24 December 1901

Malfuzat – Volume IV

Mr Abdul-Haqq: I have understood the issue of atonement, but can you refute the concept of the Trinity?

Promised Messiah (as): In the very beginning, this is why I said that you should present your objections about Islam. Also, in my initial address, I briefly

touched upon jihad, slavery and polygamy, so that you have an opportunity to raise your objections in this regard.

The Promised Messiah (as) said: “In my opinion, it is the duty of a seeker of truth to immediately present their questions if anything agitates their heart, otherwise this will weaken their faith and will weigh heavily on their spiritual faculties. For example, if someone eats spoiled food, this causes disorder within, and ultimately the food is expelled either by vomiting or diarrhoea. Similarly, an impure belief is bound to create disorder within, and this disorder is none other than the harmful influence that affects a person’s morals and character. The person becomes a leper, as it were. So, you should be sure to ask if anything rankles your heart. I have already spoken briefly in refutation of the Trinity. But now, I would like you to provide arguments in favour of this doctrine, for as I have mentioned, the burden of proof is on you, who consider it to be the means for salvation and in doing so, oppose a large group of people. For example, it is a simple fact that human beings see with their eyes, taste and speak with their tongue, and hear with their ears. Now if someone were to dispute this universally accepted fact and claim that humans speak with their eyes and see with their ears, natural law would dictate that the burden of proof is on the one who makes this claim.

In the same way, no one believes in the Trinity. The Jews who follow the Abrahamic tradition reject this belief. They clearly state that this doctrine is nowhere to be found in their scriptures; instead they have been given the teaching of God’s Oneness, and it is forbidden to suggest the existence of another God, whether in heaven, on earth, in the sea, or anywhere else.

Further, in view of the law of nature, I demonstrated before you with evidence that it is the Unity of God in which one should believe. Then, there are marks of the Unity of God etched in the law of intuition also. Now, if you contradict the scripture, human reason and the law of intuition and claim that God is not one, but three, then it is your responsibility to provide evidence. This subject is of such a nature that our only responsibility is to hear you, because what you state is clearly at odds with the teachings given to us by the Prophets and the righteous. I call upon God as a Witness and state that I do not put the burden of proof on you by way of injustice. God has made my heart pure of such things. Weak interpretations can be of no use, nor can they grant satisfaction. Ask your heart with justice—do I not follow the path of rectitude?

So you ought to write out your points in as much detail as possible and then present them. However, bear in mind that the inherent characteristic of a claim is that it is ambiguous. Some people suffer from misunderstanding and they are unable to differentiate between a claim and evidence. Evidence serves as a bright lamp to support a claim. Therefore, it is necessary to understand the difference between a claim and evidence.”

On this, Mr Abdul-Haqq said that he would write his points and present them the following day and then the Promised Messiah (as) took leave.

10 of 10 left today