9 July 1907

Malfuzat – Volume IX

A person raised a question whether it was permissible if, merely for Allah’s sake, someone lets a bull roam freely just for breeding. The Promised Messiah (as) replied:

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

. The default or natural state of things is one of permissibility. Only those things which God Almighty has declared haram [unlawful] are haram; everything else is halal [lawful]. A great many situations are dependent upon intention. In my opinion, this is permissible; nay, rather, an act of virtue.

It was submitted that this is mentioned in the Glorious Qur’an. The Promised Messiah (as) said:

I kept this in view while responding. They donate in the names of idols. Here it is specifically in the name of God Almighty. Breeding is a necessary thing. In the Glorious Qur’an, God Almighty has mentioned cattle etc. amongst His favours. Therefore, this favour should be appreciated, and breeding is a form of appreciation as well. Hence, if that were not the case, then quadrupeds would become weak and the functioning of the world would not be able to run well. Therefore, in my opinion, there is no harm in this thing. Every deed is dependent upon intention. When carried out in the name of anyone other than Allah, it is haram [unlawful], but the very same deed is halal [lawful] if it is done for the sake of Allah.

An individual posed the question:

Your Holiness, since it is your teaching to supplicate in one’s own language during the formal Prayer, is it permissible for the Imam to go on praying aloud in his own language (for example in Urdu) and the congregation to go on responding with Amin?

The Promised Messiah (as) replied:

What is the need for reciting the prayer aloud? God Almighty has in fact directed:

And:

It was submitted: ‘The Qunut is recited [aloud].’ The Promised Messiah (as) replied:

Yes, the supplications attributed to the Holy Prophet s (as) that are mentioned in the Holy Qur’an and the Hadith can undoubtedly be

[Publisher]

qiyam posture, just before sajdah. [Publisher]

recited [aloud]. Other prayers that reflect a personal liking or feeling should just be recited in the heart.

The question was presented:

What is the directive of Your Holiness about the edict that so many buckets of water should be taken out from a well when a rat, hen, goat, or a person dies inside it? Previously, our practice was to consider the water pure unless its colour, smell, or taste changed.

The Promised Messiah (as) responded:

My belief is only that which has been mentioned in the Hadith. I simply do not know, nor does my jurisdiction govern the number of how many buckets to take out if this animal falls in or how many if another falls in.

It was submitted, ‘Your Holiness has directed to abide by Hanafi fiqh [jurisprudence] when the authentic Sunnah [Practice of the Prophet s (as)] is not known.’ The Promised Messiah (as) replied:

When is there any such determination in the prominent works of Fiqh [Islamic jurisprudence]; but, yes, it is written in Nijatul-Mu’minin. However, in that it is also written:

[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]

Does anyone act upon this and is it allowed whereas Prayer is not permitted for women during their menstruation and parturition. Consider this issue in the same vein too.

I state a principle for you that is set forth in the Glorious Qur’an:

Therefore, when the condition of the water is such that there is a danger of risk to health then it should be cleansed. For example, if leaves or insects etc. fall in (even though these maulawis do not issue a fatwa of contamination on this); otherwise, there is no determination of quantity. So long as the colour, smell or taste is not changed by contamination, that water is pure.

10 of 10 left today