7. In the Mubahala that Hazrat Masih Mau‘ud (as) held with Sanaullah Sahib, the other person died [first]; Maulvi Sanaullah Sahib received a long life and died after the death of Hazrat Masih Mau‘ud (as), after Partition. The scholars say: Hazrat Mirza Sahib had written that the truthful one should live and the liar perish in the lifetime of the truthful; since Sanaullah stayed alive despite the challenge, Mirza Sahib's own standard went against him. So what right do you have to consider Mirza Sahib truthful?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 13 February 1984
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: In the Mubahala that Hazrat Masih Mau‘ud (as) held with Sanaullah Sahib, the other person died [first]; Maulvi Sanaullah Sahib received a long life and died after the death of Hazrat Masih Mau‘ud (as), after Partition. The scholars say: Hazrat Mirza Sahib had written that the truthful one should live and the liar perish in the lifetime of the truthful; since Sanaullah stayed alive despite the challenge, Mirza Sahib's own standard went against him. So what right do you have to consider Mirza Sahib truthful?
Let me tell you: when Maulvi Sanaullah Sahib received this message from Hazrat Masih Mau‘ud (as), he replied in his newspaper and wrote: 'You have set an entirely wrong standard. If this standard were accepted as true, then God would not have let Muhammad Mustafa (saw) die in the lifetime of Musailima the Liar. I therefore hold the standard that the liar's rope is lengthened.' So he says: 'I do not accept your proposal at all; our contest will be by this [my] standard.' He named Musailima the Liar and said that Musailima did not die in the lifetime of Muhammad Mustafa (saw), but afterwards; 'so contend with me in this: we will see who is proven to die later [and who] dies first.' What an amazing word God made him write: 'I hold that the liar's rope is lengthened.' Now see how long the rope became. Hazrat Masih Mau‘ud (as) had also written: 'If you agree, publish it in your journal so that people may know.' From this it is clear that it was meant to be a mutual decision, not a one-sided matter. But he made it one-sided: 'That is not accepted, this is accepted, so we will see what decision comes.' And therefore [his rope] was lengthened so much that he died only after Partition. They hide the later part, show you the first part and say: 'He turned out a liar.' How can one argue with these poor people who hide half and reveal half? Anyone who wants to see his original newspaper, Ahl-e-Hadith, in which all this is stated – when you get the chance to come to Rabwah, the original newspapers are in the library there. You can also check in a library in Lahore, it may possibly be there too; but in the [Rabwah] library all the newspapers are still available today. If you do not trust our newspaper, it will show you [their] newspaper. Secondly: since that day the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat has been quoting that newspaper in its books, and to this day the scholars have not alleged that it is lying and that it was not written in the newspaper. This too proves that it was written and that he had accepted it.