August 1907

Malfuzat – Volume IX

A person submitted: ‘I sell sugar at a shop in a village. Sometimes, boys or the servants and employees of the landlords bring cotton or wheat or something similar and barter it for merchandise, as is the general practice in villages; but some boys or servants bring these things without the knowledge of the owner. Is it permissible to give the merchandise in this situation or not?’ The Promised Messiah (as) replied:

When it is certain that an item is stolen property then to take it is impermissible, but to put oneself into undue suspicion is an undesirable act. To investigate such matters, and for no reason prove someone as a thief, is not the prerogative of the shopkeeper. If the shopkeeper will engage himself in such investigations, then when will he tend to his shop? It is not permissible for everyone to investigate. It is understood from the Holy Qur’an that Allah the Exalted directed the Israelites to slaughter a cow. It was better to just get hold of a cow and slaughter it as that would have fulfilled the injunction. Without need, they began asking other questions like how that cow is, what is its colour, and by asking such questions, they put themselves into further difficulty. Asking too many questions and to engage into excessive probing is not good.

10 von 10 heute frei