25 December 1906
Malfuzat – Volume IX
(Morning walk)
On the morning of the 25th, the Promised Messiah (as) went out for a walk. A large gathering accompanied him, the majority of which included Ahmadi brothers from the Sialkot district who presented themselves before the Promised Messiah (as) with their worthy leader, Chaudhary Maula Bakhsh.
One person asked some questions. The first question was: ‘Since God Almighty has been the Creator since the beginning and will be to the very end, and souls have always been among His creations and will continue to be, then according to the belief of the Aryas, is the soul also eternal and everlasting?’
The Promised Messiah (as) said:
This statement is not correct. There is false reasoning in the question. God Almighty has been the Creator since eternity, but all His attributes should be considered. He gives life and also causes death. He is the One who establishes, and He is also the One who effaces. He is the One who creates, and He is also the One who annihilates.
What proof is there that souls are not mortal, and that these same souls have continued to be in existence eternally? He sustains a being as long as He wishes; everything has to see an end. The only being that is eternal is God. As the soul experiences progress and decline, then how can it remain forever? So long as the soul exists, it does so under Divine command. A being can exist only under the command of God, and He alone is also the One who annihilates. He is forever the Creator and He forever obliterates creation as well. A Muslim believes in the eternality of kind, not in the eternality of individual form. This means that Islam teaches that we do not know what forms existed before and what did not. Contrarily holding a belief in the eternality of individual form would lead to atheism.