10 February 1907
Malfuzat – Volume IX
Another letter was received from the Manager of Gurukul, Gujranwala addressed to the Promised Messiah (as). The Promised Messiah (as) directed Mufti [Muhammad Sadiq] Sahib to write its response. So the following detailed letter was written.
Respected Manager Gurukal Gujranwala
Salutations! Your second letter to His Holiness was received in which you have indicated that you cannot spare more than half an hour, and that for a scholar, due to their knowledge, this time is sufficient. It is submitted as a reply that His Holiness (as) states,
Such a short time cannot be sufficient under any circumstances for dialogue on important religious matters; therefore, I cannot participate in such a gathering. If you had allocated a time of at least three hours for my presentation, then it was possible that I could have come myself, or could have sent a learned friend with my presentation. I cannot comprehend in any way that for such sublime subjects only a half an hour speech is sufficient. I am not bound by formalities, rather I adhere to establishing the truth. In regard to your statement that for an eminent scholar half an hour is sufficient, I am surprised as to how you determine this assertion to be valid whereas the writers of your sacred Vedas did not stop writing their discourses until they weighed the load of a donkey, then why do you entertain such hope from me. To strangulate a point of [divine] cognizance before its completion is to murder the truth which no pious person would desire to do. If the measure of knowledge and learning lies in brevity to the extreme degree and a short time, then the Vedas should have ended with just a few lines. I regret that this limited time has deprived me of this collaboration. Is it a task of half an hour to say something on the being and attributes of God Almighty, and then to elaborate the hidden philosophy behind the soul and matter? Certainly not. Rather even this word enters the realm of disrespect. Those who wish to boast merely of participation, they can proceed as they wish. However, the one who proves a point with arguments cannot be content with an unfinished presentation. To leave the truth incomplete is like the miscarriage of a foetus before its appointed time of birth. Now, the choice is yours.
Servant of the Promised Messiah, Muhammad Sadiq, may Allah forgive him.