2 October 1905
Malfuzat – Volume VIII
The discussion concerned the issue of jihad. Here is a summary of what the Promised Messiah (as) said about it:
This criticism against Islamic jihad, that those battles were for the sake of religion and spreading Islam is simply absurd for the reason that the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, continued suffering extreme hardship in Makkah for 13 years at the hands of the disbelievers, and his devoted Companions suffered and sacrificed their lives. The disbelievers inflicted shameless suffering upon some poor and helplessly weak women.
It reached the point that he was ultimately forced to migrate, but those disbelievers pursued him there as well. In such a predicament, when their mischief and oppression exceeded all bounds, then God Almighty commanded them to fight as a means of defence and resistance.
Accordingly, the first verse commanding the carrying out of jihad was:
Meaning that, those who have been wronged are permitted to fight. The Muslims were the oppressed; they were not the instigators. On the contrary, the disbelievers of Makkah were the aggressors. Even in this situation, it was only when their transgressions reached the point of extremity that Allah the Exalted gave hims (as) the command to fight back in self-defence.
Therefore, the criticism that those battles were for religious reasons is simply frivolous and futile. Had they been undertaken only for the sake of [spreading the] religion, why would they have been abandoned in cases where jizyah [tax on non-Muslim citizens] was given? Furthermore, I say that Christians cannot raise this type of criticism at all. They should assess their own situation whether the Islamic battles are any worse than the Mosaic battles. And since they also believe Jesus to be (God forbid) the God of Moses, peace be on him, the blame for these battles falls upon the Christians according to the prevailing standard, particularly given the situation that those battles were far more fierce and bloody than the Islamic wars.
In the Islamic battles, children, women, and the elderly were protected and not killed, but these standards were not adhered to in the Mosaic battles. Similarly, in Islamic wars, religious places of worship and fruit-bearing trees were not destroyed. However, in the Mosaic battles, fruit-bearing trees were destroyed. In short, Islamic war is nothing in comparison to the Mosaic battles.
The Promised Messiah (as) said:
It has always been the practice of Allah the Exalted that when any Appointee or Messenger comes from Him, only the weak and poor initially enter his Jama‘at; kings or nobles do not pay attention. But ultimately, Allah the Exalted bestows every kind of progress upon the Jama‘at of the poor. A revelation of mine states:
Kings shall seek blessings from thy garments.
Those kings were also shown to me. From this it is known that a time will come when Allah Almighty will confer the realization of this Movement’s truth upon some of them.
The Promised Messiah (as) said:
The people of Punjab are tender-hearted. These people are devoid of that noise and nuisance found in [the rest of ] Indians. The Indians rebelled, but the Punjabis remained loyal to the Government. Our Mirza Sahib also gave fifty horses to the Government by way of assistance at that time.
[The rest of ] India is nowhere close to the extent to which the Punjabis have accepted me.