12 September 1901

Malfuzat – Volume IV, Part 3

And whoso does an atom’s weight of evil will also see it.

So, when someone commits a sin and is thrown into hell to bear the consequences of their actions, all of their ‘divinity’ is reduced to nothing. Even the Wujudis believe in this verse of the Holy Qur’an:

A party will be in the Garden, and a party in the blazing Fire. Therefore, when human beings can never escape their human characteristics, what need is there for such useless claims, which have no substance in reality and no meaning. Therefore, these people are insolently audacious and brazen. Furthermore, since this sect ultimately reinforces freedom from divine law and a way of permissiveness, this sect continues to grow. The poison of this sect has pervaded large parts in the districts of Lahore, Jalandhar and Hoshiarpur. Reflect and look at the outcomes; this is promoting nothing but a way of permissiveness. These people do not adhere to the injunctions of Prayer and fasting, nor can they, for they are devoid of righteousness, which is the very foundation of salvation and underpins the importance of deeds. Some of them are, more or less, atheists. Therefore, I say that this too is a grave trial from among the various forms of disorder that are prevalent at this time, which has let loose an ocean of transgression and vice, and flung open the gates of permissiveness and atheism. If the honourable companions, may Allah be pleased with all of them, had been alive today, they would look at these people with astonishment, wondering from where this so-called Islam has come. It does not behove man under any circumstances to overstep the bounds of human nature. How true it is that:

Do abandon worldly pleasures and seek to inculcate piety, sincerity and devotion;

But do not step ahead of Mustafa (the Holy Prophetsas).

In short, this sect may be likened to tuberculosis. There was a man in Allahabad and he corresponded with me. After letters were sent back and forth in one or two exchanges, he began to use curse words and obscenities. Purification of the inner self is a far off thing for these people; even the general state of their morality is not very good. The fundamental reason is that exemplary morals and purification of the soul hinges upon righteousness and fear of God, and it is unfortunate that these people possess neither, because they consider their own beings to be God. As such, when they relinquish their human nature and assume for themselves the seat of God, and when it is a proven fact that they cannot become God, all that is left for one who abandons their human nature is to become Satan. This is why such people are hastily incensed. The more one investigates their state of affairs, the more it becomes clear that they do not adhere to Islam. I have already mentioned that they do not pray or fast, because they have no fear of God, and ultimately, awe of the Divine dissipates. Such people begin to associate with atheists and become permissive, breaking the limits set by God. Hence, this is a most lethal poison. A person may suggest that Hazrat Bayazid Bastami, Khwaja Junaid Baghdadi, or Syed Abdul-Qadir Jilani, may the mercy of Allah be upon them all, have made statements, which the ignorant either deem blasphemous, or like the misguided sect mentioned above derive from them an argument in favour of the Unity of Being (wahdat-e-wujud), as is evident from the words:

Holy am I. How great is my grandeur.

Or the statement:

Under my cloak is Allah.

Those who derive an argument in favour of the said concept from these statements have misunderstood. Firstly, we do not even know if they made these statements or not. However, even if we accept that they actually uttered these words, the spring from which these sorts of statements gush forth is that of love and passion. For example, an ardent admirer, in the passion of their love and wholly absorbed in devotion, can say:

I have become you, and you me, I the body, you the soul;

So that no one can say hereafter, that you are another, and I someone else. This state of being completely absorbed and annihilated is of a unique nature, like the manner in which a mother loves her child. If a mother is unable to see her child even for a little while, her heart begins to sink, and she begins to feel perturbed and restless. The longer this state lasts and the more it continues, so too her anxiety continues to grow and she begins to lose her senses. Now this form of annihilation ( fana) is greater than her own being, but as for the Wujudi, he claims that his state of fana becomes an entity in itself. So statements of this nature uttered by the saintly stem from complete and utter devotion, passion and love, but on account of their flawed understanding, the Wujudis have turned them into something else and presented them in their own favour. They do not know that when passion and love surges forth, they manifest the most remarkable effects—and this is to such an extent that a person becomes detached completely from their own being. When a person is dominated completely by love, they are unable to behold their own being, and all that they perceive is that they are themselves nothing.

The similitude of this is like a piece of iron that is placed in a fire until it becomes like a red, burning flame. In this state, an observer will not say that this is a piece of iron, but will believe it to be a flame from the fire, and apparently it is a fragment of the fire too—for one can light a fire with it as well, but in reality, it remains the iron it always was. This is the same manner in which the fire of love manifests its wonders. When the foolish behold these wonders, instead of pondering on them and deriving a beneficial conclusion from them, some people attach their hearts to a self-conceived conclusion. This is why these difficulties arise. Anyone who spends a portion of their lives following a certain religion, does not wish to leave it. However, this is a serious mistake. Where a person will be called to account for other errors and weaknesses, they will also most definitely be called to account for this as well, because God Almighty has clearly stated:

And follow not that of which thou hast no knowledge.

Then, how can a person who claims that ‘I am God’ say that they have truly gained certainty? What divine characteristics and attributes does such a one feel within themselves, so that they would be justified in making such an absurd claim? When he stumbles at every step and remains fettered and shackled by the chains of human need, what right does he have to say, ‘I am God’ and then assert that he has full certainty of himself being God? If he made such a claim, someone else could say how can you make such frivolous claims with such audacity, and why do you not look at your own helplessness and scant worth? The Holy Qur’an draws a clear distinction between the Creator and His creation. The Holy Qur’an begins with the words alhamdulillah (all praise belongs to Allah) and there is another journey after death as well. When a person cannot even know fully their own state of affairs and attributes, how can they become God? If one reflects, the limited and defective nature of man’s knowledge is the very proof of his being a creature and a servant.

