11 August 1905: (Evening Gathering)

Malfuzat – Volume VII

‘Abdul-Qayyum, the son of Hadrat Hakeemul-Ummat [Sage of the Ummah—Hadrat Maulawi Noor-ud-Deen], was ill. He was in pain last night. The Promised Messiah, peace be on him, was asking about his condition. In this connection, Hadrat Hakeemul-Ummat said that he kept thinking about the question that arises from the objection of the Aryas that the sufferings of children are the result of their previous birth. Upon this, the Promised Messiah (as) , gave the following address:

This belief is absolutely absurd! First, it is worth pondering whether the children even feel as much pain as the parents, because the sense [to feel pain] also grows with the intellect, and moreover, the child will also enter Paradise due to some right, so this is why he bears such suffering.

The fact is that human nature is such that it is reformed only by harsh treatment. The Rububiyyat [Providence] of Allah the Exalted, desires man’s perfection, and man’s servitude also requires perfection in one way or another. And so, hardships and difficulties are one of the many forms of effecting this.

The Prophets, peace be on them all, who are entirely innocent and holy beings, are also subjected to suffering and hardships. They undergo such suffering that if it befell anyone else, they would be unable to bear it. Their enemies emerge from all sides. Some cause suffering through their words, some make plans to cause harm through the authorities of the time, and some incite the people against them. In short, they are made to suffer in every way, and all kinds of restlessness, pain, and anguish come upon them. However, these things do not affect them; like a mountain, they do not move. Can this lead to the conclusion that they are the worst of sinners? Certainly not. If someone thinks like that, what would be more absurd than that?

The issue of the Prophets, peace be on them all, nicely solves the problem of children’s suffering. From the standpoint of innocence, consider them as children. These sufferings are for the perfection of servitude and are beneficial for the Hereafter. If the situation had been such that the child’s soul would disappear after death, there could be cause for objection, but in the presence of an eternal realm [the Hereafter] and lasting relief, why is this question even raised? If the question is that He should cause them to enter this eternal abode of comfort without suffering, they would ask why should there be the accountability for sins? He could have also allowed entry with them.

The answer is that Allah the Exalted is Self-Sufficient in His Being and stands in need of no one. Man must do something to attain salvation and eternal comfort. Unless he suffers hardships, he cannot find comfort and ease.

These hardships are of two types. The first is due to a person battling against himself, so he carries out spiritual exercises and passes through many hardships. And the second case is that the decree and determination of God sends down some hardships on him to cleanse him through this means. In this way, the souls of the child and the Prophets, peace be on them, are holy. They are sinless and innocent, yet sufferings and hardships come upon them to perfect them and to manifest their morals, veracity, and sincerity. Striving and endeavouring are necessary for a human being, and together with this, suffering and difficulties are also essential.

Those who endeavour benefit from its fruits. Similarly, those who strive in the way of Allah the Exalted and sacrifice their lives see the Signs of Divine nearness, lights, blessings, and acceptance, and the layout of Paradise is disclosed to them. These people are unaware of this path and deprived of these rewards, so they make such unholy and absurd objections. According to their beliefs, no one achieves salvation. This is the reason why they believe in transmigration. I am certain—and it is absolutely true—that the sufferings of this world are rewarded in the next world; others receive it in the same way that Prophets and Messengers receive it.

This is the practice of Allah. And human weakness was necessary so that he could not be the equal of God Almighty. Indeed, by attaining the nearness of Allah the Exalted, man can become a manifestation of Divine splendour. For this, he must bear suffering, hardships, and many beatings. This is a phenomenon whose truth is being proved by experience. So, when

53:40). [Publisher]

The unfortunate Aryas continue being blind. They do not see that there is another realm as well, and man is not God. There are weaknesses in him and these weaknesses are there so that he is not called equal to God. (Badr, vol. 1, no. 20, p. 3, dated 17 August 1905)

Those who strive and bear suffering patiently attain great ranks, and they are given a distinction over others. They are made the target of Divine decrees, they are subjected to beatings and then the great grace of God embraces them. (Badr, vol. 1, no. 20, p. 3, dated 17 August 1905)

a phenomenon is confirmed by experience, discussion about it is absurd.

The Promised Messiah (as) said:

In the argument of transmigration, the mention of disparity between the rich and the poor is also something absurd. This is so because Zakat and charity has been prescribed for the rich, and patience has been prescribed for the poor, and there is a reward for both. An example of this is that of a short journey. One person has excellent food with him for the trip, while the other has only coarsely ground grain. Both will complete the journey and derive benefit, each according to his deeds upon reaching the destination.

There are so many objections to transmigration that one is astounded. For example, on the one hand, these people consider distant clans and castes while considering establishing a relationship by marriage. However, if a child’s mother or sister dies at a young age, is born in another place, and marries him, what arrangement is in place to stop this from occurring? And then it would be necessary for transmigration to also suggest the types of crimes because the abundance of insects produced must all be due to different crimes. And then the sin

10 of 10 left today