Undated
Malfuzat – Volume IX
I [Akmal Sahib of Goleki] submitted that it is a tradition in villages that on occasions of joy and sorrow they undertake a type of expense. For example, when a landlord dies, they distribute money among all the mosques, neighbourhoods and the poor according to their needs. What is the directive of the Promised Messiah (as) in this respect? The Promised Messiah (as) responded:
The food that is distributed, its reward does reach the deceased but not to the same degree as if the deceased had done so himself during his lifetime.
It was submitted to the Promised Messiah (as) that funds are distributed among the poor as a right for their service.
The Promised Messiah, peace be on him, said:
Then there is no harm in this. This is a different matter altogether. A person should be compensated for his services.
It was submitted that these actions do carry pride and ostentation, that is, it is in the heart of the donor that others will proclaim him to be a person of status.
The Promised Messiah (as) said:
This expenditure is not undertaken to earn [spiritual] merit to begin with, it is compensation for service. To openly carry out some deeds is permitted under the Shariah, for example, giving alms, etc., the directive to offer Prayers in congregation, so that they act as a means of encouragement for others. There are occasions for deeds to be carried out openly and secretly. The truth of the matter is that the Shariah does not forbid all customs. If it were so, then riding a train and seeking information through telegram and post, all would have been deemed innovations.
I [Akmal Sahib of Goleki] asked the Promised Messiah (as) for his directive regarding tanbul [cash, given as wedding gift]. The Promised Messiah (as) replied:
The response is the same. It is a kind of support for one’s brother.
It was submitted that those who contribute to tanbul, they participate with the intention that by contributing five rupees, they will receive six instead, and then they spend this money on vagrants. The Promised Messiah (as) said:
My response concerns the original custom that there is no objection on the nature of the custom. As far as intention is concerned, how can you know the intention of others? This is a trait of contemptible people to give with an intention to receive more in return, or keep an accounting of insignificant matters. There are generous people who participate in tanbul to abide by the directive of cooperation and relationships of love, and some do not even want to retrieve their contribution but rather support the poor. In short, the response to everything is:
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]