Therefore, the aforementioned concept is a most unholy one. Those who believe in this concept known as Unity of Being (wahdat-e-wujud) are extremely insolent and arrogant. They do not correct their mistakes; and how would they when, God forbid, they consider their own selves to be God? If they had learned to differentiate between God and His servant, the reality of their errors would become clear. However, they are quite content with their childish views. For this reason, they can have no knowledge of the insights with which the Holy Qur’an is replete. This is a grave evil indeed and I fail to understand when it first came about. In my view, there are perhaps few from among the custodians of shrines who do not adhere to this belief. They have crafted their own philosophy from the statements of the holy men of the Faith, which they uttered in a state when they were overcome with extreme love and in the fervour of their passion. In reality, the difference between annihilation of perception ( fana-e-nadhari) and the belief held by the Wujudis is that the former is not a matter of philosophy, it is characterised by extreme love, whereas the latter leads one to become a sophist. The sophist is an enemy of God and an atheist, and possesses no love for God. For example, a philosopher could dissect a dead body, but it would be completely irrelevant to suggest that just because he has done so, he would eat the dead body too. In the same manner, an individual who believes in the Unity of Being claims to be God, but this claim has no relation whatsoever as to whether they actually love God as well. Just because a person has seen the skeleton and inner parts of a monkey or dog, does this mean that they share a bond with the animal too? The concept under discussion is based on similar types of claims.

These people portray themselves as real philosophers but they can provide no evidence as to whether they even possess a relationship with God or not. The great ones of the past who advanced on the spiritual path became the chosen ones of God. This is because the love of God Almighty had dominated their beings; they believed in the Holy Qur’an, they would swim in the ocean of love for the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, and Islam was their religion. Due to this, by the grace of God Almighty, they manifested miracles and wondrous feats. The fact of the matter is that when a servant develops an intense relationship of love and passion with their Creator, God Almighty grants them a portion of His attributes, for God has made man His vicegerent on earth.

Moving on, another disorder is the one caused by those who call themselves Muwahhids (or Unitarians). They are nothing but literalists. There was a debate with a man from Lahore named Abdul-Hakeem, and he said in clear terms that even Hazrat Umar (ra) was not a recipient of revelation. He interpreted the known narration by suggesting that if ever anyone was to receive revelation, it would be Umar (ra). This is the manner in which he translates the Hadith, and in doing so, he has essentially raised the allegation against God that He has, as if, consoled the Muslims by doing nothing. I ask, however, how he can refer to this ummah as the best of communities if, after the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, not even a single person in this community was blessed with the honour of converse with God Almighty and who could serve as a living example of the truth of Islam? Effectively, such people have accepted that now neither does anyone possess a relationship with God, nor has anyone received the honour of divine discourse, nor is there any sign of the acceptance of prayer. Even the women from among the children of Israel received the honour of conversing with God. Is there no man in Islam who is even equal to the women from among the children of Israel?

O foolish friends of Islam! Reflect for a moment to see how this denigrates Islam. Is this why God chose the religion of Islam for you? Is this why He declared that the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, is the Seal of the Prophets—so that no sign in favour of his truth would ever be established until the Day of Resurrection, and so that all signs of life would vanish? I am deeply saddened when I see the beliefs of these people. They seem to be characterised by nothing except words, and due to their beliefs, our opponents receive ample opportunity to raise serious objections. As such, even their beliefs regarding the Messiah are not hidden. These people believe that the Messiah resurrected the dead, he created physical birds and that to this day, he is sitting in the heavens alive without being affected by the passage of time. Now, pray, do tell what have they left in turning him into God? I once asked a Muwahhid that you believe that the Messiah made certain creatures, which joined the birds of this world created by God, in which case, how would we know which creature was made by the Messiah? He responded by saying that the matter had become confused. So these are the sorts of doctrines that these people hold, yet they are very clever when it comes to raising objections against the four Imams. For example, they raise an allegation against one Imam and say that he was very wealthy but did not pay zakat. At the end of the year he would give all of his wealth to his wife, and then transfer it back to himself afterwards, and in this way, he would exclude his wealth from the application of zakat. These people raise many such allegations. They have contributed nothing to Islam except for hollow words. Through their manner of practice, they have portrayed Islam as being a dead religion since they suggest that now there is not a single man among the Muslims who comes with living signs in support of Islam. Alas! What has happened to the sense of these people? Why do they not understand? The Holy Qur’an states:

Guide us in the right path — The path of those on whom Thou hast bestowed Thy blessings.

Now, was this meant as a meaningless statement of no real value? Was this meant as a tale and nothing more? Was this favour meant to be nothing? Did God say this only to deceive us and was it always His desire to keep His seekers and truthful devotees deprived? How unjust it would be to assert that the words of God are nothing but hollow statements. This is not true, however; these are the whimsical notions of the people I have just mentioned. In actuality, the Holy Qur’an seeks to elevate a person to the stations and lofty ranks which are conferred upon those who are described in the words

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

·

10 of 10 left today