26 September 1905: (Before Noon)
Malfuzat – Volume VII, Part 11
Nevertheless, here its opposite applies. It is learnt from the earlier scriptures and the Gospels that Jesus will come. But when it has been proven that he had died and having already come, no one would even think that he would be resurrected to return.
As for the issue of his death, it is so clear that there is no need to say much about it. God Almighty through His Word:
And Jesus through his confession:
And the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, through his vision when he saw Jesus together with John [the Baptist], peace be on him, during the night of Mi‘raj [Ascension], has proven that Jesus has died. Otherwise, if he is still alive, why would he be living next to one who has died? And apart from this, the first ijma‘ [consensus] of the Noble Companions upon the death of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, was that the Messiah had died. As I have stated many times that Hadrat ‘Umar, may Allah be pleased with him, drew his sword upon his death and threatened that if anyone said he had died, he would cut off his head. On this, Hadrat Abu Bakr, may Allah be pleased with him, stood up and delivered the sermon:
That is, the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, is also a Messenger and all the Messengers before him have passed away.
Now, tell me: Is there any exception in this for Jesus or anyone else? Did Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) exempt anyone from this? And since when could the Companions (ra) tolerate accepting someone else to be alive while passing the judgement that the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, had died?
In short, the ijma‘ [consensus] of the Companions (ra) confirms his death as well. Moreover, common sense rejects it outright. We generally see with our eyes. If you adduce before the intellect that you see with your ears, how is it going to accept this? Similarly, when there isn’t any precedent of ascending the heavens alive with this body since the time of Adam to the present, how can we believe that [ Jesus] the Messiah ascended to heaven alive with this earthly body ?
If there is any precedent to be found, it is the precedent of the [second] coming of Elijah, which was promised in the Book of the Prophet Malachi. And the issue of his return was resolved by Jesus himself, that John [the Baptist] was the Elijah who was to return—accept it if you will. Now, it is learnt from this precedent that this is, indeed, what is meant by the second coming, and that such words are used metaphorically. If, even after this, there is doubt about the verdict of death, then first break these arguments and then present a judgement contradicting the judgment about of the second coming which was made by the court of none other than Jesus himself. He proved that the one who is promised to come, comes only in his likeness.
You say that he used to raise those who had literally died. So if this is true, why did he not resurrect Elijah so that his own prophethood would not be doubted and the Jewish nation would not have been ruined? They had questioned only the prophecy of Malachi. That issue—and not any other—had become the obstacle and difficulty in his path. They did not concede the interpretation given by the Messiah and were adjudged accursed for rejecting him.
Sometimes, when our opponents cannot refute this argument, they say that these books have been falsified and altered. I say that they may be falsified and altered, but what will you do about the continuous narrations present among them? The Jews are still present—ask them if they are not waiting for the inevitable return of Elijah before the Messiah. The Christians acknowledge this as well. If they did not acknowledge this why would they accept John [the Baptist] as having come in the likeness of Elijah?
So the Jews and the Christians—despite being mutual enemies—are in total agreement on this issue. In such a case, it becomes absolutely clear that these matters strongly support us. Just as John [the Baptist] was called Elijah, in the same way, Allah Almighty named me ‘Isa [ Jesus]. But should someone question what the wisdom was in this name, in its reply, it should be remembered that the Jews had turned away because of this very mischief [alleging] that Elijah did not come. Accordingly, I have in my possession the book of a Jewish scholar wherein he has laid great emphasis on this issue and has even written that if they are questioned on the Day of Judgment, they will present the scripture of the Prophet Malachi and will ask, ‘Where is it written that his “likeness” would come?’
So this was the trial that caused the Jews to become accursed and astray. It was incumbent upon this Ummah, on account of the similarity with the Mosaic dispensation, for a Messiah to appear. Besides, because it was said for this Ummah that in the Latter Days it would become like the Jews,
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[maghdub] in
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
, is understood, by consensus, to refer to the Jews. Thus, they [the Muslims] would become ‘Jews’ only if a Jesus had been presented before them and they had rejected him in the same way.
Accordingly, it came to pass exactly so, that the Jesus to come did come but they rejected him. What is my fault in this? They are held to even greater culpability for the reason that the precedent of Elijah was right before them. Nevertheless, it is a pity that they did not even reflect upon this and they still do not. May Allah have mercy on them. Amin.