26 April 1907
Malfuzat – Volume IX
During Maghrib Prayer, due to the large congregation, the voice of the Imam could not reach the people standing in the last few rows. Therefore, a person [the mukabbir] in the middle rows, as per the custom, repeated the takbir calls of the Imam in a loud voice. During the last rak‘at of the Prayer, when the congregation was sitting [in Qa‘dah] and had finished reciting the at-Tahiyyat [prayer] and the Durud Sharif [invocation of blessings upon the Holy Prophet s (as)], and prior to the Imam saying salam at the end of the Prayer, the mukabbir made a mistake and called out the end salam.
The congregation standing in the back rows followed the mukabbir in saying the end salam and some even began offering their Sunnah Prayer. Thereafter, the Imam called out the end salam, and the mukabbir, who had realised his mistake, also called out the end salam again. At this point, the congregation who had finished their Prayer beforehand inquired whether their Prayer was complete or whether they should offer their Prayer again.
Sahibzadah Mirza Mahmud Ahmad who himself was praying in the last few rows and had recited the end salam before the Imam, said:
This issue had already been presented to the Promised Messiah (as)
and His Holiness had said: ‘If it so happens in the last rak‘at
of the Prayer, and they have finished reciting at-Tahiyyat, then the Prayer of the congregation is complete. There is no need to offer the Prayer again.’
The question was presented: ‘Some mosques are of the kind that have concluded either legally or through mutual understanding that Ahmadis and non-Ahmadis have the option to offer their Prayers separately there, each with their own congregations and their own Imams. At such a place, what should be done for Jumu‘ah [the Friday Prayer] as two Jumu‘ah services are not allowed in the same mosque? The Promised Messiah (as) said:
The people who declare you as kafirs [disbelievers] and do not offer Prayers behind you, do not consider your Adhan and your Jumu‘ah Prayer to be valid anyhow. For this reason they will go ahead and offer their own Prayers. And since they call a believer
a disbeliever, they have themselves become kafir according to the Hadith. For this reason, you also hold the view that their Adhan and Prayers have no substance. You call your own Adhan and offer your own Jumu‘ah with your Imam.
Hajj-e-Badal [Hajj Performed on Behalf of Someone]
The heirs of a deceased Ahmadi from Khushab wrote a letter to the Promised Messiah (as) that the deceased had a firm intention to go for Hajj, but death did not allow him to d0 so. Is it permissible now that someone may be sponsored and sent on his behalf ? The Promised Messiah (as) said:
It is permissible. The deceased will receive the reward of the
Hajj.