23 September 1905: (Before Noon)

Malfuzat – Volume VII

(Before noon)

Today, incidentally, in the gathering of the Promised Messiah, peace and blessings be on him, Miyan Charagh Din, a resident of Jammu, was mentioned in the context of his recently published book, Minaratul- Masih in which Islam has been gravely defiled. Upon the mention of this book, His Holiness said:

He is a bitter opponent of Islam. He has given superiority to the Messiah [ Jesus] over the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, in every matter. Yet, he also says that he has come to bring about a reconciliation between Islam and

Christianity. What a bizarre statement this is! There is a difference of heaven and earth between Islam and Christianity, yet he wishes to bring about reconciliation. He has uttered a lot of abuse against me in this book.

The grave of the Messiah located in Kashmir was mentioned. The summary of what the Promised Messiah (as) said about it is as follows:

It has been established by many proofs and arguments that it is indeed the grave of the Messiah [ Jesus], peace be on him. And not only is his grave here, but I believe that some of his friends’ graves are also located in this place. In the first place the name Yuz Asaf itself points to it. Besides, since he was considered a rebel in his homeland, therefore, he could not stay anywhere under the control of that government. So, Allah the Exalted had mercy on him and chose for him a cold country like Syria, to which he migrated. Moreover, since the 10 exiled tribes of the Jews, whose whereabouts were not known, were also settled here, therefore, it was also incumbent for him to come here to fulfil his duty of preaching. And then the names of the villages and other things here are also similar to some of the villages, etc., of the land of Syria.

(On this occasion, Mufti Muhammad Sadiq submitted that the word ‘Kaasheer’ exists. This word [Kashmir] is actually ‘Kaasheer’, we people add ‘ م [m]’ to it. Native Kashmiris call it ‘Kaasheer’ and they are called ‘Kaasher’. And ‘Aasheer’ in the Hebrew language is the name of the land of Syria and ‘ک [k]’ means the ‘like of ’, thus [Kaasheer] meaning ‘the like of Syria’. Then there are many other such names. Editor)

Collect all those names so they can be referenced somewhere.

In this discourse, he said that:

Ikmal-ud-Din, which is an old book, clearly shows that he is a Prophet of 1,900 years ago. Then the customs and practices, etc., of the Kashmiris resemble those of the Jews. Bernier, the French traveller, has also written that they are the Children of Israel. Apart from this, the arrival in India of the disciple Thomas is proven.

(At this point, Mufti Sahib said that I have read in a book that when Mary fell ill, she wanted to meet Thomas who was in India at that time. So her coffin was brought to India. She was very pleased to meet Thomas and blessed him. And then Thomas led her funeral prayer. On this mention, it was said that it would not be surprising if this was actually a ploy to reunite with her son. There was varied discussion about it.)

In the above discourse, the Promised Messiah (as) said:

When we present the verse

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

[falamma tawaffaitani—when You caused me to die] in support of the death of the Messiah [ Jesus], it is objected that if the Messiah, peace be on him, had gone to Kashmir after the incident of the cross, then he should have said, ‘when You caused me to reach Kashmir’ instead of

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

[falamma tawaffaitani—when You caused me to die].

The reply to this objection is that this objection is based on a fallacy. It is true that the Messiah, peace be on him, came down alive from the cross and came to Kashmir from there when he found the opportunity. But in this verse, Allah Almighty did not ask about the condition of his opponents. He asks about the condition of his own ummah. The opponents continued to be kafir [disbelievers] and kadhdhab [deniers]. Secondly, the Messiah, peace be on him, has also said this in his response here:

The expression

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

[ma dumtu f ihim—‘as long as I remained among them’] demands that where the Messiah goes, his disciples must go as well. It cannot happen that an Appointee and Messenger of God Almighty is saved from a grave threat to his life and then he migrates in accord with the will of God Almighty and yet his followers and disciples abandon him completely and do not go after him. Of course not. They, too, came here to be with him. Yes, it is possible that they did not all come at once, but came separately. Thus, the coming of Thomas to India is proven. The Christians themselves have accepted it.

There is a precedent for this type of emigration in the emigration of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. Although his faithful and devoted followers were present in Makkah, when he migrated, he took with him only Hadrat Abu Bakr, may Allah be pleased with him.

10 of 10 left today