a relationship with the Messiah (as), and then a church named after him has been built in Italy as well, and a festival takes place there every year, and when one admits that his teaching is the same as the teaching of the Gospel, how can one say that this man is not the Messiah himself ? When you accept these four points, in view of this testimony, I ask you that if you suggest that this man was a disciple, then prove that there was ever a disciple named Yuz Asaf. The name Yuz Asaf is a variation of the name Yusu (Christ). There is only one argument that can settle this matter. If evidence can be provided to the effect that the Messiah (as) had a disciple named Yuz Asaf and he was referred to as the Prophet Prince and Isa Sahib, then most surely this would be the tomb of a disciple. However, if this cannot be proven, and most definitely never can this be proven, then accept my view that it is the Messiah himself who rests in this tomb.

It gives me great joy that you listen with forbearance. Only those who listen with forbearance have it within them to investigate the truth. Few others would have listened to as much as you. You ought to reflect for the sake of God how interrelated the details of this account have become. The Christians accept that the man in question was from among the disciples. At least they have admitted that there is some relation in this respect. Then they built a church in the man’s name and now a festival takes place there every year. Now you tell me, on whom does the burden of proof fall? If the Christians had accepted no relation whatsoever, most surely the burden of proof would have fallen on me. But when you have yourselves accepted this fact, I ask you for evidence of a disciple who was also referred to as the Prophet Prince.

The Reverend: We thank you immensely for your kindness and hospitality.

His Holiness (as): This is a duty of my office and Allah the Exalted has sent me for this very purpose. I am obliged to do so.

When His Holiness, the Sign of Allah, had finished his discourse, Mr Fazl

(who perhaps is an employee at the Lahore Book Society) spoke to exhibit his intelligence. It would have been better, however, had he remained silent so that the secret of his wise and deeply reflective nature had been preserved. His

Holiness presented a long exposition on Yuz Asaf with the support of historical testimonies, but just observe the question that Mr Fazl asks.

Mr Fazl: Have you found any historical proof in relation to the tomb?

His Holiness (as): A book 1100 years old is present, the Christians have a church

named after him, a festival regularly takes place there, and you still demand historical evidence? What is this? If this is not historical evidence, then what is?

The Promised Messiah (as) went on to state: “You understand nothing. Your only objective is to deceive the people. I advise everyone to become purehearted; to cleanse their hearts of pretence and prejudice, and accept with utmost open-heartedness the truth and wisdom wherever it is found. I am always ready to listen to others if you respond with a clear and honest answer that in your view this disciple of the Messiah (as) is called the Prophet Prince for such and such reason. If you are unable to respond—and there is no response—you could perhaps state that you hold this view merely on the basis of your religious belief. However, this would be no different than someone questioning a Hindu about their belief that the Ganges river flows from the hair of Mahadev and about the reality of this belief, and the Hindu responding by simply saying that although they do not possess the arguments to prove this, they accept this belief nonetheless, and this is an undeniable reality. Obviously, this would not be logically acceptable by any standards. Therefore, I assure you that I have proven, not on the basis of mere belief, but in light of solid research, that this tomb is actually the tomb of the Messiah. Established events affirm this and history testifies all the same. There are Christians in Germany who believe that the Messiah (as) did not die on the cross. This is a very clear fact, and after reflection, no doubt remains in this respect.”

Question: In your view, what duty falls upon the Christians?

Answer: The duty of any human being ought to be that they search for the truth and then take hold of it at once from wherever they may find it. There is no differentiation between Christians and others.

After this, the priests thanked His Holiness (as) once again. Then they were given some books from the bookshop and from the office of Al-Hakam, whereafter they departed.

10 of 10 left today