21 April 1907
Malfuzat – Volume IX
Becoming Well Versed in Religion
The Promised Messiah (as) said:
Members of our Jama‘at ought to develop a deeper understanding in the science of religion. However, this does not mean what the mainstream mullahs have understood, that they prop themselves up as theologians upon learning a few tenets about personal hygiene etc., and that, too, in the manner of empty mimicry! Rather, my objective is that they ponder over verses in the Holy Qur’an, the Hadith of the Prophet and my words—to be acquainted with insights in the Holy Qur’an and verities. Should any opponent raise an objection against them, they should be capable of giving him a thorough rebuttal.
The proposal that was presented on one occasion to hold an examination, was quite necessary. This should certainly be implemented. Haqiqatul-Wahi is an extremely useful book for this purpose. In reality, this response to the Muslims is quite sufficient that they should try and raise such an objection against this [Ahmadiyya] Movement that cannot be raised against other Prophets, peace be on them. They will never be able to come up with any such objection.
They raise objections concerning the prophecies related to Atham or Ahmad Baig, but do not even mention other prophecies and Signs. How unjust this is! I have explained to them many a time that a prophecy of warning can be averted. Observe that the prophecy of Jonah was averted, and no chastisement befell his nation. Keep in mind that it is the belief of all peoples that giving sadaqah [charity] dispels calamity, and God Almighty also states:
Istighfar [seeking forgiveness from Allah] is a means of safeguarding against punishment. Should anyone judge by my experiences, then if there is an ominous command in the morning, it is abrogated in the evening.
The second objection is on my personal views relating to some of my revelations that they ended up being wrong. Acknowledging it, I say that the matter that needs to be analysed is whether a Prophet can make a mistake in their interpretation or not. So, we observe that Jesus (as) initially considered his kingdom to be worldly, and directed his disciples to buy arms, but eventually it was realised that it was his mistake, and he refrained from it. Then there is the incident of our Messenger of God, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, concerning the Treaty of
Hudaibiyyah. What was the intention he came with and then what transpired? Since the person of the Holy Prophet s (as) was the embodiment of excellences of all Prophets, it is, therefore, proven from only a single incident that a Prophet can make a mistake in his interpretation. In view of this, there cannot be any objection raised against me.