2 October 1907
Malfuzat – Volume IX
Perishes in the Lifetime of the Truthful One
A member of our Jama‘at presented a question from a non-Ahmadi, ‘You have written in your literature that the liar perishes in the very life of the truthful one. This is incorrect as Musailimah the Great-Liar died after the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him.’ The Promised Messiah (as) said:
Where is it written that the liar dies in the lifetime of the one who is true? I have not written so in my literature. Come and present the book to me in which I have penned this. I have written that the one who is a liar from among the parties in a prayer duel perishes in the lifetime of the one who is true. Musailimah al-Kadhdhab [the Great Liar] did not enter into a prayer duel. The Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, had said this much to him, ‘Even if you remain alive after me, you will surely perish’, so this is exactly what transpired. Musailimah al-Kadhdhab was killed a short while after and the prophecy was fulfilled.
The statement that the liar dies in the lifetime of the truthful one is completely wrong. Did all the enemies of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, perish in his lifetime? On the contrary, thousands of his enemies remained alive after his demise. However, the liar who enters into a prayer duel dies in the life of the truthful one. In the same way, my opponents, too, will remain alive after my death, and it is necessary for the opponents to exist until the Day of Resurrection as is apparent from:
I am simply astonished by hearing such statements over and over again. Look! How my statements are turned inside out and misrepresented, and they have attained such perfection in distortion that they have surpassed even the Jews. Has this ever occurred in the life of any Prophet, Wali, Qutb, or Ghauth that all their enemies had died? On the contrary, the disbelievers and hypocrites were still there after them. However, this much is correct that the liars who enter into a prayer duel with the truthful, they die in the lifetime of the truthful as is transpiring with the ones who are entering into a prayer duel with me.
and Respond to General Questions Itself
I feel regret for my Jama‘at that they do not possess even this much sense to ask those who pose such objections where I have written that the liar dies and perishes in the life of the truthful even without them engaging in a prayer duel. Present the reference where this is written. Our Jama‘at ought to make progress in intellect and understanding in every way, and respond to such matters themselves after proper consideration and should resolve such matters with the light of their faith, but being absorbed in worldly pursuits dulls the senses. They could not do so much as ask the critic where exactly it is written in my book that, ‘All liars die in the life of the truthful.’ Nonetheless, liars will remain in existence until the Day of Resurrection.
to Study the Books of the Promised Messiah (as)
The Promised Messiah (as) said:
From this initiative, I am also reminded that the people who travel abroad for propagating and preaching the Message should not be such that they misrepresent and distort my statements, presenting something different to what is demanded and acquainting others with my claims while they themselves have never even read my books. This is how alterations begin. At such times, there should not only be a verbal verdict, but a writing should be presented.
It is alleged against me that Prophet Jesus, peace be upon him, and Imam Husain (ra) are disrespected whereas I consider them pious and righteous. It is alleged that Prophet Jesus, peace be upon him, is deeply insulted and abused, whereas I consider him to be a Prophet of high resolve and a pious servant of God. However, if to prove the death of Prophet Jesus (as) is disrespectful in their view then I am guilty of it, for I believe that he has died like other Prophets.