28 September 1905: (Before Noon)
Malfuzat – Volume VII
(Before noon)
Today, a Turk and a Jew came to visit His Holiness, peace and blessings be on him. They asked the Promised Messiah (as) a few questions. I am recording them here along with their responses. It should be remembered that the questions and answers were in the Arabic language. I am taking their purport and writing it in Urdu. (Editor)
The Turk—You claim that you are the Mahdi and it is mentioned in the ahadith that the Mahdi will wage war when he comes.
Promised Messiah (as)—You do not know. This concept is completely false. All ahadith of this type about the Mahdi have been declared by the Muhaddithin [scholars of Hadith] to be majruh [questionable]. There is only one hadith,
[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]
; meaning, ‘There is no Mahdi to come except for the Promised Messiah’, the very Promised One who is referred to in [Sahih al-]Bukhari as ْ م
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[Imamukum minkum— ‘your Imam from among you’]; that is, the one who is to come from this very Ummah.
Further, it is not written anywhere about him that he will fight wars. On the contrary, in [Sahih al-]Bukhari, which is
[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]
ا [the most authentic book after the Book of Allah] it is clearly written that
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[yada‘ul-harb—‘he will end warfare’]. In other words, there will be no religious wars during his time. This is because there is no need for warfare anymore. Our adversaries do not wage war against us. They criticize with the pen. So, how great a weakness would it be failing to reply to the pen with the pen, but rather resorting to weapons for this? In such a situation when attacks are occurring with the pen, it is verily our duty to stop them with the pen. Moreover, if it was the intent of Almighty Allah that the advancement of Islam during this era would be through war, then every kind of weaponry would have been granted to the Muslims, albeit the extent of military inventions occurring in Europe are not taking place anywhere else. From this, it is clear that in the plan of God Almighty this is not the time for fighting, nor can any religion or faith ever spread through fighting.
Even beforehand, the sword was never raised for the growth and propagation of Islam. Islam has spread through the means of its blessings, illumination, and spiritual effects and will always spread in this very way. So, this is the most egregiously false and abominable concept that there will be war in the time of the Messiah, nor is the Messiah in need of it. He will use the pen and manifestly prove the Divine origin and veracity of Islam with powerful arguments and effects and will make it prevail over other religions, and this is happening.
The Turk—It has also been said that the Holy Qur’an will be lifted in the time of the Messiah. Where has it been lifted at this time?
Promised Messiah (as)—One of the Companions had also asked this from the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, that how would the Holy Qur’an be lifted at that time. He s (as) had replied to him, ‘I had thought that you were a wise person.’ My reply is precisely the same.
Do you not see that no one acts upon the Holy Qur’an? Nothing is being done for its support and honour. The Holy Qur’an has been eschewed and shunned in letter and spirit, in form and substance, and Muslims are becoming increasingly unaware of its verities and insights and its teachings. How else will the Holy Qur’an be lifted?
(The Turkish gentleman became silent after two questions. Then the Jewish gentleman started presenting his questions.)
The Jew—Tauhid [Oneness of God] also exists among the Jews. What does Islam offer more than that?
Promised Messiah (as) —There is no Tauhid among the Jews. Yes, the shell of Tauhid is undoubtedly there but a mere shell cannot be of any use. There are levels of Tauhid. Without them, the true essence of Tauhid cannot be known. It is not enough to say
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[La ilaha illallah—‘There is no one worthy of worship except Allah’]. Even Satan says this. So long as the true essence of
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
is not proven to be in the being of man in a practical manner, it is nothing. Where is this aspect in the Jews? You tell me.
The initial stage and status of Tauhid is that nothing be perpetrated against the Word of Almighty Allah by man and no action of his should run contrary to the love for Almighty Allah. It should be as if he is engrossed and annihilated in the love and obedience of Almighty Allah. For this very reason its meanings [in Arabic] are: ُِہللا
Keep in mind there are various kinds of shirk [polytheism]. Among them, one shirk is said to be overt; the other shirk covert. An example of overt shirk is generally what these idolaters do when they consider idols, trees, or other objects to be Gods. Covert shirk is when man venerates anything in the very same manner he venerates—or should venerate—Almighty Allah, or loves anything the way he loves Almighty Allah, or fears it or relies upon it.