1 October 1905
Malfuzat – Volume VIII
It was mentioned that someone had printed the photograph of the Promised Messiah (as) on postcards so people could purchase these cards and use them as letters.
The Promised Messiah, on whom be peace and blessings, said:
In my view, this is not correct. This is the first step in spreading innovation. I permitted the taking of a photograph so that the people of Europe and America, who are very far from us
servant the Promised Messiah. [Publisher]
Messiah, may peace and blessings be upon him. Al-Hakam also published his advertisement and continued doing so, thinking it to be an ordinary announcement. Allah the Exalted knows best what my intention was in posting this advertisement. My personal opinion was that this would also be a means of preaching. But this disease of printing photos began to spread to such an extent that Hadrat Hujjatullah,the Promised Messiah, may peace and blessings be upon him, had to pay special attention to it and issued a very strongly worded fatwa regarding its sanctity and prohibition. Thus, this innovative practice ended as soon as it had begun.
[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]
This announcement had been given briefly in the previous publication of al-Hakam. The speech of the Promised Messiah (as) is set out in detail today. The use of the card with the picture of Hadrat Hujjatullah, the Promised Messiah, may peace and blessings be upon him, will, we now trust, most certainly come to an end after today. (From the Editor of al-Hakam)
and possess knowledge of physiognomy and benefit therefrom, may be able to derive a spiritual benefit from it. Because the type of prohibition that applies to images is not universally applicable; on the contrary, sometimes, if the mujtahid sees that a benefit exists without any loss, then he can use it as needed. Permission was granted because of this particular need of Europe. Accordingly, some letters came from Europe and America in which it was written that by looking at the photograph, it appears as if this is precisely that very Messiah. Similarly, an image can sometimes prove very helpful in diagnosing a disease. In the Shariah, every matter that comes under
for much longer. However, these cards upon which the photograph is made should not be purchased. Pictures are the root of idolatry. When a person believes in someone, he tends to pay some reverence to the picture as well. Avoid such things and stay away from them, lest disaster befall our Community at its very inception. I have recorded this prohibition in a book that is under print. I am extremely angry with those people in the Jama‘at who do such things; God is angry with them. Nevertheless, should anyone’s soul be profited through any means, then that method is exempt.
(A card with a photograph was shown) Upon seeing it, the Promised Messiah (as) said: ‘This is absolutely forbidden.’
A person brought a bundle of such cards and showed them, saying that as he bought these commercially for sale, what should he do now?
Burn them and destroy them. There is disdain for religion and disdain for the Shariah in this. Moreover, do not keep them at home. There is nothing to be gained from this; instead, it ultimately gives rise to idolatry. It would have been better had there been a propagational message in lieu of the photograph.